10 ms·
Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies'
- rysertio 4y agoEveryone is against cryptocurrencies, till they get their bank accounts frozen for no particular reason.
- bko 4y ago> He worries that they enable illicit activity by making money transactions less transparent. Still, he sees the value in digital payments systems and supports electronic use of government-backed currencies like the dollar. > “I’ve been a great advocate of moving to an electronic payments mechanism. There are a lot of efficiencies. I think we can actually have a better regulated economy if we had all the data in real time, knowing what people are spending,” he says. This is almost written like a parody. Government backed electronic money is utterly dystopian to me. Imagine all the "nudges" that could easily be introduced. You're buying too much [bad thing], card declined. You're costing the health care system too much by being overweight so we'll restrict your food allowance. Your carbon emissions are over the limit this month, we'll have to deny your flight purchase. A gas station charges "too much" for gas, payment declined.
- andrenth 4y agohttps://theupheaval.substack.com/p/just-say-no-to-cbdcs https://theupheaval.substack.com/p/just-say-no-to-cbdcs
- adrianN 4y agoI would prefer something like GNU Taler over any cryptocurrency.
- outime 4y agoI'm afraid that's exactly how it's gonna turn out.
- igorkraw 4y agoWith natural monopolies like those promoted by the network effects crypto projects pin their hopes on the stable point is the same, minus democratic institutions ensuring some semblance of justice and equity.
- _ZeD_ 4y agoI'm pretty sure is more about money laundering than that.
- xtracto 4y agoAnd the security theatre in airports is more about terrorism. And not letting you pass that sunscreen bottle is about liquid bombs... There will always be a "reason" for the government to gain control over citizens.
- npc12345 4y agoThey'll never get it man. They want to government up their a$$. That's why I no longer argue with them, not as much as I used to. Every successful, cool and relaxed person Ive known in real life is against all of this shit.
- scoopertrooper 4y ago99% of retail payments already happen through a tightly regulated electronic payment system today. I haven't been denied my god given right to murder myself by purchasing tobacco and sugar products so far.
- ekianjo 4y ago> I haven't been denied my god given right to murder myself by purchasing tobacco and sugar products so far. The past does not predict the future
- bennysomething 4y agoYes but that data is fragmented, not on a giant immutable ledger.
- ceejayoz 4y agoIt's not that fragmented. Visa, Mastercard, and if you're being completionist, Amex and Discover. Four taps gets you virtually every credit card transaction in the Western world. Direct bank transfers are even more susceptible.
- bennysomething 4y agoAnd cash! :)
- 4y ago
- Tenoke 4y agoI agree but I actually wouldn't mind if carbon emissions and offsets were tracked and ensured to be not too negative. There are easier ways to do that though - e.g. just include money for offseting in the flight price.
- ekianjo 4y ago> carbon emissions and offsets were tracked and ensured to be not too negative including big exceptions for politicians who have no problem taking a plane every 2 days for no reason.
- freemint 4y agoNo, no, no need for that. It is an expense the tax payer pays for anyway. So no reason for exception for politicians
- ericd 4y agoIt’s even simpler than that - slap the carbon tax on the carbon source at time of extraction if it’s domestic, or at import time if it’s from a country that doesn’t do that itself at the same rate. The price changes will all flow downstream from there, and we don’t have a hairball of exemptions for eg jet fuel. And very pessimistic taxation estimates for materials and finished products from countries that don’t follow suit.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoYeah, but everything has to be progressive. We can't reduce emissions by taxing EVERYONE to reduce emissions. We have to try to squeeze 76% of the reductions from the top 1%. The problem is - if you ACTUALLY want to do something about emissions - they aren't as unevenly distributed as wealth. Everyone needs to cut back. And just like taxes - everyone is willing to raise taxes on someone else. Everyone is willing to force everyone else to cut their emissions. Hardly anyone wants their own taxes to go up, or reduce their own emissions.
- 4y ago
- eganist 4y ago> Imagine all the "nudges" that could easily be introduced. You're buying too much [bad thing], card declined. You're costing the health care system too much by being overweight so we'll restrict your food allowance. Your carbon emissions are over the limit this month, we'll have to deny your flight purchase. A gas station charges "too much" for gas, payment declined. Why would they do this when they can (and already do) use taxes and tax breaks to dis/incentivize behavior?
