4 ms·
Australia had a much better plan to just make the infrastructure government owned like water pipes or power lines. Then each ISP pays the government for capacit
by Gigachad 4y ago
Australia had a much better plan to just make the infrastructure government owned like water pipes or power lines. Then each ISP pays the government for capacity.
And it would have worked incredibly well but during the rollout, the conservative party got in and caused the countries biggest infrastructure fuckup.
- skissane 4y agoNow they are rolling out FTTN-to-FTTP upgrades, the fuckup is finally starting to get fixed. I think, given some more years, we’ll end up in roughly the same place as we would have been if they’d stuck to the original plan - we’ll just have wasted 15+ years and untold billions on the FTTN detour.
- weq 4y agoMurdoch bought the government to screw the NBN / stop TTN -- so his cable network would profit for longer. its that simple. Australia is NOT the example to follow, its worse then Canada they sold the public network to a private entity who then sold it back to them 10yrs later. EXACTLY the same situation. BUT WORSE!
- Gigachad 4y agoI really doubt that’s the reason. Under the ruined nbn, video streaming was still perfectly usable. And slow internet hardly impacted the streaming companies. It was really gamers trying to grab 100gb updates and workers transferring large files who were hit hardest.
- CamperBob2 4y agoHistory will remember the name Rupert Murdoch long after certain other famous names have been forgotten. The harm he has done will take generations to set right.
- bpye 4y agoHe certainly won't be forgotten in the UK any time soon [0] [0] - https://www.standard.co.uk/comment/comment/anthony-hilton-stay-or-go-the-lack-of-solid-facts-means-it-s-all-a-leap-of-faith-a3189151.html https://www.standard.co.uk/comment/comment/anthony-hilton-st...
- cmroanirgo 4y agoNothing is being fixed for the areas initially promised. My area, rural, was supposed to be the first to go fibre.... but Oz is huge... and so they chickened out and gave the rural guys nothing. The main house still only has ADSL1 (8Mb/s peak, & generally sits around 2Mb with a lot of noise). As such, I use a tethered 4G connection for all internet in my cabin. However, to cater for rural areas, they rolled out Wireless NBN, which is just a dedicated 4G connection and 50% more cost over standard NBN... staying on 4G is cheaper and has a closer tower (so the signal is better). Starlink is starting to look better... (if only I trusted Elon Musk).
- Nursie 4y ago> gave the rural guys nothing And even semi-rural, just outside the main cities, you might find yourself with "Fixed Wireless NBN" that promises to hit 25Mbps at least once per 24 hour period. Broadband in Aus (I'm a recent migrant) is so far behind Europe and so expensive!
- shoo 4y agothe original FTTP plan was never going to FTTP the entire country. most of australia - in the spatial sense of "most" - is sparsely inhabited and fixed-line is uneconomic. the original plan was always satellite + wireless + FTTP, based on density and perhaps a bit of political pork barrelling, and it is quite likely that the original design of which regions would be serviced by which tech was also somewhat optimistic, and might need to have been adjusted, even if the FTTP plan wasn't torn up by the liberal-national coalition (the original FTTP plan was replaced with a "multi technology mix" plan -- the new federal government argued that their plan would be cheaper because instead of laying new fibre, just buy the existing degraded legacy copper lines from telstra, and also buy and reuse the HFC from telstra and optus. so instead of spending tens of billions of dollars of public money building brand new infrastructure, spend tens of billions of dollars of money and reuse existing degraded infrastructure! think of the savings! from memory getting the HFC regions to actually work was a bit of a fiasco, that part of the rollout was heavily delayed. anyhow, it is great to see the coalition lose another federal election, albeit entirely unrelated reasons)
- iptrans 4y agoThe Australian NBN would also have sucked a lot less if the government hadn’t sneaked in usage fees on the network. It is, or at least was, insanely expensive to use the Australian next generation network. It cost ISPs providing service on the network thousands of dollars per month if a fiber customer actually used their gigabit connection, instead of a fixed line rental fee. Batshit crazy stuff.
- Gigachad 4y agoThis doesn’t seem to be a problem. I have a gigabit connection, the whole speed is usable and there are no data caps. It doesn’t cost a huge amount, and I don’t believe the ISP is running at a loss to provide this service.
- iptrans 4y agoUntil recently NBN fiber connections only came with 2 Mbps of bandwidth. Any usage over that was billed at $8 per Mbps to the ISP. In other words, an ISP customer taking full advantage of their gigabit fiber connection could cost the ISP almost $8000 per month. And that was just the cost for the local bandwidth in Australia. Add all the costs for cross connects and Internet capacity in addition to all the normal costs of running a business. Obviously this was and is a millstone around the ISPs’ neck. You can find a plethora of complaints and write ups on the ISP business in Australia illuminating the extremely thin or negative margins in the business. The only thing that kept the ISPs in business was statistical multiplexing at scale and aggressive traffic shaping.
- throw0101a 4y ago> Australia had a much better plan to just make the infrastructure government owned like water pipes or power lines. Then each ISP pays the government for capacity. Concepts involved: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Municipal_broadband https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Municipal_broadband * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-access_network https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-access_network
- throw10920 4y agoIs it a good idea for the Australian government to actually own the internet service, given how authoritarian I always hear about it becoming?
- Handytinge 4y agoWhat you hear is (thankfully) rubbish. Australia is still one of the best countries in the world to live in even with some nanny state policies.