6 ms·
A tool to render and upscale Sierra adventure game background images
- joshspankit 4y agoAs others have mentioned the upscaling changes the design a bit, but I’m not mad at it. It’s like it’s from an alternate reality where Sierra went for a cartoony vibe and I feel like there were at least a few people in Sierra who would have liked to work on cartoony games.
- nivekastoreth 4y agoI’m not sure what it is, but except for the spaceship image, the upscaled images look… flatter? I don’t have any attachment to these games (or pixel games in general), so it’s not a nostalgia thing, but I also can’t explain it. It feels very weird. I also can’t tell why I like the upscaled space ship, but perhaps it’s because I expect those shapes to be smooth. I think I may also be trying very hard to not use the word “mobile” here, but I have to admit it was the first thing that came to mind. [edit: to be clear I’m not trying to say anything at all about the tech here, this was written entirely out of bafflement trying to understand my reaction to the images]
- boldo 4y agoMaybe it’s because the line width appears thinner than in the originals and appears to have been used to contribute to the shading of the image.
- nivekastoreth 4y agoI think this may be the key point, at least for what was befuddling me. Looking at the right side of the castle, the old image has a clear sense of depth while the upscaled version doesn’t
- pvg 4y agoThe medium is so constrained the artists had little choice but to try to squeeze the most out of it for expressive ends and it dictated some of the stylistic choices. I think this sort of upscaling tends to throw that out and it's most eyepokey in static images like these. Some of the upscalers work pretty well (depending on taste) in motion, most emulators include a bunch of different ones.
- bradbeattie 4y agohttps://www.superrune.com/tutorials/loom_ega.php https://www.superrune.com/tutorials/loom_ega.php might be of interest.
- CamelRocketFish 4y agoFascinating comparisons, thanks for sharing it.
- whywhywhywhy 4y agoMight be biased because I grew up with the Amiga version, but the game looks so much better and has the right atmosphere in the lower color palette.
- BizarroLand 4y agoI'm split, I've not played the game so I only have the images provided to go off of, but for many of the photos, the old version looks massively better, much more artistic and evocative, but then for some of the images, like the crystals in Crystalgard, the new ones look so much better. If I had to pick, I would probably choose the older version, but for the outdoor areas, and dungeons, and character portraits the new ones are visually miles ahead.
- nope96 4y agoFeels somewhat like Prodigy vector art. (Mad Maze!)
- Reason077 4y agoIt would be neat if this upscaling tech could be built in to ScummVM so that those old sierra games could be (optionally) played with upscaled graphics!
- ricardobeat 4y agoDay of The Tentacle has upscaling available, and it doesn’t do justice to the game art. The best way to play these is with a CRT emulator.
- Jolter 4y agoFrom a brief glance at it, this tool seems to make high resolution renders of the vector based art in the game files. There is no “upscaling” because the art was drawn as points, lines, fills, etc to begin with. The reason it looks pixelated is because it was rendered onto a (very) low res screen.
- Reason077 4y agoSo these old adventure games had their art stored in a vector format this whole time and we’ve just been rendering it blocky and pixelated to preserve authenticity?
- mseepgood 4y agoYes, there's a video by the author of this tool that explains it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sclZDCjUVvI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sclZDCjUVvI
- pvg 4y agoSomeone should type this up and submit a summary as a PR since it answers just about all the obvious questions that come to mind (and thread) from the README.
- pvg 4y agoIn these particular ones, the lines-and-fills format is for compression, not resolution-independent fidelity. You couldn't fit a game's worth of backgrounds on a few-hundred-k floppy as bitmaps.
- Jolter 4y agoYou could say that. The Sierra games were a bit revolutionary in using vector graphics for the backgrounds. It meant they could fit dozens of full-color game screens on a single Apple II floppy disk, which was no small feat. Of course, since the files were drawn to be rendered on a low-resolution screen, the file format only allows for that same low resolution in the storage format. I e your X and Y coordinates in the file correspond to on-screen pixel coordinates.
- gernb 4y agoThis is very cool. I wonder what they'd look like fed to ML and asked to stylize (photo realistic, 1995 CGI, anime, ...)
- djmips 4y agoI feel like ML would have a better chance at producing a better interpretation. But training would be challenge. I guess the best bet would be a human artist. They should do the best but there would be no unanimous agreement.
- causality0 4y agoI dunno, it's pretty clear from the examples that the vector files were created with the intention of being displayed at low resolution and the high-res versions are mutilating some of the effects. For example, the skeleton's teeth and the curve on the satellite dish look right at low res but look like they were drawn by an incompetent at high res.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoIt looks to me like the data relies on the images using a minimum stroke width relative to the size of the rendered image. All of them display areas of white where there is no image data, because increasing the resolution caused pixels to appear in the space between strokes that, at the original resolution, were less than a pixel apart. Stated another way, the images are full of shapes that should have color fills, but instead they're just strokes that are guaranteed to be so fat that a fill would be redundant. You also don't need to define every edge of a shape - you can define top and bottom and just let the fat strokes implicitly define left and right edges.
- richard_todd 4y agoYeah, exactly. The other big factor is that the lines are vector but the flood fills are pixel-based, so accuracy depends very much on the width of the lines---and even the rasterization algorithm used for the lines. Add to this the issue you brought up about thick pixelated lines making many fills redundant, and you have a pretty good idea about why automated upscaling of these games will never be very satisfying. Also, the sprites in the games are not vector art, and the games depend on the sprites covering exact areas of the background imagery.
- Moru 4y agoI'm no Krita [1] expert but I have played a bit with this and it works pretty well. Maybe some similar method would work to fill in the colors. [1] https://docs.krita.org/en/tutorials/flat-coloring.html#colorize-mask https://docs.krita.org/en/tutorials/flat-coloring.html#color...
- 1wd 4y ago"EGA to VGA transformation" like it was done for games like Indy3 would be nice. http://www.superrune.com/tutorials/indy3_ega.php http://www.superrune.com/tutorials/indy3_ega.php (Even though some people still prefer the EGA version.)
- loudandskittish 4y agoIs it just me or do the "up-scaled" versions look more like a child's MS-Paint drawing?
- mseepgood 4y agoTo be honest, Sierra games always looked like a child's MSPaint drawings to me. Even Maniac Mansion, which had to work with comparable technical limitations, looked more sophisticated.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pavlov 4y agoWhat game is the skeleton image from? It’s tremendously better as a painting than Sierra’s usual standard for these AGI games. I recall the Manhunter games used AGI for some really impressive graphics (for 1988/89 anyway). Those games used lots of closeups and other cinematic angles which was also very unusual compared to Sierra’s usual flat third-person aesthetic. Maybe that’s where the skulls are from?
- iv42 4y agoYep, it's from the first one. Manhunter: New York.
- aliswe 4y agoWhy not 2xSAI or similar existing algorithms?
- Dwedit 4y agoThis is operating on the original vector data rather than the raster data you get from rendering the originals.