8 ms·
Study confirms superior sound of a Stradivari is due to wood treatment (2021)
- fargle 4y agoThat title is misleading. This article is actually titled "Study confirms superior sound of Stradivari is due to how wood was treated". It's a report about a new study that claims that it is NOT the varnish. Rather it was a secret recipe of wood preservative used by the Cremonese makers Stradivari and Guarneri to impregnate the spruce. The linked papers are much better than the article. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/anie.202105252 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/anie.202105252
- Tomte 4y agoTitle has changed from last time I submitted it.
- isaacfrond 4y agoYup, title is now 'Study confirms superior sound of Stradivari is due to how wood was treated'
- thomasjudge 4y agoSo you periodically resubmit the same articles to HN?
- Tomte 4y agoYes.
- causi 4y agoArs Technica regularly does A/B testing with radically different titles. You'll note from the URL that the submitter did use the first title.
- rjzzleep 4y agoI'm still following Ars Technica on Facebook, but it's only clickbait these days. I feel like I remember it being a quality publication at some point in the past ... What happened?
- causi 4y agoFully agree. It was incredible when the tagline was "Ars Technica, the PC Enthusiast's Resource." It's become increasingly clickbaity. One wonders how a tech news site manages to justify using a school shooting to generate pageviews. In recent months they've been reposting stories from their "partner sites", most of which are spectacularly terrible. I think the decline began a few years ago when they starting amplifying Twitter drama about game developers. That's about the same time the rumors started flying about Peter Bright, which site admins continued to stomp on right up until he was arrested for pedophilia.
- GloriousKoji 4y agoThey sold out to Conde Nast in 2008.
- rjzzleep 4y agoI've heard that before, but I'm not sure what it means in practice.
- Jenk 4y agoThe URL usually contains the original title. In this case it is ".. varnish"
- danielvaughn 4y agoMakes me wonder if the same kind of treatment, applied to acoustic guitars, would have the same effect.
- ghastmaster 4y agoWhile not infused with borax and sulfates(that I'm aware of) Martin guitars is doing treatments to their VTS line to speed up the aging process to create the sound of vintage guitars on a brand new one. http://onemanz.com/guitar/articles-2/torrefication/ http://onemanz.com/guitar/articles-2/torrefication/
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Cenk 4y agoOA.mg has the link to the PDF of the paper: https://oa.mg/work/10.1002/anie.202105252 https://oa.mg/work/10.1002/anie.202105252
- graycat 4y agoIndiana University has long had an excellent music school. E.g., one of the violin professors was J. Gingold, long Concert Master at Cleveland. A cello professor was J. Starker, long a well known, good recording artist. I liked music a LOT, had recordings of dozens of the most famous pieces from Bach through Tchaikovsky. And I was a math grad student, but my dorm building was next to the music school with a lot of music majors. One of the violin students put his old Italian violin under my left chin and gave me a first lesson. So, I signed up for a course in violin, just me and one teacher, a violin student in the school. He was terrific, far ahead of what I as a beginner, deserved! E.g., after the semester was over, he played the Brahms concerto in Toronto! But I did get a start. I continued, and took some more lessons off and on. Eventually I made it through a few pages of some of the famous music, e.g., the Bach Chaconne. The student there at Indiana University I met again later, and he had swapped his old Italian violin for one made in NYC. His statement was that what he got new was as good as any of the old Italian instruments. That is, net, somehow some modern violin makers have learned how to make violins that are among the best ever. Just how to do that? Uh, instead of what is in the OP, just talk to some such violin makers!
- JasonFruit 4y agoNagyvary has made different claims about the "secret of Stradivari" over the last thirty? forty? years, and they're all authoritative, and none of them explain why Stradivari's instruments are so valued. I'm confident that the real secret of Stradivari is a lot of things, all working together, that he learned by being an excellent craftsman with a good ear and analytical mind, and by being trained by the greatest violin maker before Stradivari, Nicolo Amati, who was likewise trained by previous great makers of his own family. There's no one change that, applied indiscriminately to an instrument, will reliably improve it. There are lots of things that work together to make a great instrument, and a great maker knows how to balance them. (Side note: I'm also confident that there are instruments being made today that will equal Stradivari's given time enough. In my own experience, one viola made by Michael Darnton of Chicago was markedly better than any of the old Italian instruments I've played, though they were not of the first rank. That was an instrument fit for any use, and if I could have afforded it, I would never have let it go.)
- jacquesm 4y agoHow much did it cost?
- JasonFruit 4y agoAbout $16K, 20 years ago when I was leaving grad school. It was really magnificent, and the price was not too high at all, but it was beyond anything I could raise at the time.
- jacquesm 4y agoI am always amazed at how much these old instruments go for, one of my uncles was an extremely good violinist and I remember that as a kid I wasn't even allowed to go near his instrument. (To be fair, I had a bit of a reputation...)
- JasonFruit 4y agoA dealer once let my wife play a small, anonymous old Italian cello. She loved it! 100K. At least the dealer that handed her a Strad told her what it was. She preferred the little Italian.
- Semaphor 4y agoNote that the "superior sound" is also very probably pure imagination > In fact, a 2012 double-blind study of 21 experienced violinists found that most of the subjects preferred playing the newer instruments; the Stradivarius ranked last in their preferences. Most of them couldn't tell the difference between the old and new instruments, with no significant correlation between an instrument's age and its monetary value. FTA
- matjet 4y agoTo add a datapoint: In this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T8q3zrCYMRw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T8q3zrCYMRw, they managed to differentiate most high end violins (4/5 tests - 10 Violins). Incidentally, the only mistake was with one of the two Stradivari examples.
