2 ms·
There are two main defenses: invalidity and non-infringement. You're correct, and you're talking about non-infringement. Invalidity can be proven outside of a
by AlbertCory 4y ago
There are two main defenses: invalidity and non-infringement. You're correct, and you're talking about non-infringement.
Invalidity can be proven outside of a full-blown lawsuit (via re-exam) and so it's cheaper. Asking a jury to judge invalidity is asking for trouble, because they usually figure they're not competent to do it.
I actually watched a video of a mock jury, where they debated this. It's pretty shocking how little they understand the law. One juror actually said, "well, that prior art reference -- it's not fair to expect the PTO to have heard of that."