4 ms·
Too many assumptions. The biggest of course is that that "22%" number will continue despite the fact that "the learning rate has been exceptionally high". Anot
by ars 15y ago
Too many assumptions. The biggest of course is that that "22%" number will continue despite the fact that "the learning rate has been exceptionally high".
Another assumption is that natural gas prices will stay the same, when actually they are going down right now.
Not an assumption but rather an omission: He uses a 25 year payback period for solar, but does not include opportunity cost of that money (i.e. how much that money would have brought in interest) over 25 years. Once you include that (and you should) it doesn't look as good. And in any case 25 years is far too long. 10 years is the standard for evaluating payback periods.
6% over 25 years is 4.5 time the base value. So the solar power actually costs 4.5 times as much as he assumes. Even assuming just 3% would give you 2.1 times your cost.
Edit: These calculations are a bit off since they assume paying for the standard power all at once at the end, but actually you make payments throughout.
- biot 15y agoHe says that $700 worth of solar cells would produce 4000kWh of electricity per year which is what the average family consumes. Over the course of 25 years ("a lifetime of household electricity") had you purchased that from the grid, it would have cost $25,000. Ignoring maintenance, you get $25,000 worth of electricity for an initial one-time investment of $700. Though that's production cost, and excludes installation, maintenance, etc. so likely multiples of that at retail. I think you misread the 25 years as being a payback period.
- anamax 15y ago> Ignoring maintenance, you get $25,000 worth of electricity for an initial one-time investment of $700. Though that's production cost, and excludes installation, maintenance, etc. so likely multiples of that at retail. Something is wrong here. Installation is maybe $3k. The typical retail markup is 2x. So, let's call it $5k. 25 years of 4,000kWH is 100,000kWH. $25K means $0.25/kWH, which seems high.
- guimarin 15y agoin south san jose, we pay an average of $.42/kWH in the summer. and it only goes down to about $.31 in the winter.
- anamax 15y agoHuh? I'm in San Jose and my last electric bill was $107 (including taxes) for 587kWH. That's just over $0.18kWH. I'm not on a life-line or time of use schedule. (That's a two family house.)
- biot 15y agoThe article mentions Germany which apparently is quite high ($0.30/kWh as of 2009): http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_pricing#Global_electricity_price_comparison http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_pricing#Global_elec...
- CHsurfer 15y agoThese solar panels are made with many of the same technologies used to make computer chips (or wafers) and much of the rapid cost reduction was possible because the PV industry benefited from the chip producer's R&D efforts without incurring the cost. This effect makes it reasonable to expect similar improvements over the next ten years - as long as there is still a market to justify the costs of transferring the learnings from the wafer fabs to the PV panel fabs. Natural Gas prices took a dip because the energy demand curve took a dip in 2009 and most importantly, a relatively new source of of Natural Gas has been developed in North America, which had previously been a major importer. (http://ferc.gov/industries/gas/indus-act/lng.asp http://ferc.gov/industries/gas/indus-act/lng.asp). Most new power plants in North America and Europe are Combined Cycle Gas Turbines as the relatively low up-front investment, flexibility and (currently)low fuel costs make them the best solution. This should prevent Gas prices from dropping much further. When/if the economy picks back up, the increased demand should further solidify the price of gas. Of course, if the energy supplied by wind and PV grows faster than the overall demand, then this will reduce the demand for Gas, thus keeping prices low.
- redwood 15y agoAlso assumes some kid doesn't throw a brick onto your roof (etc)
- roel_v 15y agoInsurance. A few dollars/month.