4 ms·
Aren't there still plenty of cameras using 3 separate sensors and an optical beam splitter, instead of a Bayer filter array?
by jeffbee 4y ago
Aren't there still plenty of cameras using 3 separate sensors and an optical beam splitter, instead of a Bayer filter array?
- jakebasile 4y agoI don't know of any consumer cameras that do this. Some manufacturers use a different filter on some models, Fuji uses an X-Trans filter on some models which in the past can cause issues with some software demosaicing.
- rplst8 4y agoX-trans is still a mosaic and the underlying tech is mostly the same (color filter array with monochrome "buckets"). Instead of a 2x2 pattern, it uses a 6x6 pattern. Goes something like: GRBGBR BGGRGG RGGBGG Instead of: RG GB
- kelsolaar 4y agoConsumers camera use a Bayer colour filter array because it is cheaper and more compact. Demosaicing is performant enough for most consumer applications that it is hard to justify for anything than scientific applications. As a matter of fact, even Motion Picture cameras, e.g. ARRI LF, are using a Bayer CFA.
- formerly_proven 4y agoIf they do, that has to be limited to "broadcast" cameras. Digital cinema cameras all pretty prominently use a single sensor.
- kuschku 4y agoThere is one model still sold by sony using these! https://pro.sony/en_GB/products/shoulder-camcorders/pxw-z750 https://pro.sony/en_GB/products/shoulder-camcorders/pxw-z750 All the others have now switched to bayer sensors.
- aidenn0 4y agoOnly $3k from Adorama; are pro cameras really that cheap these days? [edit] That was google shopping popping up the Z150, which is presumably less expensive. The Z450 is 20k, body only, and the Z750 is "in store purchase only"
- muglug 4y agoYes, it's everything else that's expensive — a set of cinema lenses will set you back many multiples of that. Then you need to pay the people to operate them. Here's a deep dive with an expert from Arri (big movie glass company) here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q1n2DR6H7mk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q1n2DR6H7mk
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- panda88888 4y agoThere’s also a stacked sensor version. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foveon_X3_sensor https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foveon_X3_sensor
- baybal2 4y agoVery surprised to see them still kicking, and preparing a 5th generation sensor by themselves. https://m.dpreview.com/news/1885231343/sigma-releases-update-on-the-development-of-its-three-layer-full-frame-foveon-image-sensor https://m.dpreview.com/news/1885231343/sigma-releases-update... They are really dinosaurs of electronic imaging. Sans Sony, I can say ALL sensor makers from the dawn of the era died off, or were sold/resold a million times.
- rplst8 4y agoSigma had their Foveon sensor in APS sized version several years ago but they're currently working on the 35mm version. https://www.dpreview.com/news/1885231343/sigma-releases-update-on-the-development-of-its-three-layer-full-frame-foveon-image-sensor https://www.dpreview.com/news/1885231343/sigma-releases-upda...
- ekianjo 4y agoIt's taking forever though, they are encountering many issues to scale to 35mm.
- numpad0 4y agoNot plenty, “3CCD” cameras exist but are rare and mainly used for industrial inspections and TV broadcasts. Some old home video cameras did use it but not anymore.
- prox 4y agoWhat is the advantage in these last applications?
- numpad0 4y ago"Image quality" seems to be the most common answer... It eliminates the need for color filter deposited on the sensor, and also seem to require cares taken in lens design to have optical parameters converged for all three image planes in respective wavelengths(can't have one color being magnified or out of focus than others). I suppose whether those points are pros or cons depends on design/manufacturing capability, and considering rarity of modern 3CCD designs, likely decisions are difficulties outweigh advantages today.
- ekianjo 4y agoNope, Bayer is the norm, but there's still some Foveon cameras that are typically rather slow to produce images.
- paulmd 4y agoNo, nobody uses a 3-strip/3-sensor approach anymore. It was used in the early Technicolor process, and was revived during the digital era with cameras like the Minolta RD-175, and it lingered on in cine cameras for a while longer, but nowadays almost everyone uses a bayer-filter approach (or a very similar one - there are several proprietary alternatives for the mosaic layout that claim various quality improvements). The only similar thing nowadays is Foveon sensors where you have 3 color sites stacked on top of each other, but Foveon didn't really have the money to keep up with the arms race and nowadays the modern sensors are far better even though they do have to apply a low-pass filter to avoid mosaicing. When you have many, many, many nodes of improvement past the Foveon sensor, that stops being a big deal. It was also never particularly widely adopted, because none of these things are new - it was a tough sell to market a "really high color-resolution!" 5mp camera going up against 20mp filtered sensors and 50mp unfiltered sensors even 10 years ago. Interestingly though, the Foveon approach is similar to film. Film has multiple layers and all are exposed at once. There's no denying bayer is sort of weird. It's just very expensive to be the odd man out doing your own sensors. "Good enough" usually wins, Foveon may be betamax but bayer is VHS - and I use that analogy knowingly, in the sense of Betamax also doing key features worse in areas that consumers care a lot about.
- jeffbee 4y ago> It was also never particularly widely adopted I think you must be ignoring television and video here? Basically everything that was shot on digital video for broadcast for decades was shot on 3-sensor cameras, and every "serious" video operation from sports to news all the way down to wedding photographers and high school videographers with any scratch at all were using 3-ccd setups. Sony's current (and only) 8K TV studio camera uses 3 sensors.
- KennyBlanken 4y agoThey meant Foveon was never widely adopted...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]