5 ms·
If you sold futures for your outputs and didn’t buy futures for your inputs, the results are on you. These are the kind of complaints you get from people who m
by colechristensen 4y ago
If you sold futures for your outputs and didn’t buy futures for your inputs, the results are on you. These are the kind of complaints you get from people who make market bets and end up wrong. You can use futures like insurance to insulate yourself from market fluctuations or you can use them like a casino.
- DarylZero 4y agoYou're spinning it like a matter of choice, but I would doubt that it is. The farmers probably can't sell their product any other way than as futures; and can't buy energy any other way than at the current market price. That would mean the actual choice involved is just the choice to go into the farming business. Not exactly fair to compare that to casino betting.
- colechristensen 4y agoUntrue on both counts. Source: generational small farmer in exile.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoDoes that mean this market is missing an entity that helps farmers buy energy futures?
- colechristensen 4y agoIt isn’t though this person is just guessing incorrectly that it does not exist. Like any business buying supplies, farmers can buy things ahead of time at fixed prices.
- vkou 4y agoIn theory, you are correct. In practice, hedging for increases in fuel prices means buying something like oil futures. Which requires you to be at terminal at some port city 6 months down the line to physically collect the oil/gasoline/whatever that you bought. And then store it for the months before you use it.
- colechristensen 4y agoIt really doesn’t, you don’t buy fuel on the futures market, you buy it locally from the coop or whatever local purveyor you use for future delivery, hundreds of gallons at a time. The same for your other inputs, you have contacts to buy them well into the future, you don’t just pay the market rate when you need it.
- WalterBright 4y agoCommodities futures are just like gold based money. The gold itself wasn't traded, it sat locked in a vault somewhere. People traded receipts for the gold. I.e. that's what banknotes literally used to be.
- colechristensen 4y agoEh, while there is quite a lot of speculation-only trading, unless you're dealing with cash-settled futures, if you forget to close out your position you'll be expected to, say, deliver or take delivery on 5000 bushels of corn. Commodities futures are heavily used to arrange actual exchange of goods and aren't abstractions but real contracts.
- simtel20 4y agoThat is true right up until the day the contract comes due. Then you need to pick up your oil, pork, OJ, etc. at the time and place specified in the contract. If you holds the contract at that point in time, you are responsible for picking it up at the place in space.
- gruez 4y agoWhy can't you buy cash settled futures and/or liquidate before due for delivery?
- rfrey 4y agoWhy? Wouldn't a farmer just buy the futures contract (or an option on it), then liquidate and use the profit to offset the loss on the spot purchase? I was under the impression that hedgers never take delivery.
- deamanto 4y agoI actually have a very specific story on this one from a friend. In Australia, there's this stereotype of the "hard working Aussie battler farmer" and that we should all support our farmers. My friend's family business was one of these growing a type of nut. It was common for neighbouring farmers to make a good living selling their produce and using it for their own purposes and expect the government to bail them out with something like a tax break. My friend's business wanted to prepare for water shortages and spent a huge amount of money setting up a dam or storage system of sorts. Lo and behold, a drought came some time after and they were prepared. A lot of other businesses did not prepare for this and instead spent it on other things. My friend mentioned to me that he has no sympathy for those types of people. Disclaimer: This is a generic statement, I did not pry into the story and there could be a multitude of reasons why one didn't/couldn't prepare for such a thing
- somedangedname 4y agoYep. I'm from a region that grew sugarcane historically but is moving to tree crops like nuts. Local 'big name' family is voracious in their consumption of government grants. They're not struggling by any means but they've got application writing down to a fine science.
- Sylveste 4y agoGrants are for claiming. Why leave money on the table? Your competitors won't.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- biztos 4y ago> expect the government to bail them out … > A lot of other businesses did not prepare for this So did the government bail them out?
- deamanto 4y ago
- RustyConsul 4y agothat was my initial thought as well, but you are limited by the availability of financial instruments as you move up the chain to inputs. Outputs are easy to craft instruments around, but inputs are what a business is.
- colechristensen 4y agoInstead of financial instruments they are actual contracts for purchasing a commodity in the future from a local purveyor.
- simtel20 4y agoWithout a futures market, you don't get futures, you get forwards, don't you? Forwards don't have enforcement for when the seller goes bankrupt, which leaves the buyer out any money paid in the forward contract and needing to find another supply at market price. That's my understanding, at least.
- colechristensen 4y agoCalling them forwards implies that they are tradable securities. I’m talking about going to the local farmers coop and purchasing next years fertilizer, fuel, etc. months in advance for a set price to be paid and delivered in the future. When you sell your outputs it’s a good idea to buy your inputs at the same time. The outputs are often exchange traded commodities, the inputs are often contract purchases with local dealers although you can also hedge with appropriate exchange traded commodities.
- c_o_n_v_e_x 4y ago>Without a futures market, you don't get futures, you get forwards, don't you? Forwards don't have enforcement for when the seller goes bankrupt, which leaves the buyer out any money paid in the forward contract and needing to find another supply at market price. That's my understanding, at least. Correct. You have an over the counter market with different derivatives. > Forwards don't have enforcement for when the seller goes bankrupt, which leaves the buyer out any money paid in the forward contract and needing to find another supply at market price. That's my understanding, at least. You're referring to counter party risk. A futures exchange seeks to eliminate this type of risk with daily settlement of positions, margins, etc.