7 ms·
"...A Dutch person with a criminal record has a better chance of finding a job in the Netherlands than someone with a non-Western background and no criminal rec
by belter 4y ago
"...A Dutch person with a criminal record has a better chance of finding a job in the Netherlands than someone with a non-Western background and no criminal record, according to a study done by researchers from a number of Dutch universities. Their conclusion is that when looking for work in the Netherlands, ethnicity is more important that criminal records, NOS reports..."
"Study: Ethnic minorities less likely to find work in Netherlands than Dutch convict":
https://nltimes.nl/2017/07/06/ethnic-minorities-less-likely-find-work-netherlands-dutch-convict-study https://nltimes.nl/2017/07/06/ethnic-minorities-less-likely-...
- usrn 4y agoShould this be surprising or even upsetting? The Netherlands isn't like the US, it's an old nation with a very racially homogeneous population.
- yunohn 4y ago> Should this be surprising or even upsetting? While it doesn’t have to surprise /you/, the victims are used to racism so they aren’t surprised either. However, it definitely upsets them because they’re discriminated against and negatively affected, while you are not.
- usrn 4y ago
- nicoburns 4y ago> We're not forcing White people into the middle east I mean, historically that's not accurate at all.
- dvngnt_ 4y agohttps://www.aa.com.tr/en/africa/dutch-colonization-wreaked-havoc-from-asia-to-africa/1075570 https://www.aa.com.tr/en/africa/dutch-colonization-wreaked-h... can't have it both ways
- usrn 4y agoSo was that justified then? I thought we decided that was wrong and stopped.
- yunohn 4y agoThe point being made is that “slavery has stopped” is a meaningless view - when there is still active racial discrimination and modern colonialism.
- usrn 4y ago>modern colonialism What? No one's going into other countries anymore (except the US but this is largely against the will of the people and even this has stopped for now) and colonizing them. The closest would be the mass immigration into developed countries which this prevents. This also robs developing countries of their best workers and keeps them poor.
- yunohn 4y agoPlease educate yourself, you could just Google it. Your bio proudly says you’ve been banned for politics 3 times - I will stop engaging with your obvious racist trolling now. Modern colonialism: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neocolonialism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neocolonialism
- yunohn 4y agoWhat are you talking about? The Dutch were colonisers who owned and imported slaves from various darker-skinned countries. Their descendants continue to live in the Netherlands now and face constant discrimination and peril, like this tax dept scandal. Further, like all “developed” countries, the Netherlands relies on a constant stream of “illegal” immigrants from developing/colonial countries, to support the country’s labor requirements. Given all this, your argument literally makes no sense.
- mikojan 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel
- usrn 4y agoYes but those definitely are not White people. EDIT: If you listen to them they'll agree, most are even vocally anti-White. Israel itself doesn't allow White people to immigrate because they don't want their demographics diluted.
- mikojan 4y agoPardon my humor I didn't realize you were an actual Neo-Nazi
- Scarblac 4y agoMany of these people who are discriminated against _are Dutch_, both in nationality and because they were born there. It is their corner of the world.
- dundarious 4y agoEven on this ridiculous basis, the tax authorities weren’t even so thorough as to assess if they were discriminating against migrants. Merely looking non-western was sufficient. Having the “wrong” nose or hair or skin color or name, or whatever superficial bases they used, doesn’t make you a migrant. Especially given Dutch history with its colonies, there are a lot of such people who have been living in NL for generations. > people with a "non-Western appearance" were subjected to stricter controls
- mc32 4y agoSouth Africa has a pretty heterogeneous population from an ethnicity perspective and they are very protective of locals when it comes to jobs (including some frequent rioting against foreigners) If you’re from up north, i.e. not southern Africa then you will most likely suffer discrimination. So yes, it’s not a particularly Dutch disease, it happens everywhere, including for example Mexico where Mexicans are preferred over foreigners in the great majority of jobs. The US is more an exception to this where we’re welcoming of foreigners by and large —with exceptions of course.
- tomrod 4y agoThere are several places in the world welcoming of foreigners. The US is not particularly welcoming on an absolute scale due to draconian immigration processes and the rise of an authoritarian political party.
- mc32 4y agoYes Singapore and New Zealand but there are barriers to entry for regular folk.
