3 ms·
* I do agree that the title should not be "public" records, as these records are by definition not public unless the FOIA succeeds. The first paragraph of the
by danso 15y ago
* I do agree that the title should not be "public" records, as these records are by definition not public unless the FOIA succeeds.
The first paragraph of the article states that context:
>>A proposed rule to the Freedom of Information Act would allow federal agencies to tell people requesting certain law-enforcement or national security documents that records don’t exist – even when they do.
The debate, of course, is whether or not these scenarios are legitimate reasons to block records requests. It's whether this particular rule change is either needed or allowed by FOIA. The main question remains: In cases where such concerns are legitimate, why is it not sufficient for the government to say: "We cannot confirm or deny the existence of such records"? Why does the government need legal cover to mislead records requesters?
As a civil libertarian, you probably know enough examples of where the government has overextended and abused what it has been granted in good faith.
- tptacek 15y agoThat's such a slippery point that there's no point in discussing it. Our elected government has done many terrible things over the last 200 years. I don't accept that as a rationale for denying it any privilege it might ever ask for, on the grounds that that privilege might be abused. You might believe that though. That doesn't make you bad; it just makes it pointless for you & I to talk politics.