- edbaskerville 4y agoI worry that the takeaway for people that only read clickbait headlines about the 2012 Stradivarius study was: expert violinists can't tell the difference between cheap and expensive violins. All the new violins in that study were high-end instruments by trained artisans, which can easily be $100,000 or more. So really the takeaway is: modern players like violins from today's masters of violinmaking as much as or more than those by Stradivarius.
- Semaphor 4y agoAFAIK there were also cheaper ones, but the more important takeaway, IMO, is that Stradivarius isn't something magical (like this article also claims in the headline), but simply a very well crafted violin. Which is great, but no lost art.
- BizarroLand 4y agoThey are master quality violins for the time period and they pretty much set the standard for modern violins. If they were being made today they would be considered very good quality violins and fetch in the $10,000+ range or more most likely, especially considering the location they are made in, the materials, and the methods employed to build them.
- DannyBee 4y agoWoodworker here. Yeah, the title is literally wrong - someone pointed out that they a/b test titles, etc. So just ars being ars i guess. The paper doesn't claim it's the varnish, it claims it's the wood treatment and its effect on density. That would make some sense. The varnish is the finishing layer that is on top. That layer is also, fwiw, about 3-5 mils most of the time (IE 0.003-0.005 inches). Depends obviously on what and why (IE marine finishes are thicker, etc). It's affect on sound is almost certainly near nil. If you could produce serious damping effects with 0.003-0.005 of a coating, we'd use it on walls, etc. In reality, mass is much more important, which is why the treatment affecting the moisture content and density of wood would make more sense.
- gonzo41 4y agoI thought the reason they sounded so good was they were made from reclaimed church timber, old beams and such, and were thus touched by the angels. Wouldn't the older wood just be lighter, dryer and less dense?
- shuckles 4y agoWood’s quality don’t change much once it’s harvested. Old wood is more often from natural forests where trees grow slowly due to resource competition and therefore have tighter growth rings. New wood is usually from lumber farms where trees are planted and managed such that they grow quickly and end up being less dense.
- tzs 4y agoDoesn't the moisture content change over time after the wood is harvested, leading to small changes in size of the wood? I recall seeing instrument making videos where they mentioned the importance of using wood that had aged long enough to stabilize so that dimensions would not change after it was on the instrument. Some instruments have parts whose dimensions are critical.
- DannyBee 4y ago
- buescher 4y agoI saw an article a while back about how, much like counterfeits that fool all the experts look amateurish after a few decades, the violins that compare well to Stradivariuses in these double blind studies eventually get considered inferior to new violins or at least go out of style. Something really funny is going on with how we perceive these old Italian violins and it's not all reputation-based placebo effect. Somebody also discovers a different "secret of the Stradivari" every decade or so. Thirty years ago people were going to make carbon-fiber composite violins that imitated the mechanical properties of the wood used in them, for example.
- hbarka 4y agoHost of the PBS show Great Performances goes to Bergamo Italy and gets to play a $15M Stradivari violin https://youtu.be/QObnfS29lKo https://youtu.be/QObnfS29lKo
- asiachick 4y agoWasn't this a solved problem like 40 years ago? Here's an episode of NOVA (PBS, WGBH) from 1982 all about it https://archive.org/details/GreatViolinMystery https://archive.org/details/GreatViolinMystery
- acadapter 4y agoNone of the Stradivarius violins are in their original condition (not even the "almost never been played" Messiah Stradivarius). There was a time where Baroque violins would get their neck removed and re-glued at a larger angle, along with a bridge replacement. This happened to every single Stradivarius ever made. And then, there's the shift to modern steel strings. And most of them have been opened multiple times to seal cracks in the wood.
- sabujp 4y agoviolinist here, you can make a $100 amazon violin sound much better by getting more expensive strings (e.g. Dominant) and also by practicing more.
- AlbertCory 4y agoOff-topic here but it does have to do with top-end musical instruments, and having the big name. Bosendorfer [1] is trying (IMHO, without total success) to displace Steinway as the premier piano for concerts. A couple items in the Wikipedia article made me LOL: > In his memoirs, Arthur Rubinstein recounts having insisted on a Bechstein instead of the hall's Bösendorfer before a recital in Austria. When my teacher moved away, she gave me her Bechstein on indefinite loan. It had a cracked soundboard, but she felt that it should nonetheless be worth $20,000 or so. A piano tech looked at it and said, "Maybe $2,000." > Jazz pianist Keith Jarrett performed the solo improvisations (his Köln Concert) at the Cologne Opera House in Cologne, Germany on 24 January 1975 on a Bösendorfer and became a Steinway & Sons artist in 1981. [1] https://www.boesendorfer.com/en/pianos/pianos https://www.boesendorfer.com/en/pianos/pianos
- snowwrestler 4y ago“The Red Violin” is a late 90’s movie about a famous and beautiful-sounding violin (clearly based on a Strad) that is passed down through the ages, which has a unique varnish on it.
- JohnHaugeland 4y agoIt's worth noting that most of the studies done on the matter suggest that Stradivarii do not, in fact, sound better. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/stradivarius-violins-arent-better-than-new-ones-round-two https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/stradivar...