11 ms·
Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work to derail data rules
- mc4ndr3 4y agoMarketing is easy. Tech is difficult. Politics often feels impossible.
- nobodyandproud 4y agoIn what way is tech difficult?
- bsedlm 4y agoin a collective way i.e. it's 'easy' for a individual (even a smallish similar group). But in society-scale? difficult.
- prophesi 4y agoI would say that's backwards. Sure, politics is slow, but we've seen it succeed exceptionally with aerospace safety (meaning planes built to protocol and maintained to prevent crashes, not TSA security theater) which is an insanely impressive global feat. Tech has the most impact on user privacy, but there's no financial incentive to uphold privacy and so the slow political stick is required. Meanwhile users can do their best installing ad blockers, navigate the snake-oil fields of VPN vendors, estrange themselves by quitting social media, set a different search engine on all their devices (which probably still use Google/Microsoft), maybe look into TOR and Whonix, ensure they use email masks and unique usernames for every service, buy Twilio numbers for account sign-ups, get their contacts to use E2E-encrypted messengers and PGP, get a dumbphone that doesn't have GPS enabled at all times, a laptop with camera/mic killswitches. It's not clear which of these steps are excessive or impractical for the layman, aside from ad/tracker blockers. So the tooling to uphold user privacy is there, but it's nuts to think the solution is for everyone to adopt better privacy-preserving habits rather than slowly killing the business model of the personalized ad industry. A great byproduct of this is that governments will see less surveillance tech vendors to buy from.
- nobodyandproud 4y ago> it's nuts to think the solution is for everyone to adopt better privacy-preserving habits rather than slowly killing the business model of the personalized ad industry. A great byproduct of this is that governments will see less surveillance tech vendors to buy from. Right to the heart. The personalized ad industry has exacerbated the issues of privacy, because it's in their interest to do so. Having enforceable ground rules in place, in the form of laws, will be difficult because of the money involved; and also the sizeable number of software engineers feeling like they're above the politics.
- nobodyandproud 4y agoIs that really about tech? I remember when both Intel’s CPU ID and Microsoft’s system updates (because it sent your info to their systems) caused an uproar. Now we don’t blink when talking about telemetry.
- notriddle 4y agoHow is this even a question? If you want E2E encryption, you sacrifice good full-text search, because you have to build the index on a computer that has access to the plaintext, which means doing it on an endpoint. It’s not as nice as doing it on the server. If you want to hide metadata, the state of the art is onion routing, and that adds a lot of latency. The only other way that’s even been attempted is Enclave computing, which basically just moves the trust from the service operator to the enclave vendor. Enclave computing is better than nothing, but it belongs in a defense-in-depth approach, not a privacy strategy in itself. And if you want to avoid fingerprinting, you lose responsive design. Those two things are just directly in conflict here.
- feanaro 4y ago> If you want E2E encryption, you sacrifice good full-text search, because you have to build the index on a computer that has access to the plaintext, which means doing it on an endpoint. It’s not as nice as doing it on the server. I'd argue it's better than on the server. Bring me back local computing, please. It's more private, more performant and more energy efficient. The attempt to centralize computing into central server nodes is not reasonable.
- nobodyandproud 4y agoI'd say it's probably the single most important question. Engineering is about trade-offs; understanding which trade-offs are acceptable means understanding what it is you're trying to solve; then assessing whether the problem is being looked at from the correct point-of-view (and for that matter whether it's even a technical one). For example: Journalists within hostile nations are risking their lives every day. Because of this, they're keen on keeping their communication private and away from prying eyes. So far, the compromises largely involve zero-days and social engineering. The former is really due to the shaky foundation of software today. Every single best practice I see is just awful. Whereas social engineering is an on-going problem and is a policy/procedural/cultural problem, not a technical one. The union of bad software and tolerant social protocols make privacy difficult. Going back to your objection: For use cases where your life is on the line, is a few seconds or even minutes of latency really a problem? Extend the question, for cases where it's not life-threatening but life-altering. What trade-offs are most users willing to make then? If you're not willing to make any trade-offs no matter what, then it's difficult or even impossible; and also a sign of a poor engineering process.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Overtonwindow 4y agoKind of the playbook for every company, do something before the government does it for you.
