3 ms·
Wireless power over radio waves is a dead end. Radio waves go everywhere, great for your cellphone. But completely useless for power beaming. Most of that lost
by grumbler348 4y ago
Wireless power over radio waves is a dead end. Radio waves go everywhere, great for your cellphone. But completely useless for power beaming. Most of that lost energy doesn't go into heat, but into your body.
Lasers are the way to go.
- ben_w 4y agoRadio waves, like laser light, can be directed fairly easily. However, laser light is absorbed by far more things than is radio, which causes them to rapidly heat objects up much more effectively. Some of these things will catch fire, but if the things are water-filled, the effect is much the same for both radio and laser: the water boils until the steam pressure makes them explode. For example, eyeballs. No, if you really want safe beamed power, you probably want something that generally doesn’t interact with normal matter at all, but will act with some specific rare thing that isn’t in your body. Neutrinos would be great from a safety POV, if only we knew of anything that could absorb them usefully so we could turn them into useful energy at the receiving end.
- grumbler348 4y agoTake a look at the diffraction formula and plug in realistic radio frequencies. Even tens of GHz get all over the place very quickly, not to mention the more common place single digit GHz frequencies.
- ben_w 4y agoIt’s also reflected off many surfaces, which is how radar works. And IR and visible light bounces off most non-black surfaces (the latter by definition of the word 'black'). UV is also (with strength varying by frequency) diffused by the atmosphere. But RF needs higher power to become dangerous: Even mere diffuse reflection of 0.5 watt laser light is considered a blinding hazard.
- grumbler348 4y agoReflection is not so scary once you have a wave that doesn't go everywhere but really approximates a point source. And if you go high enough with RF frequencies, you'll get significant attenuation when passing through objects just like with light.
- ben_w 4y ago> Reflection is not so scary once you have a wave that doesn't go everywhere but really approximates a point source. Why do you think that helps? Point-like sources make things worse for eyes. Also, why do you think visible light doesn’t go everywhere? How do you think vision works?
- grumbler348 4y agoPoint like sources can be pointed. That's the whole point. ;) They can be made to not reach eyes, or other places which are not their destination. This is probably very hard to do well, I think there is only one or two companies trying, but at least it is physically possible. With radio waves, diffraction makes accurate pointing physically impossible. Depending on the frequency, within few inches to few tens of feet, your energy goes all over the place, directly and through reflections. And the visible light that goes "everywhere" is not coming from a point source, but from a huge omni-directional source in the sky (sun) that passes through a huge diffuser (atmosphere).