2 ms·
I always figured it was due to the heavy regulations on US car design that cover every aspect of it. The same kind of regulations that eliminated SRO housing.
by WalterBright 4y ago
I always figured it was due to the heavy regulations on US car design that cover every aspect of it. The same kind of regulations that eliminated SRO housing.
For example, it would be much harder to make a small car as able to protect its occupants in a crash as a larger one.
- oneplane 4y agoIt's mostly cultural I suspect. There are almost no technical reasons and very few financial reasons why it wouldn't be possible. But to get there you'd have to make cities (as that's where those ares are the most useful) a bit more like Europe and Japan (for living, not for driving around in a big car), and people don't like change and in the US it's even more of a dislike it the change seems to come from an example outside of the country. Most of this suspicion is cobbled together from my own experience in the US (mostly the costs, not the middle part), and publications like NotJustBikes and about the way some US cities tend to grow outwards because investing in making what's already there healthy to live in is not as profitable as waiting for gentrification-ripeness and building around it in the meantime.
- WalterBright 4y agoCrash protection is a technical reason. US car regulations grew up around larger cars.
- oneplane 4y agoThat would definitely end up in a spiral where you can only keep making bigger cars so they can't get crashed to death by other cars. Reminds me of the side-effect of car-centric urban designs where it apparently is 'not news' to have people crash their cars into buildings.
- 8note 4y agoCrash protection is also a function of speed and what you'll crash into. Change those, and the car can be different
- mhh__ 4y agoThe existing cars on the road make at least some of that regulation necessary or at least not unmotivated. That and consumers tend to want a bigger car than their neighbour either for safety or bragging rights. One thing that always annoys me in the UK is people who buy big SUVs because they live on wet leaves and maybe a slightly muddy road. Totally ruins a lot of British roads (and kills people), and keep in mind that all modern cars have been worked on by a team of vehicle dynamicists to make sure they are safe and stable in slippy conditions. The number of people I've spoken to who don't causally understand why the car has a gearbox (and thus what gear to be in, in said slippy road) is too many. F1 cars have also gotten a lot bigger this year due to crash structures since there were a few pretty bad accidents involving cars basically splitting in half recently.