3 ms·
Virtually 100% of cloud operating expenses are electricity, so you can pretty much assume that if it costs less it has a lower carbon footprint.
by jeffbee 4y ago
Virtually 100% of cloud operating expenses are electricity, so you can pretty much assume that if it costs less it has a lower carbon footprint.
- _joel 4y ago+ Rent, support staff, development costs, regulation and compliance, network, maintenance (cooling, fire suppression + lots more), marketing. Speaking as someone who did sys admin for a small independent cloud provider, it definitely isn't virtually 100% of operating costs
- jeffbee 4y agoNo offense intended to your personal experience, but I don't think "small independent cloud" is terribly important in the global analysis. This paper concludes that TDP and TCO have become the same thing, i.e. power is heat, power is opex. https://www.gwern.net/docs/ai/scaling/hardware/2021-jouppi.pdf https://www.gwern.net/docs/ai/scaling/hardware/2021-jouppi.p...
- ranman 4y agoOne key call out re: power from that paper - "Most OpEx cost is for provisioning power and not for electricity use [2], so saving power already provisioned for doesn’t improve TCO as much as one might hope."
- ranman 4y agoI'd peg it closer to 75%. There's some significant opex on the endpoint connectivity side as well. That's why a lot of these providers are buying stakes in some of the transoceanic cable projects (and some terrestrial ones as well). Or they're agreeing not to charge each other (kind of sort of- see open bandwidth alliance).
- mr_toad 4y agoDepreciation is an operating expense. Not a cash expense, but if you ignore depreciation you’ll end up like Detroit.
- jeffbee 4y agoThe paper I cited did not ignore depreciation.