3 ms·
Every time I read the term "security theater", I remember how frequent plane hijackings and bombings were pre-9/11.
by echelon 4y ago
Every time I read the term "security theater", I remember how frequent plane hijackings and bombings were pre-9/11.
- eesmith 4y agoSchneier's argument (in 2007, quoting https://www.schneier.com/news/archives/2007/08/everything_we_know_a.html https://www.schneier.com/news/archives/2007/08/everything_we...) was that: > “There have been exactly two things since 9/11 that have made air travel safer,” Schneier said recently over spring rolls at a favorite Vietnamese restaurant on Nicollet Avenue. “Reinforcing the cockpit door and telling people to fight back in the event of an attack.” After a brief pause, half-devoured roll in hand, he reconsidered. “Well, maybe three,” he said. “I’m on the fence about sky marshals.” Those two or three are not security theater, a term he uses for 'new measures that conveyed safety but accomplished little.' He gives an example of security theater - requiring people to throw out their cigarette lighters. When they could buy cigarette lighters once they pass through security. If those two or three things alone indeed caused the decrease in plane hijackings and bombings that you commented about, then the rest - dumping out water, taking shoes off, etc. - is very likely security theater.
- anamax 4y ago> requiring people to throw out their cigarette lighters. When they could buy cigarette lighters once they pass through security. I thought that the reason for banning outside cigarette lighters was that the TSA folk could not distinguish a lighter with "improved/better" fuel from one with ordinary fuel.
- eesmith 4y agoWhat would such an '"improved/better" fuel' be used for, where a regular lighter or matches (not banned) couldn't already be used? Add scrapings from a magnesium firestarter for a higher temperature. If there is something, why not put the fuel in a 3oz bottle instead of a lighter?
- altacc 4y agoThe significant increases in security were in place long before 9/11. There was a small increase in the effectiveness of security measures post 9/11 but it is difficult to measure the effectiveness of them as most of the attack vectors used post Lockerbie have had to be quite unusual to evade the existing security checks. Hijacking used to be common in the early days of commercial aviation and the airlines resisted the idea of security screening as it didn't fit the experience they wanted their customers to have. The occasional inconvenience of hijacking was a price they considered worth paying. That changed once the hijackers started killing people and planes were bombed mid-air.