3 ms·
I think it is way too common to look at studies of the median person and then generalize to older. Major discoveries are made by top, top people - it seems not
by whimsicalism 4y ago
I think it is way too common to look at studies of the median person and then generalize to older.
Major discoveries are made by top, top people - it seems not unlikely that past a certain age most people cannot remain top. The same is true with chess, which does not have the same administrative duties problem.
- hervature 4y agoBut I think the OP has a point that falling out of the top has nothing to do with cognitive ability. For instance, many researchers become known for certain contributions and then eventually expected to remain in that field. If the landscape changes (say neural networks become the hot topic) then your research might fall in prestige but the level/complexity/quality does not. There are things beyond their control to prevent quick pivots let alone large pivots. A biologist cannot start doing NLP stuff. Then there is the problem of your graduate students who are doing other things and so the momentum to switch is very real.
- whimsicalism 4y agoHm. If someone in their 20s is able to make a major discovery for a problem they only heard of when they were 18, that is maximum 12 years of that line of research, which could certainly be replicated by someone older. you also see people in their 20s make big contributions to many disparate fields, like Tao.
- hervature 4y agoI think you are misunderstanding me. I'm saying that having time in the field is the exact problem. If you have established a pipeline of graduate students and you have 5 of them at various stages of completion. It's difficult to convince new students to join you in a new endeavor because no one in your group does that. Keep in mind, your role as a professor is to take on students. You would also face pressures from your current students to stay in the forefront of your field as that is what they are banking on getting advised from you. If you're 20 years old, you don't care about any of that, you just switch fields.
- spekcular 4y agoI think there are a lot of relevant dis-analogies between math and chess. A chess match at the professional level is a grueling, multi-hour contest, while math research is a lot more chill. Also, the time limit matters a lot in chess. Anyway, you can look at the pages of Annals of Math and Inventiones and see that there is a good mix of ages.
- urthor 4y agoTop mathematician's brains might be outliers. However, I strongly doubt the various parts and cells erodes any differently. Brilliant minds, bog standard glial cells. Their parts come with the same warranty we receive. My experience is that ageing is a very similar process. Acuity and ability in old age follows a very similar trajectory. Use it or lose it. Whether you're an outlier or the mean, use it or lose it applies just as much. The difference is, with top minds I find they receive so much external attention that it keeps them focused on their work in their 50s/60s/70s. All the external plaudits and celebration simply fuels use it or lose it. The brilliant thing is, we can all leverage use it or use it, we just need to maintain our abilities to leverage it.
- whimsicalism 4y agoI am not saying it erodes differently, I am saying measuring median people on median tasks they can perform when they start the study is going to be different from measuring top people on the pinnacle of intellectual achievement, and for those right tail activities you might see degradation earlier that is not caught on median, relatively simple cognitive tasks. Nothing about their brain chemistry being fundamentally different.
- urthor 4y agoSee I think, whether it's outliers or regular people. Use 100% of your brain. That's the most important thing. Revv the engine to 100%.