3 ms·
To put some numbers on their costs, one Soyuz launch is about $40-50 million. A falcon 9 is probably a bit more expensive - Soyuz rockets are extremely cheap d
by pclmulqdq 4y ago
To put some numbers on their costs, one Soyuz launch is about $40-50 million. A falcon 9 is probably a bit more expensive - Soyuz rockets are extremely cheap despite not being reusable. If the launches are dedicated solely to Starlink and not sharing significant payload space, that is about $200 million in expenses for the year.
Assuming a 5 year working life before the satellites de-orbit, the satellites launched this year have $40 million of depreciation. Other satellites have likely been launched as well and are depreciating in orbit.
That suggests that Starlink needs about 2-4x the paying customer base as today (depending on working life of satellites and launch costs, etc.) to break even.
That's a lot better than I was expecting.
Edit - someone pointed out that the $44M figure was monthly, not annual. In that case, it might be profitable. Also, I am aware of all of the "reusable" arguments, but a SpaceX launch still retails for $67M, while a Soyuz launch is still a lot cheaper at retail. This includes the cost factors of re-usability. Most of the cost of a rocket launch is fuel, not the metal tube.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoWait. If the satellites cost $200M to launch, and they make $44M per month - why do they need 4x more customers to break even? Unless I'm missing something the 5-year unit economics look outstanding already.
- walrus01 4y agotheir calculation may be based on the need to continually replace the satellites because their low orbits and relatively limited ion thruster fuel supply means each satellite has an expected 4-5 year service life.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y ago$44M * 12 * 4 = $2112M (revenue). The supposed cost to launch these was only $200M according to GP. So I'm wondering - why do they need to make 4x as much money ($8B) to make a profit in a $200M investment? Obviously R&D. But is it that much?!
- ben_w 4y agoI think $200M was just the launches this month, not all launches to date or all needed to compete the constellation. If it really costs SpaceX $40-50M per launch, the 47 launches to date cost $1880-2350 billion. I don’t know how many now launches they need before they switch to just replacements.
- mlyle 4y ago$44M/mo revenue from his estimate is $528m/year; your estimates support, say, $150m depreciation per year. And there's significant operating costs. IMO the biggest remaining factor is how long it takes to breakeven on the terminal hardware. While it's sold to end-users, it's a significant loss-leader (perhaps $2k of subsidy at this point).
- toomuchtodo 4y agoTerminals cost SpaceX $1500, breakeven is under a year considering the upfront cost to the user. Profitability will be determined by how many turns a Falcon 9 can make during its service life and if Starship can replace it fast enough (further driving down cost per kg to orbit). Everything else is mostly a fixed cost (ops, perpetual depreciation to account for satellite replacement on a cadence, etc).
- mlyle 4y ago> Everything else is mostly a fixed cost I disagree. They have all the normal variable ISP cost structures, too. They need to scale uplinks and the size of the constellation linearly with the number of subscribers they allow in an area, etc. IMO, what it will really come down to is how big the market is. Terrestrial infrastructure, including fixed wireless, should win most places-- it's a question of where the mobility benefits and/or population density make it viable, and how distributed these places are over the globe.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoUplinks and the huts for their gear, while a cost, are not exorbitantly expensive (and likely solved for long term with laser links between satellites for load balancing downlink across the constellation versus the current suboptimal bent pipe operating model). SpaceX has both US military and commercial airliners testing their service; the TAM is enormous for high speed global internet connectivity. Terrestrial service is ancillary revenue in markets where there is lower utilization (the same way T-Mobile offers home internet with no cap at lowest prioritization on their network to monetize their over investment in 5G). (disclosure: StarLink customer and SpaceX investor)
- Reason077 4y agoSpaceX's published list price for a Falcon 9 launch in 2022-2023 is $67 million, with "discounts available for contractually committed multi-launch purchases". https://www.spacex.com/media/Capabilities&Services.pdf https://www.spacex.com/media/Capabilities&Services.pdf
- bombcar 4y agoFirst off - I can’t find pricing on half the $1k enterprise software shit and spacex has rocket launcher prices on their website without a “email to ask” button? Second, that’s the customer price - I suspect SpaceX has a lower cost especially if they’re reusing stages.
- samstave 4y agoSurely you don't think that a company that has a contract to service the ISS also would likely have a number of high-value government contracts around the globe, and certainly inclusive (or even exclusive to the DoD/USD... Imagine all the surveillance the NSA can harvest simply from the use of all the starlinks given to Ukraine... We talked about the likelihood of cyber-attacks rising with the Ukraine conflict, and a part of cyberwarfare is going to be a portion of surveillance... Starlink creates a global network for providing service to anywhere on the planet. So if you have a device that uses starlink, there is not a single place on the globe where you cannot be tracked actively via starlink. I think its insane that we don't have open convos about this here on HN with a critical eye. And this is why they didnt name it SkyNet :-)
- modeless 4y agoI mean, it's an ISP. Any ISP you use can track you. Your cell provider can track you globally if you use international roaming. This is not novel. > So if you have a device that uses starlink, there is not a single place on the globe where you cannot be tracked actively via starlink. This makes it sound like Starlink is going to be built into your phone. Starlink is a satellite dish, it's the size of a medium pizza and consumes 60+ watts continuously in operation. It's not like you're going to accidentally leave it in your pocket or something.
- walrus01 4y agoWait until this guy learns that all iridium handsets also report their position when used. For the last 22 years.