- ekianjo 4y ago> Why would they do this when they can (and already do) use taxes and tax breaks to dis/incentivize behavior? Because they can. You have never heard of government abuse before?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nverno 4y agoThe dis/incentive aspect is already abused, imo. If a small percentage of society participates in one activity, eg. smoking, it's too easy for the majority to tax the crap out of them to fund whatever activities they want.
- danaris 4y agoI'm really not sure invoking smoking as your boogeyman here is making the point you want it to. It's already very well known that the reason it remained unrestricted for so long is because the tobacco giants actively suppressed the studies that clearly showed how deadly it was, both for smokers and for the people around them. I don't think using something like sin taxes to discourage doing something that actively harms both you and anyone who has to share your air can reasonably be called an abuse of government power, unless you're one of the people who thinks that anything (besides maybe enforcing property rights) is an abuse of government power.
- nverno 4y ago
- boredumb 4y agoI find it alarming how authoritarianism and totalitarianism are perfectly acceptable views if people work in particular academic and political circles and mask it in the 'better regulation', 'better government' or other pro-government sentiment. It feels like a whole section of society is trying to shoehorn in a fully regulated society by playing coy and fooling large portions of society at large into believing it's going to be to their benefit by not being completely honest with the implications and historical outcomes of a totalitarian state.
- andrew_ 4y agoThis has been pushed with every hot-button topic, every tragedy, at every opportunity. What boggles my mind even more is how many people seem perfectly willing to step right in line and accept it.
- mushbino 4y agoWe live in a totalitarian state that's managed by corporations. In true American style, we outsource all of the things you just mentioned to the private sector, but they still very much happen just the same. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inverted_totalitarianism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inverted_totalitarianism
- nine_k 4y agoIf you are smart, there is a strong temptation to start telling everyone how to behave, because they are, like, less smart, and do stupid and dangerous things. These simpletons should do what we, the smart bunch, say, for their own good! In some ancient books this is called hubris. It's a very real danger in any human interaction.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- AlanYx 4y agoA lot of academics honestly believe in the idea that we're smart enough now to do it better. I work periodically with one academic who wrote a recent book published by Harvard University Press on the history of German censorship prior to 1945 (and she has relatives who were killed in the Holocaust), and yet who is still a firm believer in current initiatives to censor the Internet to address harmful content. This "we're smarter now" is a kind of perpetual Achilles heel of academics dealing in policy. e.g., Chinese academics thought they were smarter now too just prior to the cultural revolution, and that they'd be able to steer the tiger they created in the students. They weren't, of course, and many of those academics ended up being targets.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Maf1 4y agoDavos have been pushing individual carbon trackers. "reached carbon quota.. access to flight/bus/car..denied!
- dpweb 4y agoThere’s 141 trillion of wealth in the US. 2 trillion is in currency. We already have digital money it’s called the US Dollar.
- jollybean 4y ago"Economists want real time data" --> "They are controlling our toughts!" 1) Please - enough with they hyperbole. Data is not the same as control. Yes - we should be wary, we don't want the government using our money to nudge us. At the same time we definitely want our governments using data to help us. There was a story in Canada about the government buying anonymoized cell tower data to understand our behaviours during a pandemic, misrepresented as 'they are trying to control us' - which is a disingenuous lie. Literally we're faced with a pandemic, we want to get rid of restrictions, the best way to do that is to know where and how COVID is spreading. We wouldn't bat an eye if some garbage advertising company bought that data. 2) "Government backed electronic money is utterly dystopian to me. I" Hyerbole. You already use 'Government Backed Electronic Money' - that the way it works and it works fine. It's 1000% better than 'Ponzi Scheme Money 80% Owned by Elon Musk' or 'Google Controlled Money'. And FYI - the 'Government Backed Money' we use today flows through VISA network and they are 100% selling every bit of your data to anyone who will buy. What you probably want is even stronger regulation of 'Gov Money' so that private entities cannot trace, transact or sell, i.e. even better privacy laws. And maybe some kind of legislation that forbids the Central Bank from doing anything other than targeting inflation/employment.
- yucky 4y ago>At the same time we definitely want our governments using data to help us. Speak for yourself, until the government shows it can be trusted. Their track record is awful, no thanks.
- jollybean 4y agoAgain, hyperbolic nonsense. Your government has millions of people working for it that do innumerable things from water works, electricity distribution and regulation, policing, defence. You already depend on them intimately. The naive, glib view that somehow 'we can't trust government' is blatantly contradicted by your very existed. We want to make sure oversight and controls are there, but it's bonkers to suggest we don't want health officials to understand how this pandemic played out, so that they can figure out how to deal with the next one.
