5 ms·
I agree with BigTech completely. Dealing with different laws in each state would be a nightmare for any company. If there were one federal set of guidelines i
by scarface74 4y ago
I agree with BigTech completely. Dealing with different laws in each state would be a nightmare for any company.
If there were one federal set of guidelines it would be better.
But then again, the GDPR made a shit show of the web and made it less usable with cookie banners on every page.
- g_p 4y agoGDPR doesn't mandate cookie banners - that was actual other separate legislation (ePrivacy Directive). It provided a renewed focus and made more companies sit up and take note. Sites aren't required to have banners - the intention of the legislation was to encourage and nudge companies towards more straightforward business models, based around what users reasonably expect etc. You only need banners and consent where cookies are used for purposes the user didn't request (adding an item to a shopping basket doesn't require consent, but profiling a user and sharing that with third parties for retargeting isn't something reasonably expected, so it would require consent and disclosures of the companies involved).
- scarface74 4y agoThe road to hell is paved with good intentions. How did that work out for the end user?
- tjoff 4y agoPretty great actually. The good it has done for end users are immeasurable at the same time as the cost for shady companies is increasing. Going slow though, but that is hardly surprising (and the opposite would be alarming)
- scarface74 4y agoHow has it helped users? Two of the largest tech companies are adTech, tracking ads are still everywhere. All we got are cookie banners that are worse than the ads. Ads are much easier to block.
- tjoff 4y agoYou imagined google going bankrupt as a result of GDPR? It has given users tons of options regarding exporting and deleting data. Changed the defaults and limits use of personal data. These are all huge and goes way beyond internet. Users now have an ability to more easily see how their data is being abused and which companies are too greedy to not ruin their own websites. For the first time in a very long time there is hope. Then again, we have people who still believe GDPR is about banners, we have long ways to go but it is the first step in the right direction in forever and it is a huge step at that, we have barely started reacting to it.
- scarface74 4y agoHow many users are actually saying “we don’t want to use Google after we see all of the disclosures”? This “first step” has gone on for 8 years.
- tjoff 4y agoA lot. And google is being fined for it as well. Awareness is key and that takes time to gain attraction. But no, I don't have any numbers for it. You'd might consider having an open mind though. I'm for one is done with this "discussion".
- scarface74 4y agoAnd I’m sure you have numbers showing Google’s decline in usage since the GDPR or showing a shift from ad supported websites. I’m very willing to have an open mind when given facts and statistics with citations.
- ushakov 4y agoin Germany, Ecosia is a pretty popular choice it’s built-in on Safari actually
- scarface74 4y ago
- ushakov 4y agoshit show of the web are internet companies that show ads and track users across the web
- scarface74 4y agoDid the legislation make the consumer experience better or worse? Did it accomplish its goals?
- heretogetout 4y agoProbably better. A lot of sites chose to become worse, although they were already secretly/silently terrible.
- scarface74 4y agoCan you name any popular sites that became better? Did it help the user experience for any popular sites or did it make it worse?
- heretogetout 4y agoI don't know of specific sites that became better. Your premise is flawed, though, as the sites only became visibly worse because the site owners chose to do that. And now more people know how bad the web has become.
- ushakov 4y agoarguably better the users are now more aware of unethical business models and have more control over which third-parties can access data
- IMTDb 4y agoConsiderably worse Consumer end up clicking accept all on every single webpage, after the equivalent of an attention grabbing popup, something we were happy to see disappear when organisations ( and not governments ) decided to pretty much ban them from browser. What has improve my privacy: - Disabling third party cookies via a browser setting (than you Mozilla and Apple). I can understand why websites that I visit might put cookies on my computer. I am even Ok with them tracking me when I visit their websites, but I do not feel why the need to track me outside of their websites - Deprecating some api used for fingerprinting (thank you Mozilla and Apple). These API were not designed for those reasons, but where abused. What works here is technical expertise to maintain their general usefulness, while preventing the abuse. The various laws had close to 0 impact. - Apple private relay (thank you Apple), preventing even more tracking, again through *technical* means. Things that do not help : - Clicking a button on every single website I visit. I would love to be able to put a setting in my browser to tell what I feel is OK with regard to cookies, and have my browser handle those since cookies are managed by my browser anyway. But the law won't allow me to do that since consent must be "specific", meaning that I need to express my consent for every single domain I visit. Note that this makes private browsing almost unusable since I have to repeat "consent" again fr websites that I already visit quite often. This has *reduced* my global privacy. - Asking a website about my data. I did once for the lolz and never did it again. In my company, we get an average of one query every 3 month for thousands of daily users. But it justified some lawyer salary while we did a "project" out of it. So I guess it payed some suits guy a new BMW. As a citizen on the web, GDPR et al. have made my life worse, while Mozilla and Apple made mine better. As a professional, these law have directed a small part of my revenue to lawyers, but haven't changed a thing about what we were doing and how we were conduction our business. There are better use of taxpayer money.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoThey don't have to have banners, they only have to have them if they do user-hostile tracking. Unfortunately most sites have scummy business models and this just exposes them. It opened a market for untargeted ads again (based on the general interest of site visitors) which would never have happened if it was left to the market. Google is actively working against these untargeted ads because targeting is their #1 market advantage. Nobody has a bigger tracking network than them. But especially in Europe other players are taking off with them now.