- throwaway2037 4y agoGermany too! I've heard multiple first-hand accounts from highly educated people who immigrated to Germany for work. They enjoy the high quality of life and feel welcomed in their community.
- BuyMyBitcoins 4y ago> The US is not particularly welcoming on an absolute scale due to draconian immigration processes and the rise of an authoritarian political party. Compared to most other developed countries, The United States has a surprisingly permissive immigration policy. Have you seen the requirements to immigrate legally to a country like Switzerland, Australia, Japan, or Israel? The trouble is that so many people want to immigrate to the US - and there’s no feasible way to just let everyone in - the waitlist is massive. We even have a lottery system, where most other nations demand an above average net worth and some kind of in-demand skill. Despite all of this, to some it seems “draconian” that we don’t just rubber stamp everyone who shows up wanting to get in. >” the rise of an authoritarian political party.” I know what you’re alluding to, but both the Republican and Democratic parties have been around since the 1800’s. And, I gaurantee you their modern view on immigration is far more welcoming than how these parties treated immigration in the past.
- formerkrogemp 4y agoIs this surprising? Not if you've been following the case or know many Dutch people. It should be upsetting if you're Dutch. It means that your supposedly egalitarian and democratic society isn't open to everyone. Judging and discriminating based upon skin color and ethnicity is morally reprehensible. Especially in a negative fashion. Full stop. A majority ethnicity does not excuse racism. If anything it makes it worse.
- vt85 4y ago
- j7ake 4y agoIt’s upsetting because Netherlands prides on being progressive and treating people equally regardless of sex or ethnic background. Note there are many Dutch people who are ethnically from North Africa or other non-white regions and they are systematically discriminated against. Netherlands treats white British citizen in Netherlands who can’t speak Dutch better than a Dutch person who looks Moroccan.
- Fnoord 4y ago> It’s upsetting because Netherlands prides on being progressive and treating people equally regardless of sex or ethnic background. Oh no, not anymore. That age is long over, since 9/11 or even before (9/11 was the trigger I suppose). Also, Portugal and USA have a more progressive drugs policy than we (NL) do.
- MacsHeadroom 4y agoMaybe the state of Oregon is more progressive than NL, but not the other 98% of the US.
- belter 4y agoIt is "slightly" upsetting taken into account this was the reason the latest government resigned, and the same prime minister who lied to parliament about it for 6 years...is the head of the new government! Same prime minister also deletes daily his personal official communications :-) "Dutch government resigns over child benefits scandal": https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jan/15/dutch-government-resigns-over-child-benefits-scandal https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jan/15/dutch-governme... "Dutch PM has been deleting text messages daily for years"( Dutch): https://www.volkskrant.nl/nieuws-achtergrond/premier-rutte-wiste-jarenlang-iedere-dag-zijn-sms-jes~b47ba005/ https://www.volkskrant.nl/nieuws-achtergrond/premier-rutte-w...
- Scarblac 4y agoThe percentage of the Dutch population that is either immigrant, or has at least one immigrant parent is now 25.5%: https://www.cbs.nl/nl-nl/dossier/dossier-asiel-migratie-en-integratie/hoeveel-mensen-met-een-migratieachtergrond-wonen-in-nederland-#:~:text=Op%201%20april%202022%20woonden,procent%20een%20niet%2Dwesterse%20migratieachtergrond https://www.cbs.nl/nl-nl/dossier/dossier-asiel-migratie-en-i.... I don't feel that's still very homogenous.
- eldaisfish 4y agoit is. Nearly 75% of the population is homogenous so your point is moot. The Netherlands is no outlier in this regard and systemic racism is common in most ethnostates - see France for example, where the segment of population with at least one non-ethnically french parent is even higher than in NL. The problem is just as bad if not worse.
- Scarblac 4y agoYes, the problem is bad and needs to be addressed. It sounded like you pointed at the supposed homogeneity of the Netherlands as if it were an excuse.
- Tade0 4y agoI'm not racist, so I genuinely don't know: are eastern Europeans considered a separate race? Because it's sort of a public secret that if you hail from one of those countries which joined the EU in the 21st century, you're going to be looked at with suspicion. I suppose it has something to do with the type of people who went to the Netherlands for work right after that was made much easier, but nevertheless it's there.
- rs999gti 4y agoYou have a point. NL was a country of Dutch people. The US was founded as a country built by immigrants.
