11 ms·
Bicycles Have Evolved. Have We?
- twobitshifter 4y agoI don’t understand the last sentence about avoiding the inevitable e-bike. The inevitable part I agree with, but the dislike from others has never made sense to me.
- vondur 4y agoThere is a ton of e-bike hate in the mountain bike world. And e-mountain bikes are pedal assist, no throttles.
- bombcar 4y agoFor those who feel there’s a big divergence between mountain bikers and dirt bikers (the second group having motors) the ebike is a frightening combination.
- h4waii 4y agoIt's a real shame this happens, e-bikes are such a fantastic way to lower the bar to entry and get more people on bikes, outdoors, and exercising. Yes, like all things, there are jerks who will ruin it for everyone else, which is unfortunate when it seems to be a net benefit.
- wrycoder 4y agoWe have a dirt rail trail nearby. There was this guy running one of those big wheel power skateboards. With a big cloud of dust behind him.
- ciupicri 4y agoIf all you want to do is exercise, why use an electric motor in the first place and not only your legs?
- oh_sigh 4y agoBecause no one wants to solely exercise. They want to have some fun while doing it. This is like saying that if you only want to exercise when skiing, then you shouldn't take a chair lift - just use your legs!
- seoaeu 4y agoIf all you want is exercise, you might as well just go to the gym and ride the elliptical. But most bikers like the experience of seeing the outdoors and covering distances. With pedal assist, you still get exercise but also are able to ride faster and for longer.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoThere's a subset of MTB riders who only bomb downhills and take a shuttle back to the top. An e-bike cuts out that middle man.
- twobitshifter 4y agoI read a great article that I can’t find right more showing why e-bikes are a boon for accessibility in national parks. We don’t want to close off the natural world to only those in peak physical shape.
- rootusrootus 4y agoPretty sure this entire thread could be summed up by: There is a ton of <X> hate in the <Y> world. Cars, bikes, iPhones, Androids, dogs, cats, you name it, everything is a team sport you have to win.
- idontwantthis 4y agoThe author longs for an environment that doesn’t force her to be more like a car in order to justify living.
- colinmhayes 4y agoEbikes are much more like bikes than cars. Biggest difference is you don’t need to shower when you get to work.
- KennyBlanken 4y agoYou don't need a shower when you get to work on a regular bike, either. You just need to slow down and budget more time for your commute. That's it. Slow down. I have given this advice to multiple people who were new to bike commuting and every single one looked at me like I was a Martian. A week later they said "You were right!" I've biked in one hundred degree weather and arrived in barely a light sweat. Yes, I put on hiking shorts which were passable, and the lightest athletic shirt I owned, but I didn't need a shower. I just budgeted a bunch of extra time that morning, and barely pressed the pedals, whereas usually I'd be pedaling decently hard the entire way, even down hills. Because I was expending virtually no effort - biking is more efficient than walking - and had a ~10mph breeze - I was comfortable. It helps that I eat a decently varied diet so I don't have horrific BO, use soaps that aren't loaded with shitty artificial scents and chemicals, and wash my clothing with no softener and "free" detergent that lacks any sort of perfume.
- rectang 4y agoWhere I live (San Diego), they're big, heavy, mini-motorcycles zooming past others at top speed in narrow bike lanes. Is the hate for that so hard to understand?
- oh_sigh 4y agoYes, because we have the ability to differentiate reasonable vehicles from unreasonable vehicles regardless of their designation. E-bikes with pedal assist seem ok. E-bikes which are basically just electric dirt bikes don't seem ok (for bike lanes).
- joebob42 4y agoThe pedal bit seems unimportant, I feel like the only relevant distinction is the actual top speed.
- oh_sigh 4y agoI agree logically, but an important point is that pretty much any pedal assist on the market will have a top speed only marginally faster than a biker's actual top speed - compared with the pure e-dirt-bikes which are exceptionally faster than most biker's top speed.
- ggm 4y agotwo avid cyclists I know, (off road) say that the ebike has revolutionised "cycling together" for people of different abilities and pedal cadence. She can now keep up with him, for a 60km ride, compared to 20km before. Same amount of physical effort, more companionable, better outcome overall. As a non-ebike rider I admit my lack of peripheral vision (age) is making the zoom! of an ebike or scooter past me increasingly scary, but the fact is, my declining vision is more of the issue than the ebike is.
