3 ms·
Data centers need this for space constraints, but if you're just the average Joe gamer I encourage you to think twice before considering liquid cooling (especia
by dangus 4y ago
Data centers need this for space constraints, but if you're just the average Joe gamer I encourage you to think twice before considering liquid cooling (especially a custom loop).
Why do I say this? Because...my goodness, it gets expensive, and you're really not going to get much more performance or even noise reduction out of it (and like...don't you already wear a headset while you game?)
I've never understood the market for CPU AIOs especially. They're just so expensive compared to fitting a giant heatsink and fan on there, which will be quite quiet if it's large enough.
- Filligree 4y agoI've built systems with air cooling, with water cooling, and I've also bought an air-cooled prebuilt. My goal, in each case, was to minimize noise. What I've taken away from that is: - It's perfectly possible to build a quiet, air-cooled, relatively cheap system. - But you probably don't have the skill for that. It's a complex task, and requires either good intuition or an entire engineering degree. - Building a quiet water-cooled desktop is relatively easy, because you can oversize the cooling massively. So would I recommend water-cooling? My goodness no. It's a lot of work, it's expensive, and in the end the pre-built was marginally quieter. But if the comparison is against a self-built air-cooled one, then water cooling can indeed come out on top.
- dangus 4y ago> But you probably don't have the skill for that. It's a complex task, and requires either good intuition or an entire engineering degree. That’s just ridiculous, come on. You google some reviews of some parts or watch some Gamers Nexus videos and that’s all you have to do.
- dangus 4y agoI’ll add on top of this: some of the air cooled solutions are stupidly cheap. The Cooler Master Hyper 212 Evo has been on the market forever and it’s dirt cheap, good quiet performance, upgradable to any fan you damn please. It’s really as simple as a big-ass hunk of metal, it’s hard to go wrong. As far as graphics card noise you can usually buy something off the shelf and undervolt it in MSI Afterburner…or just buy a very large three fan mid-range graphics card where the cooling package is designed for something that draws way more power.
- Filligree 4y agoSee, that’s what I thought until I saw a properly built system. Sure, you can buy good components and that will get you fifty percent of the way. But it won’t get you to a literally inaudible PC.
- dangus 4y agoWater cooling rigs aren't literally inaudible, either. They still have a pump and fans for the radiator. I'm talking about noise performance that is "more than good enough for most people." The price to dB reduction ratio of most water cooling setups, whether it's a cheap AIO or full blown custom loop, just doesn't make any sense when compared to air. These are seriously diminishing returns on investment. The reason people install custom loops is because they look cool, that's 80% of it. It's a hot rodding culture, and that can be fun and appreciated for what it is. But if all you want is a system that's quiet enough for the game audio on a relatively low volume to drown out the sound of the PC, air is all you need.
- dotnet00 4y agoI agree in general, liquid cooling loops are a lot of work for usually very little benefit for average users. Even for people who need to put a couple of GPUs together, it turns out that mining rig frames with 16x extenders are pretty effective, since unlike a datacenter, you don't really need to optimize for density. But, I think CPU AIOs are the one exception since giant heatsinks often interfere with other parts (overhanging ram slots or the first M.2 slot) and add a lot of weight to be hanging off the motherboard.
- dangus 4y agoI still really don't understand CPU AIOs from a value perspective. - I've gotten more than acceptable noise performance out of very small mini-ITX cases by using ITX-sized heatsinks with high quality fans/designs/materials (e.g., Noctua). You don't even really need a giant heatsink to get good noise performance in many instances, and in terms of price it’s very easy to beat an AIO to get a higher quality air setup. - I haven't seen many heatsink/board designs made in recent years that don't take RAM and slots into consideration, and I don't really care if I have to take a heatsink off to remove an M.2 card – by the time I want to do that, it's probably about time to re-apply thermal paste anyway. - In what world does "weight hanging off the motherboard" matter? I've never seen or heard of any motherboard issue caused by this. The Cooler Master Hyper 212 is massive, and it has been a budget staple for over a decade and nobody's had this problem with it to my knowledge. - Most gamers don't need anything above mid-range for their CPU (e.g., AMD 5600X at 65 watts), but you'll see YouTubers building rigs with crazy high end stuff that doesn't significantly impact gaming performance and requires better cooling. Unless you're trying to go from 300 to 350FPS in an eSports game at 1080p, there's no reason to go above mid-range, your money is better spent on the GPU (i.e., most people game in a way that's GPU-bound). - Case volume and well-engineered case thermal design is "free." If all you care about is reasonable cost, low noise, and performance per dollar, using an AIO setup is just about the worst way to spend your money when you can just get a larger case with good airflow design by perusing reviews. - If you're doing any kind of socializing while gaming (e.g., Discord), you should be on headphones anyway because otherwise you'll be feeding back into your microphone. As long as your computer doesn't sound like a PS4 Pro I'd say it's fine.