- moistly 4y agoYou have declined to get a credit or debit card, I suppose? If not, you may want to check out the data a “Level 3” transactor provides regarding your purchases. Data the card company subsequently sells to insurance companies, etc. Tip: pay for your “sin” purchases with cash.
- alkonaut 4y agoGovernment backed and transparent doesn’t mean all my purchases are exposed. It’s (technically) possible to have a system of tokens where it’s only known how much I spend for example, but not where. Having (say) transactions under $1000 or $10000 anonymous would make a lot of sense as a cash replacement.
- Beltiras 4y agoYet another dinosaur talking about things he does not understand. How does he propose to do that?
- seydor 4y ago> they enable illicit activity by making money transactions less transparent Given how the most heinous economic crimes of this century were done in official ceremony in broad daylight , maybe there is value to it. Academics are known in general for their controlling nature
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tootie 4y agoYou say that because we know about it because it's transparent. We don't prosecute every crime but we can get some of them and we can deter a lot of them. If you've ever worked at a financial firm they are typically extremely rigorous about compliance.
- seydor 4y agoI mean, the public democratic decisions about finance may be catastrophic. People should have a recourse from the mismanagement of central governments. That's what other currencies do . I don't see why we should not have that optionality
- rvz 4y ago> cryptocurrencies should be shut down. Sorry. You can't just 'shut them down' and the regulators also know it. If that was the case, all these cryptocurrencies would have died much quicker along time ago and we wouldn't be saying 'please shut them down now' today. > He worries that they enable illicit activity by making money transactions less transparent. And this 'illicit activity' is traceable for everyone to see on a public ledger so everyone knows where the money is going such that exchanges find that useful enough to prevent them from cashing out or blocking payments associated with a suspicious wallet address?
- shkkmo 4y agoYou can't just shut them down... But you might be able to effectively halt their use by making it much harder to transfers money out if the ecosystem by making possession of them illegal. I'm strongly anti-crypto but I don't support trying to ban them. I might support a middle ground such as requiring people to be accredited investors to buy them, depending on the details.
- peepeep00 4y ago
- KptMarchewa 4y agoFiat exchange points are completely bannable and would make cryptocurrencies irrelevant.
- rglullis 4y agoNo, it wouldn't. You'd be making exchanges irrelevant and you will be creating the opportunity for the growth of a parallel economy. I can even tell you exactly how it could be done. Take Hub20 [0]. Currently, it is meant to work as a "run-your-own crypto bank" and is only focused on ethereum networks, but it would be almost trivial to add support for banking networks like SEPA (EU) or Pix (Brazil). Given that it works with the assumption that users inside the same instance trust each other, I could setup an instance for myself and add accounts for people that I know personally. Someone in my network could have an account on another instance, and that would be enough to establish a mesh network of unlicensed exchanges. Now that I am thinking about it, you are almost making me wish that we would ban crypto exchanges. ;) [0]: https://hub20.io/about/ https://hub20.io/about/
- acd 4y agoCrypto currencies are also make graphic cards for playing computer games more scarse. A reason graphic cards can be used for mining crypto currencies. Secondly crypto currency proof of compute is power hungry and we have global warming. Crypto currency will probably become state issued with a transparent strong id transaction ledger of who did what.
- xtracto 4y agoI no understand what you talk about, the cryptocurrency I am use (Neo, Cardano, Stellar, IOTA) have no the crypto mine.
- KptMarchewa 4y agoYou don't "use" them, you speculate.
- rvz 4y agoWhy then is 'Stripe?' 'using' them for payments and not for speculation? [0] Perhaps they think cryptocurrencies has a use case as well and must have waited some years for them to improve and pick a few for their use case, before entering in the market again? [0] https://stripe.com/blog/expanding-global-payouts-with-crypto https://stripe.com/blog/expanding-global-payouts-with-crypto
- sumthinprofound 4y ago2019
- Bubble_Pop_22 4y agoWe should use reverse psychology, we should offer crypto-bros to run the entire globalfinancial system via the exchanges and faulty dapps they have built to rug people. With the condition that if one is hacked or malfunctions the responsible crypto-bro would face life in jail. Let's see how many accept
- toolz 4y agoWe might not even need cryptocurrency if we were capable of keeping the financial sector honest. Remind me again how many people went to prison after the market crash of 2008?
- AlexandrB 4y agoFrom the outside, a lot of cryptocurrency seems like an attempt to extend this kind of immunity from consequences to smaller scammers. Where's the improvement here exactly?