- Zigurd 4y agoI think the author is just being wistful about ageing, which is inevitable. E-bikes should take over in most cities. All but the most disabled can ride them. Cities like Taipei and Barcelona that already move on scooters would get much cleaner air and have the same low-cost mobility. New York makes no damn sense for cars. Even large spread-out cities are easily traversed on e-bikes. Assholes on e-bikes can be annoying but rarely deadly. Drivers who kill cyclists should be imprisoned until too old to drive again. Cars should all be required to have passive braking that won't come within 6 feet of a cyclist or pedestrian. regarding pedestrians, we could start by recognizing that "jaywalking" isn't a thing.
- KennyBlanken 4y agoBikes are not ride-able for lots of people with disabilities, but trikes reduce that number dramatically, yes. Rehab hospitals often have fleets of recumbent or regular trikes because nearly everyone can use them, and they can be hand-pedaled.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoe-bikes are an albatross if you have to carry them up stairs.
- twobitshifter 4y agoBut the problem there is not the bike itself, but theft right? There are many types of bike lo-jack that can be integrated into an e-bike.
- Zigurd 4y agoProblem is cops don't care. I find this to be an interesting opportunity: Brutal cops are currently a large liability on municipalities who have to pay out for their misbehavior. Instead, make these cops the bike thief patrol and organize a public cryptocurrency tontine that pays out to the cops when they beat the snot out of a bike thief.
- 0xcde4c3db 4y ago> “I don’t think a lot of Americans are aware . . . how far behind we are on bicycle and pedestrian safety,” Pete Buttigieg, the U.S. Secretary of Transportation, said. Republicans warned, “Democrats are coming for your cars.” No one is coming for your cars. I'm actually surprised that there isn't more direct action against overly aggressive drivers, "rolling coal", and the like, given how passionate cyclists often are about being cyclists. It's amazing how so many of them seem to take gratuitous threats to life and limb in stride. Perhaps that's survivorship bias, inasmuch as the people who don't have this reaction stop cycling instead (at least on roads).
- tjr225 4y agoCyclists in the US are mostly well aware of how hated we are for even just basically following the law and somehow surviving with motorists who probably shouldn’t be allowed to drive.
- rootusrootus 4y agoYou unfairly blame motorists. They are pissed off because bikes don't belong on roads, but politicians make them ride there. They'd be angry if you drove the same speed in a car, too. Blame the politicians for refusing to fund separate infrastructure so bikes, cars, and pedestrians don't have to share the same piece of asphalt. As a car driver I don't want bikes in the lane with me. And as a pedestrian I don't want them on the sidewalk with me. We know the solution but refuse to implement it.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoThey do belong on roads. Paved roads were created for bicycles. The law classifies them as road vehicles. You are required to know the vehicle code in order to qualify for a drivers license. Right of way precedence is one of them. Being "pissed off" because another citizen is exercising their rights within the law isn't an excuse to harm them without repercussions.
- 4y ago
- adolph 4y agoI supposed that bicycles evolve to suit a lot of people's different ideas of whats fun. I'm glad that I was introduced to the joy of less and I salute Sheldon Brown on the road beyond for inspiring so many to take a second look at something simpler. https://www.sheldonbrown.com/fixedgear.html https://www.sheldonbrown.com/fixedgear.html Are you sure you need a bicycle with gears? The purest, simplest kind of bicycle is the fixed-gear bicycle. Riding a fixed gear will make you a stronger, smoother cyclist...and it is a ton of fun!
- rootusrootus 4y agoWhere I live, it would also dramatically limit where you could ride. Different strokes for different folks, I'd hesitate to call one choice objectively better than another.
- adolph 4y agoFor certain true. I’m glad that bikes continue to capture people’s ingenuity. Single speed isn’t just for flatlanders tho. My first exposure was of a guide in the hills of Sedona, AZ. Edit: AZ, not NM.
- eesmith 4y agoIsn't it better to succeed by the artifice of a derailer than to fail by the strength of your muscles?
- adolph 4y agoPardon me, I meant no disrespect for assistive devices, one of which is the entire bike. My intent was to follow the article in recognition of cycling’s joys and add that not all evolution is an accrual of features.
- eesmith 4y agoI inverted Desgrange's quote from the "Are you sure you need a bicycle with gears?" section to point out how the essay contains many assertions which assume the consequence. Pointing to that page therefore seems likely to cause non-fixie enthusiasts to turn away. I'm glad that you and many others enjoy fixed-wheeled bicycles. Fixies = good. Gears = good. Cargo bikes = good. Bakfiets = good. More bikes = good.
- nazgulnarsil 4y agoebikes create a shift in how we should build neighborhoods, if not cities. The quality of life frontier has already shifted out from under the previous equilibrium: living in a place where you can comfortably ebike to amenities is a massive life upgrade.
