3 ms·
It seems overbroad in that some cities are doing fine, while in other, less trendy places, there actually are dying towns that these arguments could very well a
by skybrian 4y ago
It seems overbroad in that some cities are doing fine, while in other, less trendy places, there actually are dying towns that these arguments could very well apply to.
- Sharlin 4y agoThe article says "most cities". The majority of municipalities in the US and elsewhere are those less trendy places. It’s a case of availability bias to think of NY or LA or Seattle or Austin as representative of "most cities". The "towns" in Strong Towns gives an idea of the size range of the municipalities they are talking about.
- michael1999 4y agoPonzi schemes run fine as long as the growth continues. The challenge is running at steady-state, or even weathering declines. That’s when you see if full-cycle costs reconcile.
- tankenmate 4y agoTo quote Warren Buffet -- "Only when the tide goes out do you discover who's been swimming naked." That's one of the main points of Strong Towns; a focus on resiliency. Down turns in the economy, be it one oversized local sector (a local coal mine maybe) or all sectors (e.g. GFC), can be a trigger for a collapse; especially for a community that has focused all it's efficiency on that (those) sectors. If there's nothing left in the tank when the bad times come you only have one option left, collapse (and quite often a cascading collapse). Here's a term I just came up with; Sociological margin call.
- michael1999 4y agoThat's a nice vivid metaphor for financial types. Although margin calls usually trigger liquidation, while Tainter's model of catabolic collapse starts more like an orderly wind-down. Or maybe a private vulture buyout. The real liquidation happens later.
- actionablefiber 4y agoThe Strong Towns thesis is that there are a lot of ways for things to "look" fine when things are not actually fine. As an example, municipalities often count physical infrastructure like streets and water pipes as an asset on their books[1], even though it is illiquid and incurs large long-term liabilities. [1]https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2014/8/19/is-a-street-an-asset.html https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2014/8/19/is-a-street-an...