- toolz 4y agoA financial system built on top of transparent and trustless components is opt-in. That means that if all my currency is based on trustless structure I can be responsible for my currency and when it's transparent I can be more aware of how the fungible units of my currency are being used in the wider ecosystem. As it stands, private banks (the fed) have not only the ability to manipulate my currency, they are actively encouraged to do so. Sure you can build scams and call it cryptocurrency in similar ways you can scam people in fiat. I'm certainly not claiming crypto solves all problems, only that it provides a solid foundation for society to build a better financial structure on top. That improved foundation does not mean society will build stronger on top of it, it just means that it gives us the ability to do so if we choose to do so. I don't believe it's possible to have equality in our money without rules that apply to everyone. Crypto can apply rules to everyone, equally. Compared to our financial institutions today that are very much tier privilege controlled by the government, which appears to have strong malicious influence from the largest stake-holders in our current financial institutions. I don't believe it's mere coincidence that wealth distribution is becoming dangerously unequal, I believe that is a direct consequence of our financial system.
- djohnston 4y ago"Man who benefits enormously from status quo worried about change"
- criddell 4y agoHow would Dr. Stiglitz be affected by change?
- rglullis 4y agoHe wouldn't, that is why he favors it. He has nothing to lose with such a proposal, no Skin in the Game.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoNo one is using crypto to facilitate legal payments in any meaningful volume. The only people who have something to lose is those who are using crypto to avoid government and regulations around AML and KYC or those getting wealthy in the ponzi.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rglullis 4y agoNo one is using crypto for payments yet because the infrastructure is still expensive and not a viable alternative. There are plenty of use-cases where using crypto can be a better alternative for merchants (no risk of fraud and chargebacks) and consumers (micropayments where the cost of CC processing is higher than the cost of fraud, or purchases where the payee values privacy above all else - think "Ashley Madison" subscribers who'd rather not have their names on the site)
- toomuchtodo 4y agoCheck in next year when FedNow instant payments are live, and you can move up to USD $500k ($25k at initial launch, increasing over time as the system shakes out) at a time for 5 cents per transfer. It is currently in preprod, and being actively tested between hundreds of banks and financial services firms. https://www.moderntreasury.com/learn/what-is-fednow https://www.moderntreasury.com/learn/what-is-fednow https://frbservices.org/financial-services/fednow/community/news/012521-announcing-pilot-program-participants.html https://frbservices.org/financial-services/fednow/community/... https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2020/08/31/fednow-the-federal-reserves-planned-instant-payments-service/ https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2020/08/31/fednow-the-federa...
- ls15 4y agoIn 2011 I expected that governments will eventually try do shutdown Bitcoin and that these attempts will ultimately fail, because it would require most governments to tightly collaborate, which I think will not work out, because of conflicting incentives. Everything is taking much longer than I anticipated... > “I’ve been a great advocate of moving to an electronic payments mechanism. There are a lot of efficiencies. I think we can actually have a better regulated economy if we had all the data in real time, knowing what people are spending,” he says. And he likes this kind of surveillance dystopia? Is he trying to sell us CBDCs?
- KptMarchewa 4y agoIt does not require most governments to collaborate. It would require one government, the one where most users of this site are from. The actual banning of use of cryptocurrenties is irrelevant, the fiat exchange point is completely bannable.
- ls15 4y agoI don't think that a US ban would successfully shut down crypto. Not even a simultaneous US, EU, Russia and China ban. BTC price may adjust accordingly though. > the fiat exchange point is completely bannable. So are drug trades, but the global illegal drug trafficking market is worth about half a trillion dollars.
- evandale 4y agoSomebody needs to explain to me how a government could successfully shut down Bitcoin because I'm incredibly confused when people suggest this. You can't stop people from meeting in person and trading things amongst themselves with cash. Banning cryptocurrency would require the same effort that would be needed to ban drugs and last time I checked the illegal drug market is huge even in countries where there's legal access. How will cryptocurrency be any easier to ban?
- jacknews 4y ago"He worries that they enable illicit activity by making money transactions less transparent." I always have to prefix that I'm no fan of crypto, don't own any, never have, but this seems like a shill to me, and brazenly opposite to reality. Blockchains show every transaction ever, to everyone, albeit the transactees are pseudonymous. But the traditional system is totally opaque to most people. And even to government, when complex webs of tax-haven shell-companies are involved (unless records are leaked, as in the panama papers, etc). So billionaires, mafia groups, corrupt government, get away with all kinds shenanighans, because the transactions themselves are secret. The complete opposite of what Stiglitz is arguing.
