3 ms·
The duration of the war speaks volumes. The commentary may well be true, as personal observations go. But it isn't a winning strategy for Russia, as it stands.
by ggm 4y ago
The duration of the war speaks volumes. The commentary may well be true, as personal observations go. But it isn't a winning strategy for Russia, as it stands. They aren't in a commanding position and they obviously didn't achieve initial war aims.
I do think most "but it didn't work" stories are survivor bias, but against that a lot of wartime mistrust of the Sherman was founded on misunderstood survival. They weren't actually worthy of the ronson nickname, and Patton was probably right to rail against homemade armor additions. Postwar analysis showed Sherman tanks had higher survival rate than people said at the time. It's because crews got out alive, we know crews didn't die.
That said, I think there's an awfully large number of ruined supply chain, light armoured vehicle, and other vehicle videos. They do not look like dud javelin outcomes. Maybe this "half are duds" is like scarecrow shells in the bombing raids on germany: you tell your own guys half the missiles fail to make them feel better. (There were no scarecrow shells: the shells exploding looking like US and British bombers being hit, were indeed bombers being hit, according to Len Deighton)
- wrp 4y agoThis article caught my attention because of the Javelin reference. There is a huge disparity between number of missiles sent over and the number of vehicles seemingly destroyed by missiles. If the Javelins really have a 10% kill rate, the numbers make better sense, even more so if there are plentiful battery failures.
- decebalus1 4y agoI don't think we'll know exactly until after the war ends (and hopefully the russians are pushed back to the '91 borders). There is a huge disparity indeed, but not all of them are concentrated in the areas of conflict right now (I bet a large chunk of them are still in western Ukraine) and the russians were indeed able to target and destroy a couple of weapons transports, so who knows how many of them never even made it to the Ukrainian armed forces.