4 ms·
> control data produced within their perimeters societies, and our regulatory frameworks, need to move beyond the idea that "data is produced and resides withi
by andsoitis 4y ago
> control data produced within their perimeters
societies, and our regulatory frameworks, need to move beyond the idea that "data is produced and resides within a particular geo". Not only is it not, it is also holding us back from leaping forward / bootstrapping into the beyond-meatspace.
- lazide 4y agoGood luck with that when if you’re going to be prosecuted for a felony or not depends on said meatspace location.
- ddingus 4y agoTake their point of view: why do they need to do any of those things? What is in it for them?
- FredPret 4y agoHere's the opposite point of view: if the bulk of value is created in the ether, why are they relevant at all? All a rich nerd needs is a protection from criminals - whether paid for publicly or privately.
- ddingus 4y agoThe question I posed may speak to how it may be possible to get these entities to move toward a more preferable world view. A rich nerd needs more than criminal protection, BTW. Just a few basics: Without the machinery of society running well, wealth becomes quite burdensome. The nerd needs said wealth recognized, means to transact, enforce contracts, currency to trade with, and all that depends on courts and governments of some kind. And there is more. I just sort of stopped. There will be value in the "ether", but it will also intersect real space and there is the relevance. Talking about this is sort of like those free energy machine discussions where everyone excited about the machine potential forgets about the initial energy input and how entropy will bleed it away however slowly. Wealthy nerds do not just appear and create in a vacuum. And no judgement on the idealized nerd being discussed. Could be a wealthy anyone! A poor nerd needs the same protection as well as the means to do all the basic human stuff needed to exist and practice nerdery. (I laughed at that being a defined word) In terms of being a nerd and creating ethereal value, it looks to me like assuming wealth just makes it considerably easier to ignore where this stuff meets up with reality, a lot like some free energy machine presentations end up compelling enough to sideline the initial energy input...
- FredPret 4y agoFair points all. I meant my comment mostly in terms of negotiation. Rich nerds don't pop into existence out of a vacuum, but now that we exist, we can move to the country that suits each of us best and do the same work with roughly similar incomes. Yes, we still need the common infrastructure, but for the most part, I need a fast internet connection and a lack of bullets coming my way. This drastically reduces the hold any one country has over me, which is what allowed me to wave goodbye to my country of birth and move to a country where I like the tax/spend pattern more (Canada). Theoretically, one could site all earning, investing, and banking in some tax haven and just use a credit card to transact. We'll still need countries, but they will be more like regular infrastructure providers (civilization as a service?).
- ddingus 4y ago"for the most part" Let's talk about farmers and fields for a moment: Early on in human history, the first farmers began their work with fertile ground. Mistakes were made, understanding gained, improvements were also made. And this is just humans being humans. Over time, it was observed the earth can become parched when farmed too many times without putting some of the yields back into the soil. There are no free lunches. Every so often, it is necessary to invest in the earth so that it remains fertile and yields bountiful. Farmers, having once learned this, continued to do it, and everyone is living in relative harmony. Along comes big Ag. Good yields are not good enough. They want the maximum, and they ignore history and proceed to max the ground out, and of course it becomes parched. Rather than invest in the maintenance of fertile ground, which requires some crops be grown to be turned back into earth, they treat the ground chemically and continue. And now there is a top soil problem where there was once fertile ground. And so they basically mooch top soil from somewhere else, and on it goes. Turns out those high yields are quite expensive for everyone else! Now, let's look at what you say you need: For example, what gives that fast Internet connection value? A wealthy society in which to derive that income! This is fertile ground. See where I am going with this? What happens when that wealthy society is not maintained? In other words, what happens when the ground becomes parched? Bullets, among many other things like it being harder to get that income due to lower demand as greater numbers of people struggle due to growing economic problems and those are generally due to labor not paying what it costs for people to actually exist and show up for work and perform that labor, and also generally due to debt accumulation in the form of "parched" societies in serious need of reinvestment. It's great to maximize it for you, thinking of only your considerations as if the rest of the world just comes gratis. It doesn't you know. Really, this is all no different from the farmer who does not see the need to reinvest in their ground. What they do is get all they can and when that ground becomes parched, they call it someone else's problem and move to new, fertile ground where they wash, rinse, repeat, until they have a lot of wealth accumulated and have left behind a lot of parched ground for others to restore to being fertile, and doing that isn't cheap!! That farmer could have invested in their ground, still could have accumulated considerable wealth, but would not be costing everyone around them very large sums of money while doing it. Nobody exists in a vacuum. Everything costs something. And if you are not paying it, someone else is forced to, and or where it's not paid, other costs and risks, such as bullets, tend to follow soon after. That's it. Ideally some food for thought regarding "needs" being far greater than the idealized picture you put here.
- enasterosophes 4y agoWe did move beyond it, and what we got for it was covert operations infiltrating social media to influence national elections, along with various large organizations suffering ransomware and other hacking over the last few years. Even if you could go back to the wild west days of the 90s, most people these days would just complain about how people could go ahead and say whatever they wanted without being cancelled. We started with the dream you're referring to, and it couldn't stand up to the crappiness of reality.
- CryptoPunk 4y ago
- bitwize 4y agoYeah, we said that in the 90s too, that was the thesis of high-minded bullshit from the era like the "Declaration of Independence of Cyberspace". Look where it got us. There is no sphere that is outside the government's control. None. Create one, and the government will come round to enforce its will on it.
- pessimizer 4y agoCopyrights, patents, censorship and other kinds of monopolies on information are to human civilization as plaques are to an Alzheimer's-afflicted brain.
- yardstick 4y agoCopyrights and patents are quite different to censorship. Copyrights and parents provide assurances that spending large sums of money (millions/billions) to create new technology won’t be in vain. There are issues with both (too long copyright, patent trolls, obvious patents) but they are better than not having any protections. Why would anyone make a movie or game if it’s going to be almost exclusively pirated? Would anyone invest in new camera technologies, computer graphics techniques/algorithms, motion capture tools, etc? Why would anyone spend millions/billions creating new vaccines and medicines if anyone could copy them and they weren’t going to get paid for their research. Good will only goes so far. You’d only do it if the budget (risk) was peanuts, and unfortunately innovation needs money. People need a roof over their head and food on the table. Which would leave only rich governments with the means to fund such advancements, and their ideology often won’t be aligned to such endeavours.
- rhn_mk1 4y ago> they are better than not having any protections. People keep saying that, but no one comes up with any data to back up the assertion. > Why would anyone make a movie or game if it’s going to be almost exclusively pirated? Because they like it? See: 0AD, Nexuiz, Battle of Wesnoth. > Would anyone invest in new camera technologies, computer graphics techniques/algorithms, motion capture tools, etc? I read someone posing this question and proposing the answer that yes, patrons are going to crowdfund what they want to see. > Why would anyone spend millions/billions creating new vaccines and medicines if anyone could copy them and they weren’t going to get paid for their research. Good will only goes so far. Wait a minute: > they weren’t going to get paid for their research. Lack of protection is not connected to lack of remuneration. US government spends millions/billions to get data from the outer space, despite that data not being protected. > innovation needs money Makes me wonder how the innovation of money came about before there was money to spur innovation.
- imwillofficial 4y agoReality is going to rudely awaken you in the not so distant future if that’s the way you think the tide is turning.
- gjvnq 4y agoFor this to happen, we would need all the world to have compatible laws. Doing that without eroding national sovereignty is essentially impossible. We would need something like the European Union for all of humanity. And even the somewhat limited powers delegated to the EU were enough to cause serious backslash as we have seen during Brexit.