2 ms·
I guess I think the footnote and "paper of record trying to morph into an academic journal" argument is silly. The 1619 articles in the NYT magazine (used in t
by gumby 4y ago
I guess I think the footnote and "paper of record trying to morph into an academic journal" argument is silly.
The 1619 articles in the NYT magazine (used in this blog post as a prior example) were not footnoted. The subsequent book version is heavily footnoted, plus includes info on contributors and an index. This criticism feels like someone complaining about character development in the film adaptation of Lord of the Rings: that's not the nature of the medium.
Relatedly: the NYT is hardly overreaching (and if they were, I don't consider it a justifiable criticism). Newspapers do analysis and inherently do summarization and selection. While most such articles are "small" (i.e. reporting on the recent shooting) they have had large analysis, most notably the Pentagon papers that weren't merely published but extensively analyzed. They do "long form" multi-article analysis all the time, from the recent Tucker Carlson pieces to analysis of the complex timeline of the Jan 6 incident.
The definition of newspaper changes all the time and frankly more long form is a good thing.
(the comments here are orthogonal to any criticism I might have of the NYT in general)
- shkkmo 4y agoI think that if newspapers are trying to take academic tone and content, it behooves them to also adopt some of the rigor that helps that pursuit. I too think that deeper analysis is value-able, but when newspapers do that, they should up their game. If they are trying to present themselves as more academic or scientific, they need more citations and possibly a process akin to peer review (or even submitting a paper with underlying materials themselves to a journal if they are doing original work, as the NYT is claiming to have done here.)
- gumby 4y agoI think it's OK if that material is in the book and doesn't make it to the "paper" part. The audiences are different.