4 ms·
It's certainly ironic that they haven't released such information, considering their alleged function & goals.
by sliverstorm 15y ago
It's certainly ironic that they haven't released such information, considering their alleged function & goals.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- rimantas 15y agoIt's not ironic, this was one of the points for me "writing them off". Wikileaks reponse to inquiry about their financial matters was basicaly "none of your business" and since then I see them as Assange's personal PR tool, nothing more, despite the claims.
- sliverstorm 15y agoSo much for transparency.
- todsul 15y ago^ strawman
- skeptical 15y agoBefore jumping in quick judgement you guys should be aware that giving away such information will simply generate a lot of attack vectors by those who want to take down wikileaks. I'm not even saying I agree or disagree with wikileaks itself, but heck, considering the amount of pressure they get from everywhere, giving away information about how they spend their money would be plain stupid and would take them down in a eyeblink. Just two cents.
- untog 15y ago"you guys should be aware that giving away such information will simply generate a lot of attack vectors by those who want to take down wikileaks" Same as governments, then.
- mrleinad 15y agoAha.. but does Wikileaks affect your life if they hide that information from the you? Indeed, this is a strawman argument. Governments shouldn't hide information from people. That's the point.
- astine 15y agoYes, yes it does. What if Wikileaks is taking especially large donations from powerful interests and chooses to censor its output as a result? To say that transparency only applies to governments is to miss the whole point of transparency. If that is indeed Wikileaks' position as you say, then they've missed the point from the get-go.
- burgerbrain 15y ago1) clearly this is not the case. stretching much? 2) that would only be effecting your life through inaction. defunding wikileaks would have the same effect.
- mrleinad 15y agoNo, it doesn't. If you don't support Wikileaks you can choose not to donate money. You can't choose not to pay your taxes (at least without breaking the law). You can choose the kind of politicians you vote, but again, those politicians may choose to do something else with your money when they have the power. If you do support WL, and believe in what they have achieved so far, I think that it's wise to trust them, given the amount of criticism they face from almost every government in the world. I haven't read about any government denying anything that was published, but I've read a lot about those governments trying to censor what is published. So, who's the censor here?
- burgerbrain 15y agoThe key difference of course is that they are not a government. If you knew the slightest about Assange you would realize that he has always been a campion of individual privacy, while he at the same Itime attacks the privacy of nations and nation sized organizations. It takes some seriously warped logic to see hypocrisy in this, but hell, americas seem to think corporations are people, so I guess I shouldn't be that suprised.