- burlesona 4y agoI could not agree more. I’m a few years from the financial independence I need to pursue this fully, but my life dream is to build a large neighborhood / small town exclusively for bikes and pedestrians (minimal car access for deliveries etc worked in following Dutch safety standards).
- SoftTalker 4y agoSteve Jobs said almost the same thing about the Segway. He said it we would design cities around it. How often do you see one in use? The reality is that most people don't like to cycle. They like to drive. They like to be protected from the rain, cold, heat, and other vehicles as they move from place to place. Especially if they have kids, or elderly passengers, or have to move stuff with them, or have to travel any appreciable distance. eBikes are good for out-of-shape people who think they want to start cycling, and not much else.
- philips 4y agoI take my children to school in the rain regularly with this. Covered areas for ecargo bikes are relatively common. https://www.ternbicycles.com/us/accessories/471/storm-shield https://www.ternbicycles.com/us/accessories/471/storm-shield
- sam_lowry_ 4y agoBakfietsen are even better.
- sunstone 4y agoIn 2020 the Netherlands bought more ebikes than pedal bikes for the first time. They also paid on average $2000 for their ebikes compared with $1000 for their pedal bikes. So in terms of dollars (or Euros) the market in the Netherlands is now 66% ebikes. What people in the Netherlands found was that an ebike would allow them to do errands up to a distance of about 15km whereas with a pedal bike the distance was more like 5km before they would take their car. My experience is similar. Ebikes in practice are more like a smaller car than they are like a bigger bike, when the roads or bike paths are suitable.
- UI_at_80x24 4y agoAn article about the evolution of bicycles and not one word about recumbents. I saw my first recumbent bike as a child in the 1970s. I didn't know what it was but I did know that it made sense to me. I have been riding a recumbent (as it turns out, not that different then the one I saw over 40 years ago) for over 12 years now; and it's contribution to changing my interaction; no, my relationship with the world around me cannot be overstated by calling it eye-opening. In my teens I was at competition level cycling. But coming from a small town, and a poor family there was no way I could ever compete. I cycled everywhere, as that was the only way I could get around. I would even ride to nearby towns 40 miles away, just to see if I could; alongside a 2-lane highway. Cycling was how I explored my world. Computers & books fed my mind, cycling fed my heart and my insatiable wanderlust. But even with all the freedom that a bicycle gives you, that traditional diamond-frame upright bicycle limited that view to 4 feet infront of the bike. The uncomfortable hunch, bent neck, and numb genitals was a labour of love that while freeing me to explore, still left me shackled to a narrow view of the world. Riding a recumbent opened that view into a panoramic vista. This is now the 3rd age of biking, electrically assisted cycling. The more people that try it, the more people will want to do it. It is fun in a way that awakens the inner glee that only comes from childhood. There will always be 'purists' that believe that the way they suffer is the only "real way to do it". You don't have to suffer. Embrace the evolution, and enjoy the ride.
- justsomeuser 4y agoDo you not feel vulnerable to unfocused drivers lying down? When riding a normal bike, I feel safer knowing I can quickly abandon the bike and dive to the side if needed.
- UI_at_80x24 4y agoI ride a Longbike SlipStream and my 'seat height' is slightly taller then most sedans. That puts me a little above eye-level of most drivers. Here's a random GIS that kinda gives the perspective: https://ebent.files.wordpress.com/2006/05/slipstream_panniers_tent1.jpg https://ebent.files.wordpress.com/2006/05/slipstream_pannier... So my bike isn't of the 'laid down' variety. It is harder to do a shoulder-check when changing lanes. "Abandon the bike and dive to the side" is not an option. But, I don't ride in those kinds of traffic conditions either. When I was in university I rode in Toronto. That city is so hostile towards cyclists that I had cars TRY to hit me; intentionally try to run me off the road, and worse. I never needed to dive off my bike there either. I wouldn't ride my recumbent there unless I could stick to dedicated and secure lanes.
- timonoko 4y agoIn the 1980's I drove 3 times coast to coast North America, because it was so bicycle friendly. You never saw any other bicycles, except kids and fatties. So motorists were very careful. There were no bloody bicycle lanes, so could you do any speed you want in the middle of the road. Compare this to Netherlands and Deutschland were bicycle lanes are narrow, bumpy and with pedestrians with dogs in leash. And the polize and motorist force you to use them no matter what. I even found out that there are sections of the Interstate you can ride on a bicycle, when there is no other roads, like east of Palm Springs. Only one problem: People were so unaccustomed to seeing bicycles on the road, that they tried to give me a ride. And of course in Texas I was threatened with a guns because illegally sleeping on someones precious dirt. In sane countries "illegal threat" is an actual and most severe crime.