I hate to break up perfectly good hand-waving with numbers but I put together a test. On my Core i7 with an 18mb input, which is a large novel duplicated many t

I hate to break up perfectly good hand-waving with numbers but I put together a test. On my Core i7 with an 18mb input, which is a large novel duplicated many times, the performance factors, normalized to the if-based version are: if: 1x byte-based lookup: 0.83x int-based lookup: 0.84x bit-vector based lookup: 0.93x http://pastebin.com/5twfXfEt http://pastebin.com/5twfXfEt