8 ms·
Ten years of Windows XP: how longevity became a curse
- pavel_lishin 15y agoThat was a lot of paragraphs to say, "Despite being pretty great for its time, Windows XP is pretty outdated, and somewhat annoying to deal with."
- yuhong 15y agoXP is still common enough that I wonder how many enterprises will opt for custom support in 2014 (costs $200,000 for first year, more every year after).
- pavel_lishin 15y agoDepends on how much upgrading would cost, right? Enterprise-wide licenses, plus the cost of upgrading (downtime, overtime for IT staff, training for users, etc.) It might make sense to shell out $200k/year for a few years, while gradually rolling out upgrades to more recent versions.
- yuhong 15y agoNote that $200k/year is for the first year. The price of Custom Support generally increases every year, with the pricing generally disclosed 3 years in advance.
- hvs 15y agoFun note, OS/2 Warp 4 support was discontinued on December 31st, 2006; ten years after its release.
- yuhong 15y agoAnother fun note: MS rounds the end of support date to the nearest quarter. I still remember when extended support for XP was to end at the end of year 2008.
- ck2 15y agoI'm a happy XP user. XP fits into 1GB and is very very fast. Windows7 takes 10GB and grows exponentially as it keeps two copies of almost every system file that cannot be deleted.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- recoiledsnake 15y agoHow much does 10GB of HDD space cost these days? I would rather have the OS be able to recover from corruption or deletions than save 5 bucks or something.
- gwern 15y ago5 bucks is way too high. The cheapest drive with 4 eggs on http://forre.st/storage#hdd http://forre.st/storage#hdd is is 23gb/$; 10/23 * 100 or 43 cents.
- qjz 15y agoSpace on a hard drive is finite, no matter how much it costs, and the size requirement makes it particularly unattractive for running in a VM, compared to a leaner OS.
- zedpm 15y agoI run only SSD in my desktop and I was running out of space for VMs. I decided to move a VM to my NAS and I discovered, happily, that it runs great on the NAS, connected over Gig-E. I moved the rest of my VMs over there and I really don't notice a difference in performance.
- viraptor 15y agoToo much if you want a one off install like I did this week. When you want a quick VM and one app, why waste more space/time? I know this is not a common usecase, but I was actually wondering - when most apps won't run on XP anymore - what is the minimal-windows going to be? Also, not sure what you mean by recovering from deletion... How could any system recover from that?
- markkat 15y agoI was using XP until my Lenovo died this weekend. I pulled Vista off of it pretty quick. I suppose I'll be moving on to 7 now. :)
- Alpocan 15y agoI'm still on XP because there is no clear choice for an upgrade path. I have a pile of business, programming, and electrical engineering applications that work well on XP and maybe fine on Windows 7. I don't like the bloat, interface, and locked-down nature of Win7. But do I wait for Win8? Or maybe try some Linux flavour and run XP/7/8 in a VM? It's really not an easy choice. Larger enterprises must hate this.
- wvenable 15y agoHave you actually seriously tried Windows 7? I couldn't stand Vista, but Win7 is a worthy successor to XP. It's faster, more memory efficient, and more stable. I've done my fair share of tweaking to make it more XP-like but many of changes are improvements. Most businesses I work with are now moving to Windows 7 after skipping Vista entirely.
- dmpk2k 15y agoFaster and more efficient than what? They've been saying this every single release since at least as far back as Windows 95. Strangely enough, Windows 3.1 sure seems a lot smaller and snappier than Windows 7...
- TruthElixirX 15y agoSeven is faster and more efficient than Vista. I have it running (with Aero off) on a 6 year old Thinkpad. It workss great, just as well as XP. I also used Vista for 3 years, and recently moved to 7. It boots much quicker and uses less resources on a consistent basis. Of course I realize that the plural of anecdote is not data but I haven't heard anyone contradict what I said.
- megablast 15y agoFaster than Vista? High praise indeed. Vista is what drove me to Mac OS, Windows 7 does not seem like much of an improvement in my limited testing. I hated the fact that Microsoft would just move everything around for no good reason, so I had to relearn to do everything I could do in XP. I managed with Dos v3.3 -> XP.
- nobody3141 15y agoSo 10years of R+D from the foremost manufacturer of PC operating systems has produced ...... Hardware accelerated transparency effects on the desktop (if you're lucky and not on an Intel chipset) Just think what the next 10years might bring - multicolored keyboard CAPSLOCK lights?
- to3m 15y agoI suspect a lot of the R&D goes into making sure that people can make this sort of "is that all" type comment without looking ridiculous :) Perhaps if Windows 8 were to break all your old apps, and look utterly radically different, then people might find it easier to believe that it was genuinely something new? Maybe that could work.
- nobody3141 15y agoHey the new 2012 Oldsmobiles are in! And not only are they new and improved in ways you can't actually detect - but they are guaranteed compatible with your current gas.
- brisance 15y agoTell that to the iPhone 5 prognosticators.
- mappu 15y agoI realise i'm missing the point here, but I have an Intel GMA950, and it runs Aero flawlessly. Windows 8 is introducing ubiquitous DWM compositing regardless of hardware.
- m0nastic 15y agoWe still standardize on XP on the corporate images at my work (where we have more employees than many cities have residents), and are just now starting to even consider running a trial build of Windows 7. We had to skip over Vista completely, as a year after it was released there were still loads of applications that didn't work on it (including our VPN software, which boggles the mind as it's not exactly like Vista was a surprise). We had a few security applications we use day-to-day that prevented us from even installing XP Service Pack 2, as the changes to the raw socket support broke them. Were it not for Microsoft preventing newer versions of IE from being installed, I think we'd probably stay on XP forever.