- BrianOnHN 4y agoDoes anyone know why I can't find the English version of this[1] Wikipedia page? Seems relevant. [1] https://de.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bummer https://de.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bummer
- mistrial9 4y agohttps://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/may/27/jaron-lanier-six-reasons-why-social-media-is-a-bummer https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/may/27/jaron-lan...
- pvg 4y agoBecause it mostly looks like book promo rather than something that needs a separate Wikipedia page. It's not a widely used term and should likely be tossed from German wikipedia as well. It would make sense in a page about the book or the author.
- treve 4y agoIt doesn't exist in English Wikipedia. If you find this weird, my guess is this acronym must have gotten more (mainstream?) attention in Germany (despite being in English). I've never heard of it and I don't think it's common where I am (Canada). Sometimes people coin terms and they get picked up in some places, but not others. When I lived in Germany and the Netherlands, it was often surprising to me which foreign terms/concepts/artists get elevated to mainstream relevance. There's a lot of imported culture from English speaking countries, but it's through a specific filter. Here's an English source from the article you shared though: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/may/27/jaron-lanier-six-reasons-why-social-media-is-a-bummer https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/may/27/jaron-lan...
- marban 4y agoOriginal Markup report: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31528823 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31528823
- scarface74 4y agoI agree with BigTech completely. Dealing with different laws in each state would be a nightmare for any company. If there were one federal set of guidelines it would be better. But then again, the GDPR made a shit show of the web and made it less usable with cookie banners on every page.
- g_p 4y agoGDPR doesn't mandate cookie banners - that was actual other separate legislation (ePrivacy Directive). It provided a renewed focus and made more companies sit up and take note. Sites aren't required to have banners - the intention of the legislation was to encourage and nudge companies towards more straightforward business models, based around what users reasonably expect etc. You only need banners and consent where cookies are used for purposes the user didn't request (adding an item to a shopping basket doesn't require consent, but profiling a user and sharing that with third parties for retargeting isn't something reasonably expected, so it would require consent and disclosures of the companies involved).
- scarface74 4y agoThe road to hell is paved with good intentions. How did that work out for the end user?
- tjoff 4y agoPretty great actually. The good it has done for end users are immeasurable at the same time as the cost for shady companies is increasing. Going slow though, but that is hardly surprising (and the opposite would be alarming)
- scarface74 4y agoHow has it helped users? Two of the largest tech companies are adTech, tracking ads are still everywhere. All we got are cookie banners that are worse than the ads. Ads are much easier to block.
- indymike 4y agoPrivacy regulations can make it very difficult for competitors to gain traction for incumbents, so there is active lobbying to get regulatory barriers to competition in play. At the same time, far too much money is being made to allow laws and regulations to kill revenues... so it gets complicated. The easy way is to just say you are all for privacy, and then oppose it at every turn. Another issue is this: breaking some of these privacy laws both in force and proposed, is really quite easy to do - as easy as a misconfigured logger or a developer including the wrong field in a query.
- thfuran 4y agoPlenty of existing laws take intent into consideration so its not unreasonable to suppose that a log that happens to accidentally contain some information that it shouldn't before being destroyed and the bug patched would be quite legally distinct from a log containing the same information but has a business unit processing and profiting from it.
- xyzzyz 4y agoIt is not unreasonable, I agree. However, the privacy laws passed by government are mostly intended to play performative and punitive role, and actual interest of the people in balancing their privacy and usability concerns are tertiary at best. The politicians pass those laws to look good on one side, and to attack the companies on the other. User concerns are mostly ignored.
- thfuran 4y ago>However, the privacy laws passed by government are mostly intended to play performative and punitive role Yeah, that seems to pretty well describe most all legislature these days.