- samstave 4y agoI know all this JEASUS. Iridium was out of the price range of the averwage bear. With family in Alaska, we've them for a LONG time in my family. My point is that as SkyNet eveolves - its going to provide defacto global coverage for even the poorest regions. Even Musk himself said that large swaths of africa will see early value. This IMPLIES that they are intending to poc-mark the globe with enough cells... Moonshot idea.
- jmyeet 4y agoStarlink launches are costing nowhere near that. First, you're ignoring reuse. They may not discount external customers for this (or they might, I honestly don't know but $67m doesn't reflect that regardless) but they are of course getting that cost reduction themselves. Second, SpaceX is creating demand for reusable first stages and proving their reliability through Starlink so it can afford to be a loss leader. Third, a big cost in satellite launches in insurance costs. Launches can fail so insurance costs are really high. That's not really an issue for SpaceX because the Starlink satellites are cheap and replaceable. There's really no need to insure them at all. If a launch fails, that's fine. Just launch another one. it's cheaper than paying the insurance premiums.
- mlyle 4y ago> Starlink launches are costing nowhere near that. [citation needed] > First, you're ignoring reuse. SpaceX charges $67m for a Falcon 9 launch. They have some margin, of course. > They may not discount external customers for this They did reduce prices when reuse became viable. > Third, a big cost in satellite launches in insurance costs. Launches can fail so insurance costs are really high. Insurance isn't included in the $67M figure. SpaceX has self-insured, so, when the Feb 2022 batch failed, that was a launch and set of satlelites that was paid for that did not enlarge the constellation. Finally, the satellites themselves surely cost something.
- tuatoru 4y ago> SpaceX charges $67m for a Falcon 9 launch. That's the price, not the cost. They only need to reduce price a bit below their competitors' in order to get the price-sensitive business. That price tells us only that their cost per launch is below $67M, not how far below that it is. We won't get a good idea of cost until someone else can do 10x reusable rockets of similar capacity I don't think launch costs can be below $5M on a fully amortised Falcon 9. There're the expended upper stage and fairing, NASA/FAA admin and facility charges, and ground crew. And fuel, which is pretty much a small item in the "miscellanous" budget category. The satellites have been guesstimated at $300K each. SpaceX is trying very hard to reduce their cost, whatever it is. Remember that they want to make about 10,000 of them per year, so think in terms of car-making rather than legacy satellite construction.
- elteto 4y ago$200 million seems high. That is the price for a brand new ride, no? According to this [0] 3 of the last 4 launches were refurbished first stage cores so the actual price is much, much lower than the sticker price. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Starlink_launches https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Starlink_launches
- modeless 4y agoRetail price of a Falcon 9 launch on a newly built booster is $67m. I doubt that it costs them $40m for one Starlink launch when they are now reusing those boosters 12 times each with 21 days turnaround. Also there are a lot of benefits to SpaceX of being their own customer. The increased launch cadence makes everything more routine and reliable, benefiting their other customers. But the most important thing is that they can try things that third party customers may not want to risk, like pushing reuse to the max, or being the first customer for Starship. F9 numbers are moot, really, because the previous launches are a sunk cost and won't be an ongoing expense. The ongoing expense will shift to Starship launches to launch and maintain V2 of the constellation, and costs per pound will drop dramatically if things go as planned, though the constellation will also be a lot larger.
- robbiep 4y agoYou’ve missed out a lot of numbers here. Soyuz is a bad example because it doesn’t matter how ‘cheap’ it is, it isn’t reusable. If they can built a second stage for $13m, $2m for fuel and refurb (musk has previously said marginal cost for a relaunch is $15m) you’ve got marginal costs per terminal assuming 50 per launch of $300k, and terminals are somewhere between 250-500k (Shotwell said in 2019 they were below 500k ‘already’). So I’m going to go with 600k cost to orbit for a single satellite. There’s ~2,400 in orbit currently, so rough capital outlay so far is $1.44Bn Income at 528M means they’re closing hard on some sort of model but yea that 2-4x figure looks good-ish
- jws 4y agoDid we skip launches per month and launches per year here? The post says ”…four starlink launches all with successful first stage landing just in the month of May” then the parent goes to $50M/launch -> $200M/year. I don’t think you can analyze the cost as a steady state since to constellation is growing rapidly. But to consider a snapshot of the current constellation… There are about 2200 Starlink satellites in orbit, generating $44M/month in revenue and lasting 5 years. That suggests the need to replace 440 satellites per year, or 8.3 launches of 53 satellites per year for $415M/year (at $50/launch) or $35M/month. That’s just launch costs, so not a lot left over for everything else, so probably not profitable at this time. But it doesn’t need to be. It needs to get all the pieces in place so Starship launched next generation satellites have a big enough customer base to make that business work.
- rifty 4y agoI know this isn't the main point of your exercise but a reusable Falcon 9 puts double the payload mass to LEO over a Soyuz. So despite a greater retail cost to launch, its retail payload mass cost to orbit is definitely cheaper. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_orbital_launch_systems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_orbital_launch_s...
- Fatnino 4y agoSoyuz can put ~7000kg in low earth orbit. Falcon 9 can put ~22000kg into the same. Falcon 9's $67m price per launch is just what SpaceX charges. They need to undercut the rest of the market but once they get below everyone else's cost per kg there is absolutely no reason for them to charge less until there is real competition someday. What I'm saying is that for SpaceX themselves it costs much less than $67m per launch. And the comparison to soyuz is a joke. Even ignoring that you can't get a soyuz launch anymore since about 3 months ago. Western payloads in Baikonur were taken hostage / outright stolen, and new rockets are not being shipped to French Guiana.