5 ms·
He's making way too many assumptions. In 1894 a writer said that at then current rates of population expansion in fifty years the streets of London would be bu
by rmason 15y ago
He's making way too many assumptions. In 1894 a writer said that at then current rates of population expansion in fifty years the streets of London would be buried in horse manure.
http://www.thefreemanonline.org/columns/our-economic-past-the-great-horse-manure-crisis-of-1894/ http://www.thefreemanonline.org/columns/our-economic-past-th...
Course he didn't foresee the advent of the automobile. Breakthoughs like the horseless carriage come out of nowhere. Something like Thorium could end up generating ultra cheap electricity and in fifty years solar might end up being thought of as a quaint technology like buggy whips.
Our goal for the US should be energy independence, not a slavic devotion to a specific technology.
- marze 15y agoSince solar is less than 1% of US electricity generation, it is unclear why you interpret this to be "a slavic devotion to a specific technology". Solar is the ultimate option of energy independence, since as the OP discusses, 30 lbs of sand turned into solar cells will power a house for three decades or more.
- temphn 15y agoBut it's hard to store energy and to transmit it across long distances. This is the fundamental problem with solar and wind. You can put one of China's new thorium [1] or pebble bed [2] reactors anywhere on the face of the earth, and the wattage per surface area ratio relative to solar will be a great deal less. Solar will likely be some part of the answer but it's always going to be niche relative to oil, coal, nuclear, and (where the region allows it) geothermal/hydroelectric. The question that only experts in the space could answer is whether the $1.25 price per Watt is due to a real decrease in the price of fundamental components/manufacturing processes or whether it is due to subsidies of some kind. [1] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/comment/ambroseevans_pritchard/8393984/Safe-nuclear-does-exist-and-China-is-leading-the-way-with-thorium.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/comment/ambroseevans_prit... [2] http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/25/business/global/25chinaside.html http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/25/business/global/25chinasid...
- marze 15y agoNot hard to transmit solar electric fifty feet, from the rooftop to the iPad charger, pretty much a solved problem. The OP graph showed solar prices falling faster than linear on a log scale. Meanwhile, nuclear and coal plant construction costs are now two to three times what they were a few years ago. Not sure where your confidence solar will be a niche player comes from when the pricing trends favor solar so dramatically.
- brc 15y agoSolar will always remain niche because it can't do baseload power. Sure, there's been some success with solar thermal providing power for 24 hours, but during bad weather there's no chance it's going to do that for a week at a time. Anything that can't do baseload power has to have baseload power backup, which is a large cost of duplicating power. Which is why very few people will every totally rely on solar power if they can get a grid connection. There is no way around the fact that the sun doesn't shine 24 hours a day, and residential power usage peaks after dark. In short, other types of large-scale generation will always outdo solar because it just cannot reliably provide power around the clock. A bicycle is cheaper than a car by an order of magnitude, but can't carry passengers or luggage, can't go long distance, and isn't weatherproof. That's why nearly everyone with a bike also has a car, even despite the massive cost advantages to cycling.
- marze 15y agoSo the question is, is it possible to imagine a system that uses a majority solar? And does it appear to have the potential to be economically competitive? First, however, residential usage does not peak after dark. Peaks occur on sunny hot days when A/C usage is maximum. And since in the US the electric grid already exists and no one is proposing dismantling it, that simplifies the problem. Ten years in the future, iPad-level power consumption will rule for computing machinery at home (iPad == 2.5 watts). LED lights will be common. Solar panels will be the cheapest form of electricity, if current trends hold. Even on a cloudy day, solar PV generates significant power, so about the night? Batteries, either connecting a city's worth of hybrid cars, dedicated battery packs, pumped water storage, compressed air storage, are all options. Others are to run natural gas generators at night, or wind or hydro or geothermal, all grid connected. None of these are particularly difficult to imagine, and combined with efficient lighting and other expected improvements in efficiency could easily be expected to cover residential night time load.
- rmason 15y agoI was referring to government spending on wind and solar companies to the exclusion of competing technologies. Note I am not against government spending for basic research it has paid for itself time and time again. If you consider solar to the "ultimate option" you're closing your mind to other ideas. People have made fortunes betting against conventional wisdom.
- mambodog 15y agonot a slavic devotion to a specific technology I'm thinking you mean: http://www.thefreedictionary.com/slavish http://www.thefreedictionary.com/slavish rather than: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavic_peoples http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavic_peoples
- rmason 15y agoYou are correct. That will teach me not to multitask;<)
- roel_v 15y agoThat is a false comparison, because you're comparing a 'positive evolution' (yield of PV increases) with a 'negative evolution' (amount of horse manure produced grows). What he's saying is that, even without radical breakthroughs, we will reach grid parity in a few years. Of course there may be a breakthrough in either PV or other tech, that will make it only better. What he's saying is that we've reached the point where we can generate renewable electricity. Now we only need to triple the output so that we can have our cars drive on it too, and that industry can run on solar power.