7 ms·
That's not a limitation of USD, it's a limitation of sleazy crypto exchanges. If I sell stock through my stockbroker, I can have funds in a bank account within
by Animats 4y ago
That's not a limitation of USD, it's a limitation of sleazy crypto exchanges. If I sell stock through my stockbroker, I can have funds in a bank account within hours. You ought to be able to sell BTC and get funds in your account in Chase or Barclays via wire transfer within hours.
But no. Crypto exchanges hate to pay out real money. They don't even like paying out cryptocurrencies to external wallets. They want you to just bet within their closed system.
Real brokerages don't care whether you're buying or selling. They get commissions either way. Crypto exchanges have a strong bias towards your buying what they're selling.
- bombcar 4y agoThe exchanges don't want (or pretend to ignore) the Know Your Customer (KYC) rules, which your brokerage does not. So your brokerage is fine sending you the funds immediately. They also are fine with the audits, etc that are required to prove that they're not playing sillybuggers with your stocks or funds.
- LewisVerstappen 4y agoJust a side note, but it's funny how the Patriot Act is commonly decried by everyone as an overreach of government power & invasion of privacy. But, when you mention these KYC laws (which were put into place in the US by the Patriot Act), no one bats an eye and just assumes KYC rules are reasonable.
- djur 4y agoThe Patriot Act is a broad-ranging piece of legislation, and the anti-money laundering provisions in Title III are less controversial than other titles.
- gabereiser 4y agoParty > Policy
- oarabbus_ 4y agoWhat is unreasonable about brokerages and crypto exchanges being subject to KYC and AML regulations? How is that at all comparable to the government being able to eavesdrop on my private communications and violate my 4th amendment rights without a warrant?
- tylersmith 4y agoFinancial transactions are private communications.
- oarabbus_ 4y agoAnd how does that make KYC unreasonable?
- codehalo 4y agoThis is becoming an increasingly rare sentiment, and oddly even on HN. Thank you.
- oarabbus_ 4y agoYou can simultaneously believe that financial transactions are private communications, and also that a securities broker being required to verify their customer's identity pursuant to KYC and AML regulations is reasonable. Your post is very vague (since the comment you're giving thanks to focused on a semantics "gotcha" and completely avoided the actual point) so I'm curious as to why you think KYC/AML regulations are invalid and brokerages and centralized crypto exchanges shouldn't be subject to them in the light of "private financial transactions".
- supersync 4y agoKYC is the reason we have an archaic banking system while the rest of the world leap frogs us. Tough to solve when petrodollars are still the reserve currency globally.
- lmm 4y agoIn fairness it took me about 2 months to withdraw from an "instant access" account around the new year, because my bank demanded documents that don't exist in the country I'm living in. They also refused to even stop paying me interest that creates a tax liability, so I'm going to have to file a tax return to report less than £2 of interest this year.
- SilasX 4y ago>If I sell stock through my stockbroker, I can have funds in a bank account within hours. Wait, what? I'm pretty sure you're exaggerating there. Stocks have a two day settlement period. (I know because that knowledge gets firehosed every time Robinhood/GME comes up.) Last year when I sold stock in one account (Wealthfront), for the proceeds to deposited into another, it took four business days (edit: using ACH). When I complained on social media, my finance friends said that was typical. Now, it might have been faster with a wire, but it's not the hours you talk about. >That's not a limitation of USD, it's a limitation of sleazy crypto exchanges. It would still be an issue if you want to convert to USD purely on the blockchain because you're interacting with multiple smartcontracts. The USD would need to be a cryptocurrency that lives there.
- Animats 4y agoRobinhood didn't have enough cash on hand for the business they are in. It's not that brokers are required to wait for settlement. They can pay out as soon as the transaction is logged. They have the option of delaying until settlement, but big customers don't like that, so, usually, they don't. Online-only brokers tend to be sleazier about this.
- SilasX 4y agoSo, in other words, if you want cash quickly, you can borrow against an asset? (In this case, the unsettled proceeds of the stock sale.) Good news: you can do that with smartcontracts too! (e.g. Compound/AAVE)
- Animats 4y agoNo, the broker is borrowing against their own assets. They already did the transaction. They just haven't been paid for it yet. It's their accounts receivable problem, not the customer's. That's what it means to be a broker, rather than an exchange. Since brokers usually have transactions flowing in both directions, it's usually a wash.
- 4y ago
- rglullis 4y agoHow about someone on any other country that does not use USD? Aside from some smaller countries in South America and others that fully adopted the USD for their economy, you can not get exchange other assets for USD without significant overages.
- tomatocracy 4y agoNot sure this makes sense. I can exchange USD for my local currency, GBP (including physical notes) for significantly less in commission and bid/offer spread than crypto exchanges charge for crypto to USD.
- rglullis 4y agoTry the same with the Brazilian Real or the Argentinian Peso. Also, try doing that with more than 10k USD. Also, try sending it to someone overseas.
- tomatocracy 4y agoYes - countries with capital controls and/or corruption problems make life harder in many ways. But I'm not sure I understand why stablecoins make that any less of a problem when compared with holding USD in a US based account - unless the point is to avoid AML/KYC requirements. Same for larger amounts and sending money internationally - I've done both quite frequently, and it's much cheaper to do than using crypto would be.
- rglullis 4y agoIn a global economy, it is a lot easier to acquire/transact/hold stable tokens than actual USD, that is the point. If all you care about is the developed bubble, crypto makes little sense.
- lottin 4y ago> unless the point is to avoid AML/KYC requirements That's the entire raison d'etre of these stablecoins.
- svachalek 4y agoI'm not sure why the comment was worded "some exchanges" but notably, this is the only way that a DEX (distributed exchange) can work. A DEX exchanges crypto directly on the blockchain between wallets/accounts via smart contract. These are literally just dapps (distributed apps) and no company needs to be involved; they are the most open exchanges of all.
- saberience 4y agoSo you can get settled by your stockbroker during a weekend? Most payments providers will not settle during weekends and most will settle at T+2 or T+1. Instant settlements and weekend settlements are basically unheard of in the financial and payments worlds, trust me, I work in this world. Stable coins allow almost instant settlement and weekend settlements, that's why merchants and individuals are interested in them.
- Qworg 4y agoStablecoins aren't settlement - even with fiat backed stablecoins, you're an owner of a portion of the most junior debt of a private company. You can pay with them, but you need to convert to fiat to settle.
- renewiltord 4y agoYou can sell VOO at midnight and transfer the money to your bank account? I don't think so or at least I'm not sufficiently privileged to do so.
- Karunamon 4y ago> If I sell stock through my stockbroker, I can have funds in a bank account within hours What brokerage are you using that ignores days-long settlement times? The only way you're actually getting this is a margin account in the background, and that comes with its own risks and limitations. And even then, it takes days for ACH to clear, or fees for wires or debit deposit.
- oarabbus_ 4y ago>If I sell stock through my stockbroker, I can have funds in a bank account within hours. You ought to be able to sell BTC and get funds in your account in Chase or Barclays via wire transfer within hours. This sounds false on several levels. Stock settlement occurs 2 days after the trade executes. Then transferring the money from the brokerage to the bank account via ACH takes 3 business days. Some brokerages may call the cash settled after 1 day, but the ACH still takes multiple days to land in your bank account. Wire transfers often come with fees outside of Credit Unions who may generously waive it but the cutoff time is 5PM EST at best and in some cases earlier than that, otherwise you need to wait until the next business day.
- lmm 4y agoMaybe they're in a country with a bank transfer system that doesn't suck. In most of the OEDC there are free transfers that take <2 hours even in the worst case.