4 ms·
Approximately two months ago AutoBild made a range test with several models. "German AutoBild March 2022 – EV Range Test at Highway Speed" (In German): https:/
by belter 4y ago
Approximately two months ago AutoBild made a range test with several models.
"German AutoBild March 2022 – EV Range Test at Highway Speed" (In German): https://www.autobild.de/artikel/e-auto-autobahn-reichweite-test-tempo-130-km-h-20977681.html https://www.autobild.de/artikel/e-auto-autobahn-reichweite-t...
They Tested 28 Models - Top 10:
---------------------------------------------
Mercedes EQS -> 444 km ( 276 Miles)
BMW iX xDrive 50 -> 434 km ( 270 Miles)
Ford Mach-E GT -> 367 km ( 228 Miles)
Audi RS e-tron GT -> 367 km ( 228 Miles)
Porsche Taycan 4S -> 352 km ( 219 Miles)
Tesla Model 3 Performance -> 337 km ( 209 Miles)
VW ID.4 GTX -> 332 km ( 206 Miles)
VW ID.4 Pro -> 328 km ( 204 Miles)
Audi Q4 e-tron 40 -> 326 km ( 203 Miles)
Skoda Enyaq iV80 -> 316 km ( 196 Miles)
---------------------------------------------
- lelag 4y agoSuch a meaningless article as it does not take battery size into account... Sure your EQS has 444 km but have fun recharging that 107 kwh monster battery... The name of the game is efficiency and here are the result in that test: | Model | Range KM | Battery (kwh) | Efficiency | | ------------------------- | -------- | ------------- | ---------- | | Tesla Model 3 Performance | 337 | 75 | 222.55 | | Mercedes EQS | 444 | 107.8 | 242.79 | | VW ID.4 GTX | 332 | 82 | 246.99 | | VW ID.4 Pro | 328 | 82 | 250 | | Audi Q4 e-tron 40 | 326 | 82 | 251.53 | | Audi RS e-tron GT | 367 | 93.4 | 254.5 | | BMW iX xDrive 50 | 434 | 111.5 | 256.91 | | Skoda Enyaq iV80 | 316 | 82 | 259.49 | | Porsche Taycan 4S | 352 | 93.4 | 265.34 | | Ford Mach-E GT | 367 | 98.8 | 269.21 | The real winner is Tesla by a large margin and LR and SR version are ever more efficient than this. Also I find the result of the EQS suspicious low given the weight of the vehicule, whereas the Tesla's consumption is surprisingly high. I don't think it should be over 200wh/km at 130km/h under normal conditions.
- kken 4y agoWhat unit is "Efficiency" in? Wh/km? It's interesting that VW seems to use a standardized 82kWh battery back in their MEB platform and achieves basically the same range as the Tesla 3 with 75kWh. Appears this is engineered to the point. Why is Teslas Efficiency 10% better? My understanding is that they use SiC transistors in their inverter while the MEB uses Silicon IGBTs. A trade-off between reliability (Si), cost (Si), performance (SiC). How much of the difference is caused by this?
- lelag 4y agoYes, wh/km. I don't know why they get better efficiency but I suppose that they still have some significant technological advantages compared to the others.
- Delphiza 4y agoSame as for ICE? Better weight to power ratio. Less drag (aerodynamics, wheels). Plus better EV tech? More efficient power curves. More efficient regenerative braking.
- bjelkeman-again 4y agoEfficiency seem to be Wh/km. During the summer, with mixed driving I get about 168 Wh/km, and year round 185 Wh/km in a Tesla Model 3 AWD. Not everyone needs to drive autobahn speed. ;)
- clouddrover 4y ago> It's interesting that VW seems to use a standardized 82kWh battery back in their MEB platform and achieves basically the same range as the Tesla 3 with 75kWh The table is mixing net (usable capacity) and gross (total capacity) battery sizes. The battery in the ID.4 is 82 kWh gross but 77 kWh usable. The ID.4 is also an SUV model whereas the Model 3 is a sedan.
- lelag 4y agoWell, Tesla also has a buffer after 0% and still some energy after it stop moving. This might be what explain the "bad" figure here. A model 3 at 130km/h on the flat in good weather conditions should not exceed 200wh/km normally. (Based on experience with my own car). My point was that the posted article is non-sense, and likely really just an advertisement piece for the german cars. Claiming the EQS is best because it has a decent range with a 107kwh battery is infuriating. We should be moving to smaller battery on light efficient vehicles and not make monster 3 tons EV like this.