2 ms·
I genuinely think this is an antisocial and unhealthy state to be in, yes. That's a pretty interesting take. I lived in a super dense city in Asia. Almost no
by refurb 4y ago
I genuinely think this is an antisocial and unhealthy state to be in, yes.
That's a pretty interesting take. I lived in a super dense city in Asia. Almost no one lives in a detached home, most live in 30+ story towers. Transit is great and it's pretty walkable - you can easily live without a car. Lots of small stores, not a lot of big box stores. Apparently the pinnacle of the human experience from what you describe.
After living there for a while, it was pretty clear a very large percent of the population wants: 1) to live in a detached single family home with a yard, 2) own a car and 3) love shopping at big box stores and buying online.
What you seem to think is an unhealthy state to be in is actually what a lot of people like. Sure, some people don't want those things - young single people are more than willing to give up a nice home to be close to cool bars, but it's not a very big part of the population.
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoWhat you seem to think is an unhealthy state to be in is actually what a lot of people like. Sure, some people don't want those things - young single people are more than willing to give up a nice home to be close to cool bars, but it's not a very big part of the population. It's just a rhetorical trick. "Everyone who doesn't like what I like is unhealthy" is just a milder form of the age old "everyone who doesn't think like me has some mental condition that I will use as a pretext for denying their agency and ignoring their opinion" reply. It steers the conversation away from the legitimacy of his opinion and makes people on the other side waste effort proving "no I'm not insane".
- decafninja 4y agoUnsure what city you are referring to, but I've lived in Seoul which matches a lot of what you describe. Excellent transit (IMHO, still the best subway system I've experienced in the world), vast majority living in superdense highrise towers. It's one of the few cities I felt I actually wanted to use public transportation instead of grudgingly being forced to (like NYC). Yet most people living there still want a car. Maybe things have changed in the past few years, but last time I was there a few years back, and based on what I see today in K-dramas and shows, it seems most young people still aspire to have a car.