3 ms·
... Give $11,000 to each household making under $50,000, and you're in essence paying all of that towards households making over $50,000. Some people are poor
by potatolicious 18y ago
... Give $11,000 to each household making under $50,000, and you're in essence paying all of that towards households making over $50,000.
Some people are poor because they're honestly down on their luck, and need a helping hand. The majority on the other hand are simply unemployable, or horrible with their finances. Give them a handout and the money will simply end up in richer people's hands. That's not helping them.
- nostrademons 18y agoHowever, if you gave $11K in seed capital to anyone making under $50k who has a viable plan for a business with the promise of a few hundred K more if they started showing traction, then you might shake things up a bit. ...wait, isn't that YCombinator?
- steveplace 18y agoI don't think the yC model would scale up to 700B. I think it would be a great experiment, though.
- MaysonL 18y agoGrameen bank?
- Retric 18y agoHey, I was working with a college degree for 3 years before I broke 50k. At the time I was investing 8% of my income and I was still eating out all the time etc. I think the bar for poor needs to be a little lower than 50k/year.
- HeyLaughingBoy 18y agoHow many kids were you trying to support?
- gambling8nt 18y agoFamily size for $50k to qualify under the federally mandated definition of poverty is 12. In fact, $50k is approximately the median household income (for 2007), with mean household sizes in that income bracket at about 2.6.
- sfamiliar 18y agoIs a collage degree made up of other degrees that are cut apart and then pasted back together to form pretty pictures? (couldn't resist). I wasn't shooting for the poor. I was shooting for a bunch of people. It's roughly half of the households in the country. That's a lot of liquid capital to inject into the economy at once -- around 5% of our GNP.