6 ms·
First you have to establish who goes to jail, corporations are able to avoid this by having vague structures of shifting blame so a jury can't decide if any par
by colechristensen 4y ago
First you have to establish who goes to jail, corporations are able to avoid this by having vague structures of shifting blame so a jury can't decide if any particular individual is actually at fault.
There probably should be laws establishing ultimately responsible people with the unenviable duty of being responsible for illegal things corporations do (sort of like an engineer signing off on the design of a bridge), but doubtful such a thing will happen.
We're left then with personal responsibility being limited to people stupid enough to leave pretty explicit records of nefarious intent to commit crimes.
- xanaxagoras 4y agoPick a C-suite exec or VP at random then. "Nobody, it's too hard to unravel the organizational structure" isn't really cutting it.
- verisimilidude 4y agoThat sounds kinda like the Mafia or Yakuza. Take the fall, do time, protect the organization, get respect, get promoted. Many people would gladly do a few years in minimum security prison in exchange for million dollar salaries, etc. While I do think that would be better than nothing, it could create its own set of bad incentives.
- FireBeyond 4y agoNext interview... "Says here you spent time in federal prison?" "Yeah, at my last job, I broke the law and directed others to do so, too."
- saagarjha 4y agoAh so you have experience breaking the law? We have a number of projects where your skills would be useful.
- adamc 4y agoAll decision-makers should go to jail in such cases. Then they would work harder on making blame clear.
- colechristensen 4y ago"All" is a vague term. So jail everyone at Twitter who isn't an individual contributor and is even tangentially involved? This is how you escape consequences as an organization: obfuscation. Make what you've done complex enough that it's too difficult for a jury to decide who is responsible for what, prosecutors won't be convinced they have a case and will decline to pursue the matter.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoI think the CEO should personally be on the hook for widespread organizational fraud, and in cases should be held criminally responsible.
- StillBored 4y agoYah, some personal risk might justify some of the salary package. Yah sure your going to make $50M a year, but you might have to sit in jail for 20 years sounds fair.
- pessimizer 4y agoSomehow they don't have to figure that out with felony murder. Everyone who participates who is aware is liable to the same punishment, then. Why not in crimes of bureaucracy? Why make sure people who are just following orders are free from punishment?
- colechristensen 4y agoBecause killing someone is usually pretty explicit in the obviousness of a crime being committed. Filling out forms, designing product features, and implementing them can have each individual contributor mostly ignorant that anything could possibly be wrong with the request and the few people who do have some idea only have a small one which is plausibly deniable. The person who does get caught in those circumstances is usually just a scapegoat anyway.
- pessimizer 4y agoThat's why you investigate. But awareness should be enough. And if we start to have trouble proving awareness (maybe employees aren't aware of a settlement), just require in settlements that employees are informed. For felony murder, you don't have to know that the person you're with is armed, intends to kill, or if you're driving the getaway car you don't even have to know that they have killed anyone at all. You're participating in something that you're expected to know is wrong, and you're punished for anything that results from the entire event. If this were like felony murder, the engineers that implemented it (assuming awareness) would be as liable for the $150 million as anyone else involved.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> Because killing someone is usually pretty explicit in the obviousness of a crime being committed. > Filling out forms, designing product features, and implementing them can have each individual contributor mostly ignorant that anything could possibly be wrong with the request That's got nothing to do with felony murder. Felony murder occurs when you participate in a crime with someone else and they accidentally kill someone while you can't see them.
- 4y ago
- strangattractor 4y agoHope they keep an eye on Truth Social that requires your phone number even to use it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Beltalowda 4y agoI don't think it has to be that hard; you just need to require that communication is preserved for companies over a certain size, e.g. meeting minutes, emails, etc. This is already the case for financial records and some employment records, and the case with politics ("but her emails!") This way, a record can be subpoenaed if needed. Don't keep records or don't have records of this particular decision? The person responsible for making sure the records are kept for that department will be in trouble. There is some administrative "red tape" here, but it's not that bad, and much of these records already exist (or existed). The problem is the political will to enact such a law; I agree that's not likely to happen.
- colechristensen 4y ago"You have to keep a record of what happened during all employee interactions so that we can prosecute you some day" isn't exactly a likely-to-succeed plan. Already prevalent are coaching employees not to leave records of certain legally contentious topics.
- sodality2 4y ago> isn't exactly a likely-to-succeed plan It doesn't have to gain popularity, be well-liked, or be agreed with by the companies. If it is law, they must follow it.
- oceanplexian 4y agoI worked for a certain rainforest company and they specifically coached us on not leaving records or discussing certain subjects in any form of written communication.
- spiffytech 4y agoEarly in my career I worked at a company that stored customer credit card numbers in clear text in the database. When I learned of PCI compliance, I naively emailed my manager some links on the topic and a note that we might not be in compliance. I was promptly rebuked for leaving a paper trail.
- 4y ago
- dylan604 4y agoMeh, that's why the CEO makes the big monies. "The buck stops here" kind of thing. Charge the CEO. Make it the CEO's problem to prove they were not responsible only by giving up the person that was. I do believe sometimes CEOs are not fully aware of what happens below them in the org tree, but they are accountable for their people. If the CEO can't handle that, then they shouldn't be accepting the roles. Clearly, this has to be understood as part of the job description
- J-Kuhn 4y agoHere is a fictional timeline of events: * Problem: Spammers automate creation of accounts. Solution: Reuse the MFA infrastructure as some kind of "CAPTCHA". The phone number is not stored. * Problem: Spammers use a single phone number to unlock 1000's of accounts. Solution: Store the phone number - so those kinds of misuse can be detected. * Problem: Ads-Team wants to sell more targeted ads. Solution: There is possibly a phone number stored in the user profile, use that. Who is to blame here? The Ads team that didn't check if the number can be used?
- pornel 4y agoYes! There are now privacy laws that explicitly require you to check if user has given consent for such use of the data.
- lkschubert8 4y agoHow about the lowest common leader?
- jeffparsons 4y agoSolution #2 modified to be safer: > Solution: Store A HASH OF the phone number - so those kinds of misuse can be detected. If you don't need to store PII verbatim, don't store it verbatim. > Who is to blame here? The Ads team that didn't check if the number can be used? Yes. 100% yes. It's insane that we've normalized the idea that if you can physically get your hands on some data then that means you're allowed to do whatever you want with it. Anyone even remotely responsible working in advertising should be tracking provenance of the data they're using. I've heard all sorts of excuses about why this isn't practical, but with each year that passes I find them less convincing, and I've finally reached the point where I reject those excuses outright. If you don't _know_ you're allowed to use some PII for marketing, then you _can not_ use it for marketing. It's that simple.
- puffoflogic 4y agoIt would be more accurate to say that organizations avoid this with shifting blame. It happens just as much if not more in government, ngos, etc.