- scarface74 4y agoSo how many users have said “okay I’m not going to use this website because I know how they use my data based on the cookie banner?” How many of these companies in Europe have even a fifth of Google’s ad revenue?
- gerash 4y agoNone-sense! If you have to blame 99% of the website (clothing, media, restaurants, ...) as being malicious in order to defend a piece of legislation then you're obviously wrong. I don't care about the intentions of the law. I care about the effects. No one is trying to update/fix the law within a feedback loop. It's a one time process.
- ad404b8a372f2b9 4y agoYou mean all websites that incorporate Google and Facebook trackers allowing those companies to know everything we buy, every piece of text we read, who we talk to, etc ... I don't find it obviously wrong to have a problem with this.
- stiray 4y agoSorry but you are wrong. GDPR doesnt mandate any cookie banners. You might be interested in this: https://noyb.eu/en/more-cookie-banners-go-second-wave-complaints-underway https://noyb.eu/en/more-cookie-banners-go-second-wave-compla... Actually NOYB has also provided website owners how to make cookie banners GDPR compliant: https://wecomply.noyb.eu/static/app/pdf/OneTrustGuide.0afba7b9c87d.pdf https://wecomply.noyb.eu/static/app/pdf/OneTrustGuide.0afba7...
- scarface74 4y agoSo now 270 websites just have more compliant irritating banners…
- stiray 4y agoWell, they don't need to. They just need to turn off the tracking of users and they don't need any banners. The problem is not in GDPR. The problem is in the website owners. They are the one who are trolling you with banners.
- scarface74 4y agoThey weren’t trolling me with the banners before the law. Now they are still tracking users and the user experience is worse.
- skinnymuch 4y agoWeird to blame regulation for how private entities act. Entities whose focus and goal are maximizing profits. I hope I don’t need to give citations for how the basics of our societies economic system works. Though I’m sure we can find “experts” at hundreds of think tanks simping for big business disagreeing.
- scarface74 4y agoLegislation forced private entities to act that way. They weren’t forced to make any substantial changes.
- ocdtrekkie 4y agoSo the point of cookie banners is malicious compliance. Annoying banners get people opposed to EU privacy laws, which is the true goal of the banners. When Facebook blocked news in Australia over a legal dispute, they "accidentally" blocked all sorts of other content. But it wasn't a mistake, it was intended to sabotage the privacy regulations' popularity, so people like you would call for it's removal. Craigslist didn't actually need to close personals when FOSTA was passed, but by doing so, they created a plausible claim for harm caused by a law that regulated them. When companies overreact to legislation in ways that negatively impact society, stop blaming the law, because that's entirely what the tech companies are trying to do. They're trying to turn you against the very lawmakers who are protecting you from them.
- scarface74 4y agoSo you mean the government passed a law without thinking through the unintended consequences…shocking! And you’re claiming that every website that chose to use cookie banners was doing so for political reasons? Do you think that is the simplest explanation - and not that a bunch of lawmakers were incompetent?
- ocdtrekkie 4y agoIt's not that I think laws were passed incompetently, but that they were watered down to get them passed. We should be hauling executives of Google and Facebook to jail, but we're still at the "make everyone notify users they're being abused" level.
- scarface74 4y agoEither way you cut, the legislation was ineffective and are you also going to haul in every mom and pop WordPress owner? Every blog site? You really want the government policing web content?
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 4y agoGDPR didn't make the shit show. Tech companies that rely on breaking the GDPR caused the shit show by choosing to simply ask for consent to violate it instead of changing their practices.
- scarface74 4y agoSo in other words the government law was ineffective at accomplishing its goals — all 11 chapters and 99 sections? https://gdpr-info.eu/ https://gdpr-info.eu/