3 ms·
What you should say is "the electoral college system doesn't give me the outcomes I want so we should change it". The electoral college system was designed wit
by refurb 4y ago
What you should say is "the electoral college system doesn't give me the outcomes I want so we should change it".
The electoral college system was designed with intent.
It's like when people complain Congress is deadlocked. Yeah, that's the point, if enough members of Congress can't agree, the it should be deadlocked.
That's a feature, not a bug.
- the_only_law 4y ago> That's a feature, not a bug. In the same way fever dreams are a feature, maybe…
- LordKeren 4y agoI can objectively say that I take issue with the statement “The winner of the presidential election is not the person who received the most votes from citizens” Regardless of the party of the winner. > It's like when people complain Congress is deadlocked. Yeah, that's the point, if enough members of Congress can't agree, the it should be deadlocked. This is a meaningless statement when you consider there is only one president. The person cannot disagree with themself. The executive branch does not have to debate and compromise with itself.
- refurb 4y agoI mean, the Prime Minister of Canada is not the person who receives the most votes. They are the leader of the party who gets the most seats (not the most votes as the last election shows). If the Prime Minister loses in their riding (constituency), they'll actually run them again in another one that guarantees they'll win. So in Canada (and Parliamentary system in general), the voters have even less say in who their executive leader is. The is nothing inherently anti-democratic about not electing via popular vote. The Founding Fathers deliberately designed a system different from "the most votes wins the Presidency". They were trying to avoid the exact scenario that would happen today with popular voting - 3 or 4 states would decide the Presidency alone. Not much point in having United States of America if most of the states had no say in their leadership.
- mrguyorama 4y agoRemember that the electoral college was designed with the same _intent_ that the 3/5ths compromise was. It was desperation to get everyone on board, not sound political science. It was designed to purposely give smaller states outsized voices because that's what it took to convince a small state to give up total autonomy to this new, untested, group of states thing.
- refurb 4y agoSame intent? You mean deny full voting privileges? Can you provide a source? I mean, the way the Bill of Rights was written was the same intent - to get everyone on board. But I’m not prepared to throw out the first amendment because of it.
- TheCoelacanth 4y agoIt was designed with the intent to allow slave-holding states like Virginia with huge populations but that allowed hardly any of them to vote to not get outvoted by smaller states that allowed all male inhabitants to vote. The intent it was designed with is the worst part of the electoral college and was fundamentally unjust and corrupt.