- ericd 4y agoLevel 2 chains don’t generally put everything back on the main chain. Lightning, for example, is peer to peer, and then only does net settlement to the main blockchain very infrequently (maybe after a couple months of transactions). This also makes it vastly more energy efficient on a per-transaction basis, the marginal energy cost of a transaction can approach zero. But also, my understanding is that the transaction history isn’t really preserved in a format that would be easy for a government to put together after the fact.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 4y agoGoing further, some L1 chains claim to be anonymous not pseudonymous. Whether that is or remains true depends on the crypto(graphy). Happy to see all this discussion on HN.
- ekianjo 4y ago> He worries that they enable illicit activity by making money transactions less transparent. Oh so you are also against cash? By the way is he even aware of the concept of open ledger?
- sebmellen 4y ago@dang this should have a (2019) appended to it.
- voldacar 4y agoNote the ways in which he uses the word "we". Very mendacious
- stareatgoats 4y agoThere will be a lot of "We should shut down the cryptocurrencies" from different perspectives (combatting crime being one) before it actually happens. But it will likely happen, starting with the US and the EU when it becomes a perceived threat to fiscal policies or national strategic interests, whichever comes first. Within 20 years is my guess, but could be much sooner. What the fallout and consequences will be is harder to predict. I could be wrong of course, some anomaly might be buried here. But almost a lifetime of experience tells me the state structures will protect their interests when threatened. And this has the potential to be such a threat at a certain scale.
- Geee 4y agoSome countries will embrace bitcoin, just like some individuals will. Those who embrace it first, will benefit the most. I think this will be the great divide for this century. Countries with hard money standard and free market economy vs. countries with inflationary money and centrally planned economy. Everyone has to pick their side.
- sudden_dystopia 4y agoThis is exhibit A in why creating an open source monetary system is so important. Because it robs those with all the power and wealth from manipulating the system for their benefit via monetary and economic policies. This is also why most of the critiques of capitalism fall flat in my opinion. Capitalism is not the problem, but the financial system is. The financial systems greed and market manipulation is what people are trying to eloquate when they say things like “unfettered capitalism”. You can have capitalism with an ethical monetary system, we just don’t. But we could.
- oneplane 4y agoSo it's not the system itself, but the greed and manipulation. If any currently existing system could exist but without people's greed and manipulation, would it be as bad as it is now? I think people who have things (imaginary power in the form of numbers in a spreadsheet) will work very hard to make sure that at the very least they can keep what they have, and generally will just want more of the same. Then again, the scope, size and blatant abuse varies from country to country and in some cases gets re-dressed and hidden behind movements, religions, armed conflicts etc. and a universal system for everyone is unlikely to work in the real world, at least not with identity politics and borders.
- entropicgravity 4y agoKnowing about every little thing people buy is as creepy as knowing about every little thing people say. And it's not necessary in the least. There are valid ways to measure cash flows without tracking every individual dollar. In the end cryptocurrencies play a similar role as gold and diamonds; not a great investment but useful as a store of value.
- tootie 4y agoThat's not what he's saying. This isn't for monitoring individual behavior but rather macro trends. We could, for example, provide precise real-time data on metrics like inflation so we could craft better policy faster.
- EveYoung 4y agoPayment providers are already selling this information for marketing purposes. I'm sure policy makers and central banks could already get much more detailed insights if they want to.
- oneplane 4y agoPerhaps. But considering people are already publishing their payments and thoughts on the internet in a constant stream of mediocre mental vomit, I doubt that besides advertisement agencies anything really changes if it was done at a different level. The information availability might change mostly in areas where people are actively trying to hide (regardless if that's for good or bad reasons), but considering the size of that niche (ironically, perhaps also just a 1% of the masses) I doubt the significance of such a change.
- sudden_dystopia 4y agoI’m not a BTC maximalist but I am a fiat currency minimalist.
- tboyd47 4y agoI thought cryptocurrencies were proven to be a bubble, according to them. Now they're a threat!?
- thawaya3113 4y agoBubbles are threats for the economic system? We had a very famous instance of this not even 15 years ago, and another about 23 years ago.
- tboyd47 4y agoYet we didn't "shut down" the internet or housing.
- victorvosk 4y ago"We should shut down a system where everyone can see all transactions because its not transparent, what we really need is a way for the government to track everyone."
