6 ms·
Is he a well regarded expert on this kind of stuff? I've never heard of him, just -- title in the format "<Noun> of the <Dramatic Noun>" tend to set off little
by bee_rider 4y ago
Is he a well regarded expert on this kind of stuff? I've never heard of him, just -- title in the format "<Noun> of the <Dramatic Noun>" tend to set off little alarm bells in my head.
- rfwhyte 4y agoNo, Graham Hancock is an anti-science charlatan. No actual archaeologists take him remotely seriously.
- mistrial9 4y agodescribing people who publish original thought as "anti-something-important derogatory-name" sets off alarm bells for me. Is conformity really that precious? are public writings so black-and-white ?
- nobody9999 4y ago> describing people who publish original thought as "anti-something-important derogatory-name" sets off alarm bells for me. Is conformity really that precious? are public writings so black-and-white ? In that case, I recommend you check out Erich von Danniken[0], Giorgio Tsoukalos[1] and Charles Dawson[2]. They have some original thoughts that have been wildly popular. Or are you saying that if something is "popular" that it's "conformity" and should be rejected for being conformist? If it's generally accepted (as bible dogma in the middle ages was), then it must be a false flag designed to hoodwink the masses into accepting false information, because no amount of consensus is enough. amirite? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erich_von_D%C3%A4niken https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erich_von_D%C3%A4niken [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giorgio_A._Tsoukalos https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giorgio_A._Tsoukalos [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Dawson https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Dawson
- mistrial9 4y agoI met a traveller from an antique land, Who said—“Two vast and trunkless legs of stone Stand in the desert. . . . Near them, on the sand, Half sunk a shattered visage lies, whose frown, And wrinkled lip, and sneer of cold command, Tell that its sculptor well those passions read Which yet survive, stamped on these lifeless things, The hand that mocked them, and the heart that fed; And on the pedestal, these words appear: My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings; Look on my Works, ye Mighty, and despair! Nothing beside remains. Round the decay Of that colossal Wreck, boundless and bare The lone and level sands stretch far away.” -- Ozymandius by P.B. Shelley
- aksss 4y agoCalling people “anti-science” now also sets off alarm bells for me. “Anti-science” is analogous to calling someone a “heretic” in the 1400’s, but with our benefit of hindsight into the fallacy of groupthink and servility to orthodoxy.
- edmundsauto 4y agoEspecially when the field is archaeology, which is a study and not a science. It has its rigor, but it is more of an interpretation of understanding rather than experimentation. Still valuable, still rigorous… but no ground truth is possible.
- tonyg 4y ago> no ground truth is possible. Oof. I have bad news for you about science in general.
- edmundsauto 4y agoEh, I'm not overly proscriptive that science answers all the questions, or that it has the precision people think that it does. OTOH, it has been important for civilizational science, so I'm pretty comfortable saying that it's a good option. More germane to the point, it's probably better to think about "ground truth" as "sufficiently reasonable approximation for the grain that I need to operate at".
- anthk 4y ago>but no ground truth is possible. Carbon 14.
- edmundsauto 4y agoThis is actually a really interesting situation. Carbon-14 resides only in organic matter, and so a lot of stone age artifacts found can only be dated based on what surrounds it. Humans have a tendency to dig down to bury organic matter, which makes it very difficult to understand if the C14 readings are associated with what artifacts. So while we can reasonably ascertain the age of (organic) artifacts, it does not answer the questions being asked.
- icare_1er 4y agoThere has been a lot of precedents of "actual scientists" not taking anti-science charlatans seriously: before the discovery of genes; before the discovery of DNA; before the discovery of tectonicsl before the discovery of the ultraviolet catastrophe. Etc, etc, etc....
- AlotOfReading 4y agoNo. He's widely regarded as a crank. However, he is quite popular. There's a bit of a split between archaeologists that merely think Hancock is an indication that Archaeology's public outreach is insufficient and those that think he's actively harming public perceptions of the field with misinformation. For the record, I'm more in the former camp. Anyway, the SAA (an archaeology trade group) devoted 27 pages of a magazine issue to discussing that split and picking apart the arguments in one of Hancocks's recent books. You can find the magazine here to decide for yourself: http://onlinedigeditions.com/publication/?m=16146&i=634462&p=3&ver=html5 http://onlinedigeditions.com/publication/?m=16146&i=634462&p... For fairness, here's Hancock's response: https://grahamhancock.com/saa-archaeological-record-response/ https://grahamhancock.com/saa-archaeological-record-response...
- bee_rider 4y agoYour "for fairness" response article includes: > [Graham's blog post] Before closing, however, I’m understandably very happy to quote here the useful concise summary of America Before given by anthropologist Jeb J. Card in his contribution to the issue (pp 26-30): >> [Card's review] Attempting to critique America Before: The Key to Earth’s Lost Civilization by Graham Hancock (2019) using the criteria of professional archaeology is doomed to failure, as his goals are outside of the materialist practice of scientific archaeology. In a nutshell, Hancock argues that an ancient civilization of the Pleistocene emerged in North America that was based not on material technology but on psychic/spiritual knowledge. It became a global sea-based society comparable with the late pre-Industrial British Empire. These Ice Age Americans (spoiler: Atlanteans) foresaw a cosmic disaster and spread memetic seeds of sacred knowledge of geometry, astronomy, and the Otherworld and how souls may navigate it around the world. After this civilization was destroyed by impact events from a comet during the Younger Dryas, these advanced people came to be remembered as magicians and gods. Seeking this knowledge today is a path to truly understanding reality and the spiritual elements denied by materialist science.” > [Graham's blog post] Card’s precis of my arguments is fair, and in general I’d say that his analysis of my work and its function is much more carefully thought through than that of any of the other contributors. If the author thinks the reviewer pointing to psychic Atlanteans in his work is treating him more fairly than the rest, that doesn't bode well for the overall work.