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoWhat software specifically stopped working (and are you aware of why)? Have you researched alternatives?
- m0nastic 15y agoIf you're referring to our VPN software, the version distributed by the vendor would crash upon initialization every time for a good year after Vista was released. I presume they eventually released a version that was stable, but my company had already decided to skip Vista by that point. As to the applications which wouldn't work with XP SP2, WebInspect was a specific one (they eventually fixed it), but I recall there were a few others (basically any scanner that used raw sockets). As to researching alternatives, I don't work in IT at my company, but if you're testing out a new version of the operating system that you deploy to all of your employees, and the VPN client doesn't work, you don't research alternative VPN solutions. You just decide to hold off on upgrading several hundred thousand systems until everything works.
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoI'm afraid I don't understand; why don't you research alternatives? Is it a training thing?
- testz3453 15y agoI will use Windows XP for another 5 years - until new software and hardware will stop working on XP. Windows 7 GUI is 5 times slower than XP and has bugs: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ay-gqx18UTM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ay-gqx18UTM (Windows 7 GUI slowness) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ToFgYylqP_U http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ToFgYylqP_U (Windows 7 GUI slowness: file explorer) Windows 7 uses 5 times as much resources: XP: 233MHz, 64MB RAM, 1.5 GB. 7: 1GHz, 1GB RAM, 16 GB.
- redthrowaway 15y ago1 GHz, 1 GB RAM, and 16 GB HD are micenuts. You couldn't buy less than that if you tried. Hell, you could run it on a phone. Windows 7 is faster and much, much nicer on any computer made in the last 2-3 years. I'm not a Windows fan by any means, but choosing to run XP over 7 in 2011 is incomprehensible.
- redthrowaway 15y agoOne minor note: " Direct3D 10, for example, only supports Windows Vista and Windows 7; it's not available on Windows XP. The continued widespread usage of the old operating system makes it much harder for developers to depend on these new features: every time they do, they rule out the ability to sell to half of all current Windows users, and that's a bitter pill to swallow." How many devs who would like to use the features offered in D3D 10 but not 9 are realistically going to be selling to people running XP? An outdated OS with outdated hardware and users who are behind the curve on upgrades does not seem to be a market that people implementing rich graphical features would be targeting.
- coffeeaddicted 15y agoI guess the best available survey for hardware used by gamers is from steam (http://store.steampowered.com/hwsurvey/?platform=pc http://store.steampowered.com/hwsurvey/?platform=pc). Around 20% are using XP there - still a hard decision if you want to ignore a fifth of your potential customers.
- redthrowaway 15y agoSteam's a bit weird, as it has a lot of games that run on lower-spec systems. Your point's a valid one, but I think Steam might be a bit of an oddity.
- Gormo 15y agoGamers are particularly reluctant to 'upgrade' to new versions of Windows, especially where there are major overhauls to the driver layer or DirextX. Doing so could break comptatibility with their existing library of games, or prevent hardware from working properly. SLI wasn't even supported under Vista for ~4 months after launch, for example.
- Androsynth 15y agoWin7 feels like aliens came down to Earth and decided to rebuild their own version of OS X. They know nothing about human user interfaces and they are just kinda putting all the pieces together. In the end, all the pieces are there, and if you look at it superficially it looks good, but once you really get into it, it feels like bizarro usability. Just to give you an example of some things that make no sense: -shaking windows minimizes everything -moving the window to the top of the screen maximizes it (its easier for me to just click the box in the corner, and now I can't place windows across the top edge) -window explorer went from a couple large buttons to a ton of small buttons -the clickable area of a directory in windows explorer in list view is about half the size, making it very difficult to right click a directory unless its already selected (something done a lot with tortoise svn) -control settings has become so complex its almost unusable I won't go on, I know from experience that you either vehemently agree or vehemently disagree. edit: I should add: I used XP for 10 years then switched over to win7 last year. I am not a mac or linux fanboy. I recently switch to osx full time at home, and use XP to play games. I could not be happier with that setup.
- dmfdmf 15y ago> Windows XP needs to be not only the first ten-year operating system; it also needs to be the last. I disagree with this. I agree ten years is a long life for an OS now but sometime in the future that won't be true. The point is that the OS is a platform that should be stable and supported for years, if not decades. At some point the underlying technology and operation principles of an OS will plateau or reach diminished returns and a new OS will not be needed or just not worth the trouble. Fast tracking OS releases today is really bad for all (except MS which is why they do it). Vista came out 5 years after XP but it was not ready for prime time. Win7 came out 3 years after Vista and Win8 is slated for 3 years after the release of Win7. This 3 year OS cycle is insanity. One reason no one wanted to give up XP was because it worked, it was reasonably stable and no one wanted the pain and cost of moving to a new OS with all the inevitable driver and app problems. I'd bet that most of the new "features" of Win8 are really improved apps that would work fine on Win7 or completely unnecessary. Sell new features in the old OS but make them standard in the new OS and release the new OS on approximately 5 year (and eventually longer) cycles when the fundamental functions of the OS need to change to improve security, efficiency or operation, not because MS needs revenue. Win7 is a good OS, a worthy successor to XP, but we aren't even out of the Win7 adoption period (by users, hardware manufactures and ISV's) and we are suppose accept Win8 and stir the whole pot again? I suspect that Win8 is going to have the same marketing problem that (in part) submarined Vista. People don't care about Operating Systems, they run them to run Applications.
- rkudeshi 15y agoI think OS X does this right. Every Windows upgrade feels like a brand new operating system. In contrast, every new OS X release feels more like an iterative update. In a sense, OS X has been your ten year operating system, just with rolling updates.