- I_am_tiberius 4y agoHe was working for the World Bank.
- game_the0ry 4y ago> "We should shut down the cryptocurrencies." You can't "shutdown" crypto currencies. Technically not possible. Anyone who believes otherwise does not understand crypto currencies.
- ProjectArcturis 4y agoEh, if you made it illegal for banks to transact with crypto exchanges, you could make it a lot less useful.
- 0xcde4c3db 4y agoOr even just apply the regulations transitively to banks, exchanges, and money transmitters (i.e. they can only transact with their crypto equivalents that follow the same regulations).
- game_the0ry 4y agoOperative word being if.
- EveYoung 4y agoMaybe not technically but if the US or EU would ban any business activities related to crypto currencies, the entire ecosystem would collapse. Even if they continue to exist for black market purposes, their real-world usefulness would decline substantially.
- game_the0ry 4y ago> Maybe not technically but if the US or EU would ban any business activities related to crypto currencies, the entire ecosystem would collapse. You won't be able to track people who have and use crypto if the people who use it do it correctly. > Even if they continue to exist for black market purposes, their real-world usefulness would decline substantially. I'll agree with you there, but I do not believe most governments will legislate a full ban.
- faangiq 4y ago
- npc12345 4y agoYou can't. That's the whole point.
- peepeep00 4y ago
- 0des 4y agoLike my grandfather used to say, "if you feel froggy, then leap, boy"
- thegabez 4y agoThis is from 3 years ago. How is this getting voted up?
- frank_bb 4y ago
- Geee 4y agoThis is just pure evil. There is no "we". It's mind-boggling how some economists have become complete puppets for governments. He is just straight up lying in most of his arguments. Economic inefficiency is a problem of the current monetary system, caused by its centralization and inflationary nature, and this is the problem which bitcoin is trying to fix. Most of the issues in the world today are caused by our current monetary system, from wealth inequality to consumerism and environmental problems. He is suggesting that the monetary system should be even more centralized, and we should move into even more centrally planned economy, like in Soviet Union. This time however, they're planning to use big data to solve the economic calculation problem and to control consumer behavior. This is completely immoral, and ends up destroying both personal and economic freedoms in a society. This problem is very well understood, and no one seriously suggests central planning unless they are evil and want to decrease freedom and equality in a society. We already have too much central planning in our current system. Central bank digital currencies would be the last step in this process of completely monopolizing money, and giving governments and central banks the absolute authority of where money is invested and how it is spent.
- bluefone 4y agoI don't see any wrong in what he says. So, crypto is designed for a future where all the institutional banking fails and where political borders don't exist and where no transparency is required. All that it offers is less fee and speed. First of all such future dreamed by the cypto pundits doesn't exist. And many people don't mind paying a little commission to a bank doing my payment, so that they can call the bank and hold it accountable. All this is taken away in the crypto model just for the sake of avoiding a small fee and delay. How many times does an average person transacts across border for which their fiat currency doesn't work or too difficult to use? crypto has too little to offer at the cost of enabling crime and lack of transparency. Why all this is so difficult to understand for these crypto geniuses?
- Geee 4y agoYou have missed the point of Bitcoin. It's not just a payment network, it's a completely new type of money. It can't be inflated, it can't be taken away from you, and no one can stop anyone from using it. It's the opposite of our current, inflationary and centrally controlled money. Bitcoin can take away these authoritarian and repressive powers from governments and central banks. It's not really possible to understand Bitcoin if you don't know how broken our current money is and how much damage it has caused. This website collects stats from the beginning of purely fiat monetary system. https://wtfhappenedin1971.com https://wtfhappenedin1971.com
- hereme888 4y agoPerhaps the worst part about this authoritarian train of thought is that we think these things won't happen if we simply voice our opinion. History, including recent one, shows that "elites" will suddenly shove things down people's throat, passing bills against the vast consensus. I just don't see how a centrally-controlled digital currency can guarantee privacy. Crypto is an idea that arose for a good reason, but it's not a long-term solution. CBDCs are coming though to most countries, including the US (eventually). It's unstoppable.
- thebigspacefuck 4y agoAttempting to shut them down will prove (or disprove) their real value.
- alkonaut 4y agoI completely agree. But only so long as the integrity and privacy is upheld (which is very much possible). The state should now how much I earn and from where, and also how much I spend but not necessarily on what. Anonymous small transactions on a centralized government currency would be a step up from what I do today with 99.999 (or thereabout) transactions being card/digital through systems I trust much less than my government.