3 ms·
Hi from Argentina! I hope to give an external perspective. My first recommendation is to go to thttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_school_shootings_in_the_U
by gus_massa 4y ago
Hi from Argentina! I hope to give an external perspective.
My first recommendation is to go to thttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_school_shootings_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_school_shootings_in_th... and make an excel file with the data of each incident, and try to make clear if the attacker was an immigrant "0", the son of an immigrant "1", the grand son of an immigrant "2", ... It's a strange metric, because if only one of your grandparents is an immigrant, do you get the same number in that field that if all your grandparents are immigrants.
My family is very weird, so some of my ancestor arrived recently and some a very long time ago. Try to imagine what would you write in that field for you and your friends.
Most immigrant are nice people. Some not.
Most people with long history of family there are nice people. Some not.
Most people with complicated ancestors structure are nice people. Some not.
In my opinion you are putting too much weight in the last case, and trying to fix it one detail that is not a common pattern and will not be useful to prevent next case.
- jelliclesfarm 4y agoI hear you. I don’t want to focus on this one case but this was the one that got me wondering because I can’t stop thinking about it. More than any other community, I feel like perhaps Americans are drowning in a melting pot and sinking in it because they can’t seem to create community. I don’t understand why it’s so hard to create community here. When I was growing up in india, doors were always open with neighbours. Now, I have to call or text before I even go to drop something at my neighbors because it’s ‘manners’. I get that but I wonder if there is a trade off. Moms always watched out for each other’s children in the neighborhood. This was the ‘village’ that raised children. I don’t think someone else’s mom can take the liberty to scold or instruct another’s child in America. This is also a feature of ‘community’. It is not to say that there aren’t problems with ‘community’ but that was an acceptable price for the greater benefits. In America, there is no acceptable price that infringes upon individuality. No, Sir! There seems to be very clear disadvantages to this way of life. Schools are trying hard to inculcate conformity but that’s not a good thing either. Conformity works in small homogenous groups and there has to be multiple small homogenous groups to create diversity. Creating dense communities of individuals who can’t relate to their neighbors is not diversity. The ‘melting pot’ is not working. Everyone ends up feeling alienated but is being made to conform. I wonder if this happens in other countries too.