2 ms·
could you clarify the difference between externalizing and internalizing please? isn't feeling like a victim the very definition of externalizing? wouldn't in
by em-bee 4y ago
could you clarify the difference between externalizing and internalizing please?
isn't feeling like a victim the very definition of externalizing?
wouldn't internalizing mean to blame yourself instead?
doesn't accept personal responsibility translate (crudely) to: don't blame others, it's your own fault. (i realize that this is not the intent, i actually understand the article to mean that i should take responsibility for changing the situation, not just for getting into the situation in the first place. so this is just exaggerated to draw out the point)
so yes, i agree this is for externalizers, but that's because internalizers would never see themselves as victims. (well maybe one can see oneself as a victim of ones past self)
sorry, if i sound confused, i am trying to work this out as i write.
so basically, the advice to not feel as a victim is a no-op for internalizers because they don't do that already. but what follows still applies: take responsibility to get yourself out of that situation
likewise internalizers are also not immune to self-pity.
externalizers feel they can't do anything because everyone else prevents them. internalizers feel they can't do anything because they themselves are lacking the necessary capacity.
but the article says that neither is true. you can take responsibility and make your situation better. i think that applies equally to both.
an externalizer can say: yes, that happened to me, but i can fix it, even though it's not my fault. and the internalizer can say, yes, i got myself into that situation, but i can also get myself out of it.
so i don't really see much of a difference there, and why the advice would be terrible for internalizers.
- Delk 4y agoI think GP's point might be that, if you tell an internalizer who is miserable -- and thus seeing the fault in themselves -- that it's bad to feel victimhood or a fault in others or in their circumstances, you might push them further into self-blame even if their misery was brought by bad luck, or if they're disproportionately seeing a failure in themselves already. What you say makes sense from a solutions point of view that assumes people presently have the mental capacity to improve their lives and circumstances. Sometimes it works, and it's always attractive to think of and offer solutions, but it can be a two-edged sword. If you say that to someone who's burned out (for lack of a better expression; doesn't have to be burnout), out of capacity and miserable and disproportionately blaming themselves for that, you might just increase their self-blame rather than positively encouraging them towards solutions even if your intention is the latter.
- em-bee 4y agoi believe recommending solutions to someone is not really a good idea. rather i'd encourage the person to look for for their own solutions and then help them validate whether those are a good.
- Delk 4y agoAFAIK, in therapy, the therapist's focus on giving advice correlates negatively with success. I imagine the relationship between the two might depend on the problem, interpersonal chemistry and various things I can't think of, but especially if the problem isn't something absolutely concrete, advice probably isn't something that helps. Most people aren't stupid, and if a psychological or emotional problem were just a simple solution away, they'd probably have thought of it already. Friendship or other "normal" relationships and interaction aren't therapy, of course, but the negative correlation might be an insightful observation nevertheless.
- em-bee 4y agoyes, exactly, because it is not advice that people need, but validation of their feelings and ideas. good friends validate and support. therapy of course goes beyond that by for example pointing to new ways to think about your situation, and recognizing problems that friends may not be able to see.
- lazide 4y agoNot necessarily. Validation of bad state is harmful. A therapist shouldn’t, for instance, tell someone it’s ok to feel uncontrollable rage because the mail was 5 minutes later than normal yesterday. Noting it is happening is of course important. But challenging the client is also important. Is that helping them? Do they know why they felt that way? Are there tools we can use to discover why, if not? Are there actions that can be taken to put them in a place where they can feel something that IS helping them, for instance. Friends who always encourage or validate are toxic, just like those that never do. It’s contextual.