- K0SM0S 4y ago> User concerns are mostly ignored. Indeed and I don't see how that changes _structurally_ when people "in the know" are always going to be a tiny minority — they say that about 3% of the population has the profile to work in tech, and I tend to agree anecdotally. I feel it's comparable to the inception of medicine for instance, and the solution was auto-regulation of the field by itself through the application of a loud (public and transparent) set of deontological rules of practice ("Primum non nocere", etc). Awareness of society about these issues re. privacy and information sanctity in a democracy will not come naturally, structurally as time goes by. Just like they don't really know how doctors make life-or-death decisions on the spot. Nevertheless, the right principles should eventually exist, be known, and abode to, by those who work in the field. It should be loud and clear that we all have ethics (rules, implementing guiding principles), and which exactly. A deontology of information technology and its practice in relation to human beings is one big "TODO" of this century, and it should concern anyone even remotely skilled to understand the problem.
- blocked_again 4y agoNo wonder newspapers are going bankrupt. Summarised such a complex topic in 12 words. And I can't even summarise my function refactoring changes in less than 20 words.
- onphonenow 4y ago
- omgwtfbyobbq 4y agoThe DOJ is investigating anti-trust violations, which are arguably unrelated to Apple offering more privacy for consumers.
- onphonenow 4y agoOf all the areas of "consumer harm" online my point is for some reason THIS issue with Apple is the key issue they are going after. My guess is this is actually a "business harm" case - ie, scum bags like Match / Facebook with disrupted businesses now doing some kind of alliance to stir the pot and get action (the law is for the rich not the poor). This is after Apple showed up the DOJ with app store rules that frankly should apply everywhere (ease of cancelation / clear subscription terms) as well as tracking rules, payment method rule and login rules that allow for lots more actual privacy and more. Of the entire internet, with its endless horrors beyond Apple's control, the DOJ has decided to go after a small green patch that users trust. This is more an indictment of the DOJ than anything. Apple's phone market share is small, but the trust / spending on apple are crazy because it's one of the few places online that doesn't just screw you over. And hey, I've tried to report online fraud issues for businesses I worked with - it's a total joke. The DOJ gives two craps for even totally obvious scams. Then all the scam calls
- spideymans 4y agoMatch Group has mentioned in their earnings how Apple’s restrictive polices are harming their earnings by making it easy for consumers to cancel subscriptions. Facebook has been screaming bloody murder over Apple’s regulations making it difficult for them to monetize user fare. These companies are not your friends, and don’t for a second believe that their push for more open regulations has anything to do with user “freedom”. These companies are only concerned about apple limiting their freedoms to prey on users. > Of the entire internet, with its endless horrors beyond Apple's control, the DOJ has decided to go after a small green patch that users trust. This is more an indictment of the DOJ than anything. Apple's phone market share is small, but the trust / spending on apple are crazy because it's one of the few places online that doesn't just screw you over. The fact that the most valuable consumers willingly lock themselves behind this walled garden, when there were and are plenty of open alternatives is a pretty glaring indictment of the state of the tech industry. Unfortunately predatory and user-hostile companies are the norm in our industry, and consumers have adjusted their spending habits accordingly.
- seydor 4y agoBut privacy regulation practically gave them their monopolies
- jeltz 4y agoHow? Their monopolies pre-date privacy regulation with actual teeth.
- Cypher 4y agoReal question is how do we get through post modernism.... I think part of the healing process is going to be accountability
- guerrilla 4y agoWhat is this comment supposed to mean? Postmodernism is a (nonsensical, imo) philosophical program. Do you mean postmodernity instead? In what sense?
- pessimizer 4y agoThe children of Glenn Beck use language in a strange way.
- stakkur 4y agoStill amazed daily at how many people eagerly line up to work at Facebook and Google, two companies engaged in mass fuckery with long-term harm to the entire population.
- mistrial9 4y agoone of those two did not start that way
- b112 4y agoNeither did.
- mistrial9 4y agoyou mean when I toured the new Facebook campus in California, with a data science group from Berkeley, and the Facebook guide stood on the stage and showed us on a thirty foot screen, that any one of us can make a map-reduce job in a certain format, Facebook will sell us info on any way to slice the hundreds of social tags and categories they had mined.. that was perfectly OK? I think the example the guide gave was "bowlers in the upper midwest" .. it was made clear that we could make a job submisison and be sold data on those people. Someone asked if law enforcement was a customer and the answer way "yes we do business with all branches of law enforcement".
- throwaway6093 4y agoThey don’t sell the data, they sell targeted ads.