- yunohn 4y ago> NL was a country of Dutch people. Ah so then NL shouldn’t allow other Europeans in either? Or is this opinion only about non-white people. Either way, the Dutch should’ve thought of that before colonising and enslaving other countries. And then importing slaves to their “Dutch only” land. Quite odd.
- rajin444 4y agoHow can you look at this data and know it’s “racism”? There’s so many unexplained confounds that you can’t account for. It’s “interesting” data, but using it to definitively draw conclusions seems malicious and pseudo scientific.
- Fnoord 4y agoMy family is of Dutch origin. The husband of my niece is from Moroccan origin. He has his own business. He experimented with giving her last name, and suddenly he got way more clients (all pre-covid btw). So they married and he changed his last name to hers. It kind of adds to the problem on one hand but on another this type of assimilation of culture is something you can find throughout history. Yes, foreigners are welcome, but they must adapt and leave a large part of their own cultural identity over time. Its a never ending struggle, and sometimes it goes with more violence (ie. Uyghur concentration camps) than elsewhere. Also, I have a family member who worked at the Dutch tax dept. customer service who got a burnout over this very issue. Because they knew it was wrong.
- rs999gti 4y agoSort of the same thing happened to my mom's family. Her grandparents immigrated to another country (not US) and the natives were very hostile to them because of their last name. They changed it to a native sounding last name and were able to integrate into society. However, on her side of the family, some of the relatives choose to go back to the old last name, so when we have reunions there is a mix of people with the native and original last name.
- throwaway2037 4y agoWow. This is such a deeply personal reply. Thank you to share about your experience. Please don't think this is only the Netherlands. The United States still has similar issues. If you have a name that "sounds Black" on your CV, you are much less likely to get a call for interview. It is sad, and it bothers me to no end. The same will be for people who have traditional Islamic/Moslem names (Muhammed, Siti, etc.). What makes me most hopeful: These investigations and reporting demonstrates a functioning democracy is able to audit itself -- either internally or externally via media. Years ago, I had a Japanese co-worker. We were discussing recent news events in Australia. For whatever reason, Australia was in one of those mini-bubbles of political corruption. To him, it seemed like everyday was some new corruption in Australia! He asked me -- in all seriousness: "Is Australia a corrupt country? Look what we see in the news." I am not Australian, but I mentioned that it was positive the gov't and media was investigating and being transparent about it. That part was the most important to me. In the end, he seemed satisfied with my explanation -- and not excusing the scandal.
- Out_of_Characte 4y agoAlthough similar in nature, it is to be expected that people of similar features and likeness to themselves have the advantage. This is something everyone is equally guilty of and is not specific to any particular organisation or group. But structurally labeling non-westerners for tax fraud is unacceptable. Turn someone away at the border or give them the same treatment as dutch citizens. I dont entirely trust the randomised study for CV'S Because the dutch criminal record system doesn't allow for such discrimination in the first place. When applying for a job that, for example, lets you handle the cash register then you have to apply for a VOG ( Verklaring omtrend Gedrag AKA certificate of conduct ) Which for operating cash registrar you can get your VOG even if you've committed every crime in the book exept if you've previously mishandled money. https://www.government.nl/topics/identification-documents/question-and-answer/how-do-i-apply-for-a-certificate-of-conduct-vog https://www.government.nl/topics/identification-documents/qu... Dutch government is inept at solving problems appropriatly. I dont think the people hurt by the fraud investigations will ever be properly compensated.
- aerodog 4y ago"it is to be expected that people of similar features and likeness to themselves have the advantage" Do you think Chinese prefer to hire their own over European-looking people? Or Arabs in the Arabian gulf prefer to hire their own over European-looking people?
- nemomarx 4y agoI would be kinda shocked if there wasn't some data supporting that? Japan isn't China, but I've heard lots of stories about westerners trying to move there and struggling to get jobs or be accepted into communities. I'm sure this varies by countries, and maybe China is more welcoming of immigration in general, but I would expect some level of subconscious biases in hiring there too.
- mc32 4y agoLook at who is hired in Chinese and Mexican small biz in the US, for example.
- ddorian43 4y ago"... For the study, the researchers sent out 500 fictional application letters and CVs and looked at the responses they received. The letters were all about the same in content, but on the CVs ethnicity and criminal record were systematically varied. The types of crime were also varied - violent crime, money crime and sex crime. ..."