4 ms·
Slightly related, but... what is it with stars? I've never starred a repo and don't understand why I would want to. Yet it seems to be a popularity contest peop
by viraptor 4y ago
Slightly related, but... what is it with stars? I've never starred a repo and don't understand why I would want to. Yet it seems to be a popularity contest people care about for some reason, even though it correlates strongly with forks/issues/prs so you get the same idea about usage from those. Does it go at all beyond a "like", or am I just too old to get it?
- frou_dh 4y agoIt's a 2-in-1 like & bookmark.
- asaddhamani 4y agoI think of it as a "like" or a bookmark, if I come across a repo and I find it interesting or useful, I star it.
- irrational 4y agoI use it as a bookmark. Under my own account I can find the repos I have starred.
- onionisafruit 4y agoIt makes me feel good when I see one of my projects getting stars. When I star a project it is with the hope that another maintainer will have a similar good feeling.
- viraptor 4y agoYou're a good person and this made me think I should star some smaller project I use. Thank you. Let's show the maintainers some love.
- hk__2 4y agoGitHub recently added a feature where you can organize your stars in lists, so you decide what they mean. My lists include for example "useful CLI tools", "languages", and "projects to contribute to". Outside of this feature, I mostly use the stars as a 'like' button.
- MetaWhirledPeas 4y ago> Yet it seems to be a popularity contest people care about for some reason Before you incorporate someone's Github library into your own project, you want to know some things. Is it secure? Is it well-maintained? Is there an active userbase to help with support? Stars are one indicator of this.
- toastal 4y agoHardly. I was on a project with a JS dependency with 6.5k stars and sponsors but it injected a remote script at runtime without consent. I'm also a part of niche community circles where a project would be lucky to break 50 stars despite having phenomenal value and quality. It really is purely a popularity contest and only that with a bias towards other languages and projects that are equally as popular.
- yreg 4y agoan indicator is not a proof
- viraptor 4y agoHonestly, I would rather go for that specific info instead. CVEs for security, network graph and PRs for activity, CI maturity for security and maintenance, etc. Stars give you mostly popularity which is not necessarily correlated. But yeah, I agree they can be a single-number-proxy for the above.
- akh 4y agoI wrote a blog about how stars helped us at the very early stages of our open source product: https://www.infracost.io/blog/github-stars-matter-here-is-why/ https://www.infracost.io/blog/github-stars-matter-here-is-wh...
- flohofwoe 4y agoI use them mostly like bookmarks, a cool project I stumbled over and want to "pin" for the future.