- ocdtrekkie 4y agoThere's going to be a point where choosing to work at Google in 2020+ is going to be a black mark on your entire career. Nobody has the excuse of claiming they still don't know what's going on. If you work there, you chose to put profit over society. And at least in my hopes and dreams, someday that will cost you a job.
- Bud 4y agoYet another article where Apple gets recklessly tossed in and combined with the real bad actors in this field, even though the article then fails to cite even a single breach or privacy issue or anti-privacy stance taken by Apple. Worse, the article contains this complete lie: "All of the companies cited by The Markup – Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, and Microsoft – have dominant or emerging online ad businesses, which rely heavily on data collection." Nope. Apple does not have an "dominant or emerging online ad business". Apple has no ad business at all, let alone one that "relies heavily on data collection". Is it too much to ask to have some professional editors vetting these articles before publishing?
- Terretta 4y ago> Apple has no ad business at all… https://searchads.apple.com/ https://searchads.apple.com/ Understanding the ways this is different from, say, Google Ads, AdRoll, or TowerData, is nuance beyond most journalists. Not that it’s hard to research. Consider: Apple Search Ads doesn’t buy or share users’ personal information with other companies. We don’t track people by linking user or device data collected from Apple apps with user or device data collected from third parties for advertising targeting or measurement. And we don’t share user or device data with data brokers. — https://searchads.apple.com/privacy https://searchads.apple.com/privacy Pro-tip to journos: the story is in what comes immediately after “which rely heavily on data collection”. Data is collected. Then where does it go?
- cycomanic 4y agoSo that text doesn't say they are not using the data they collected for advertising targeting or measurement. They simply say they don't link the data with data collected from third parties for advertising. They are the only ad provider on iOS are they not? So the argument is, because they have a monopoly on their platform and don't share with anyone else they are vastly different? Or am I misunderstanding something?
- Terretta 4y agoI'm not sure if you're misunderstanding something. Definitely seem to be missing something. I didn't ask what's being done with the data. I asked where it goes. Do you think there's equivalence between selling user data to a marketplace of 4,700 third parties, and an internal machine-learning-sized A/B test? https://themarkup.org/ask-the-markup/2021/09/02/what-does-it-actually-mean-when-a-company-says-we-do-not-sell-your-data https://themarkup.org/ask-the-markup/2021/09/02/what-does-it... Or put another way: > So the argument is, because they ... don't share with anyone else they are vastly different? Yes.
- onetokeoverthe 4y ago
- moffkalast 4y agoCompanies lobbying to change laws in their favor? Well I never!
- bratwurst3000 4y agoI couldnt believe it either… they wouldnt …
- alaricus 4y agoYou needed a study for that?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- de6u99er 4y agoTime for the FTC to act and split ip those larg enterprises.
- gerash 4y agoGDPR and privacy laws so far: intentions: Holy! effects: annoyed consumers, legal maze for smaller companies, more job opportunities for lawyers
- guerrilla 4y agoYou forgot the other effect: privacy and control of our data.
- scarface74 4y agoWe have more privacy because of GDPR?
- guerrilla 4y agoYes, we do.
- scarface74 4y agoDid companies like Facebook ever say their business was impacted negatively by GDPR - no? But they were impacted by billions once Apple did one 10 line rule change strengthening privacy and pop up on apps. It didn’t take a 11 chapter 99 section law.
- guerrilla 4y agoThat's an interesting proxy for measurement for sure, but there are others. It rests on the assumption that all privacy improvements will cost Facebook significantly. I don't think that has been demonstrated to be fact. It seems that many will but also many won't. Apparently, just for example, being able to obtain and delete their data didn't effect them in the same way.
- fartcannon 4y agoHey everyone! Stop supporting these corporations. Our money and our labor is what allows these corporations to abuse us.
- kache_ 4y agoData regulation laws: introducing engineering constraints that only the big 5 have the engineering army to design & deal with :)
- cycomanic 4y agoThis is backward. You don't need an engineering army to _not_ collect private data. You do need an engineering army to collect private data and use it.
- scarface74 4y agoNo you just need an army of lawyers. Just like you need them to interpret the 11 chapter 99 section GDPR.