4 ms·
This has been orthodox economic policy for decades. There's two usual prongs: - put up interest rates. This raises the cost of business credit, and at the marg
by pjc50 4y ago
This has been orthodox economic policy for decades. There's two usual prongs:
- put up interest rates. This raises the cost of business credit, and at the margin, puts people out of work, until employment reaches the "non-accelerating rate" (NAIRU)
- break labour power by legislating against unions, breaking up state-owned businesses into the private sector, and promoting the Uber-style "independent contractor" model where people aren't employees
The public may be exposed to rising food and fuel costs, but if they can't demand higher wages that can't feed forward into higher prices and a wage-price spiral.
Yes, this involves a lot of worsening of living conditions.
- arcticbull 4y agoI agree with you broadly. I think it's important to consider though that what we have right now isn't a demand crisis but a supply shortage. There are, thanks to all sorts of reasons (the fallout of COVID lockdowns from 2020-2021, supply chains, war in Ukraine between an oil exporter and a grain exporter, COVID zero in China) not enough things available for everyone to buy. The amount of money folks have and are being paid - and are demanding at new jobs - cannot turn into the same quantity of goods now as it would have two years ago. Hence rising prices. One of two things can happen: - We can increase supply of goods, fix supply chains, infrastructure, bring in more labor, etc. - We can decrease demand by reducing the amount of money in the system (increase interest rates, reduce wages). But like, one or both of these things have to continue to happen until the demand for goods and services matches the available supply of goods and services. Yes, this may lead to worsening conditions but that's because we don't have enough stuff for everyone to get what they want right now.
- ItsMonkk 4y agoIt's mostly a demand shock, not a supply shock[0]. The supply chains are busted mostly because of unprecedented demands. But considering that most normal people spend just about all of their money each month, and with personal savings rates below where they were before CO-VID and credit levels rising, either inflation ends by itself or the demand as it turns out, is coming from the wealthy looking to shelter their cash in safe commodities during the recession and away from bubbled assets. [0]: https://www.bridgewater.com/its-mostly-a-demand-shock-not-a-supply-shock-and-its-everywhere https://www.bridgewater.com/its-mostly-a-demand-shock-not-a-...
- 7speter 4y agoWe arguably have a demand crisis as well, because we’re at full employment. At full employment, as more people get income, they are willing to pay more for goods. We see this in the housing market and the car market right now. This is textbook economics, and sure, there are new variables taking part in the game (wall street speculators buying homes as investments), but everything else is pretty by the books (low interest rates, rising inflation). The big question is if the fed can tighten monetary policy without crashing the economy.
- lamontcg 4y agoPeople aren't getting paid more because everything else is more expensive. People are getting paid more because there's a glut of jobs / shortage of workers. To achieve its policy goals at containing inflation and avoiding a wage-price spiral the Fed needs to break the back of the wage market, which means it needs to destroy jobs.
- CursedUrn 4y agoThis seems like a very one-sided description. You didn't mention the motivation for doing this? What's the benefit?
- metacritic12 4y agoEasy: just consider the opposite: > put up interest rates. This raises the cost of business credit, and at the margin, puts people out of work, until employment reaches the "non-accelerating rate" (NAIRU) Instead, keep interest rates now. Then wages will go up, but prices of goods also go up, and prices are less stable. This seems strictly worse for everyone. > break labour power by legislating against unions, breaking up state-owned businesses into the private sector, and promoting the Uber-style "independent contractor" model where people aren't employees This is not really within the purview of Fed policy, but the various legislatures. If you had the opposite, probably real wages will go up. In the socialist ideal case, more of GDP will go to labor, and laborers will get more equal salaries, which is great. The other side's argument is that with strong unionization you would a lot of stagnation: jobs that have low economic output but are still there because the unions keep it in place. General Motors is a classic example of a company beholden to it's labor so that capital doesn't want to invest in the company at all, and it ends up having relatively low productivity.
- arcticbull 4y ago> Instead, keep interest rates now. Then wages will go up, but prices of goods also go up, and prices are less stable. This seems strictly worse for everyone. FWIW I disagree with this. Prices will go up, which will incentivize adding new supply, and prices will eventually stabilize at a new (albeit higher) rate. This will eventually be compensated for through the wage-price cycle. Rising prices are a function of supply exceeding demand right. There's simply not enough gas right now for everyone. So you can either reduce demand, or you can increase supply. Reducing demand, IMO, isn't the right way forward.
- landemva 4y ago>> There's simply not enough gas right now for everyone. So you can either reduce demand, or you can increase supply. Biden can increase fuel supply by approving pipelines or allowing more drilling on federal land. This would help the poor and laborer class. But he won't.
- giantg2 4y agoThe problem is that this has been policy for decades. Their job losses mostly affect the lowest earners. Giving us higher income inequality. They need to figure out policies so that they don't just negatively impact the bottom.
- SoftTalker 4y agoThe bottom is where most people are. The spending of the 1% isn't really driving inflation of consumer goods and food, it's the spending of the bottom 80% who have extra cash from recently higher wages and stimulous checks. There isn't a job around here that pays less than about $15/hr now, even entry level McDonalds is paying 16 year-olds that. That's a lot more, almost double what they were paying pre-COVID.
- ushakov 4y agoyeah, let's take it away from the poor so the rich can buy more stuff at lower prices!
- SoftTalker 4y agoYou can't run away from the real economic value of goods, services, and labor. If the working poor are now making more than they used to for doing the same work, prices will inflate until they consume about the same percentage they did before, because the economic value of their labor has not changed. If you want to help the poor in the long run, you can't just pay them more money for the same work, you have to find ways to make their labor worth more.
- ushakov 4y agothat's just sounds like excuse why we should take money from the poor "we'll have to take away your pay bump and any hopes for better pay, because the market decided you're not actually worth it" "our billion dollar/year company can't afford to pay more without increasing prices for end-consumers"
- 4y ago
- 7speter 4y agoThe fed doesn’t deal with making or breaking labor power. Thats decision is left to the the people who work on capitol hill and the voters who put them there.
- cudgy 4y agoThen why is the employment level one of their primary determinants for interest rates? What do you think happens when the Fed raises rates? Companies lay off workers which increases unemployment. More unemployment means more workers in need of work, which viola means lower wages. See how it works?