4 ms·
Proposed law allows federal government to lie about public records' existence
- DanielBMarkham 15y agoSounds like they're already doing this. This would just make it official. Also interesting is that the change is just a "rule change," not a proposed law. That means that if the rule change takes effect, information could be restricted further without the legislative branch having anything to do with it. It's just the executive alone, completely deciding what to release and what not to -- and now being able to lie about it to boot. I find it amazing that such a proposed rule change could even be suggested. The inmates are truly running the asylum. Just to recap, if a federal official asks you a question, it's a felony to lie to them. But if you ask them a question, they want the ability to lie to you as a matter of course. Amazing.
- JoachimSchipper 15y agoIt's not just lying to the public - in one case, they lied to a judge handling a FOIA request case (to be clear, the article does not suggest that this would be legal under the new rule): > In a recent case brought by the ACLU (...) the FBI denied the existence of documents. But the court later discovered that the documents did exist. (...) [the] Judge (...) wrote that the “Government cannot, under any circumstance, affirmatively mislead the Court.” It's pretty clear that a select few documents should not be released. It's much less clear that they should not even be released to the judge.
- cma 15y agoMeanwhile, it is illegal to lie to the US Government even in matters not relating to crimes: http://www.overcomingbias.com/2011/09/we-ban-lies-to-officials.html http://www.overcomingbias.com/2011/09/we-ban-lies-to-officia...
- 0x12 15y agoThe scary thing to me really is that I no longer find stuff like this astonishing.
- tptacek 15y agoWhat are the rules about this in the Netherlands? Are they better than our current FOIA rules?
- 0x12 15y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_information_legislation#Europe http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_information_legislat...
- tptacek 15y agoSection 10 1. Disclosure of information pursuant to this Act shall not take place insofar as: a. this might endanger the unity of the Crown; b. this might damage the security of the State; c. the data concerned relate to companies and manufacturing processes and were furnished to the government in confidence by natural or legal persons. 2. Nor shall disclosure of information take place insofar as its importance does not outweigh one of the following: a. relations between the Netherlands and other states or international organisations; b. the economic and financial interests of the State, other bodies constituted under public law or the administrative authorities referred to in section 1a, subsection 1 (c and d) and subsection 2; c. the investigation of criminal offences and the prosecution of offenders; d. inspection, control and oversight by administrative authorities; e. respect for personal privacy; f. the importance to the addressee of being the first to note the information; g. the prevention of disproportionate advantage or disadvantage to the natural or legal persons concerned or to third parties.
- ajross 15y agoSo basically just as large an opening as in US law. The specific notion of "deny the documents exist" isn't covered here, though I'd guess that would be the spirit of the law as you quote it.
- ck2 15y agoThey can already hide information despite the freedom-of-information act. The way they do it is to charge an absolute fortune for the records. Happens all the time: http://pogoblog.typepad.com/pogo/2011/10/gsa-wants-113k-to-tell-you-what-it-think-of-ipads.html http://pogoblog.typepad.com/pogo/2011/10/gsa-wants-113k-to-t...
- danso 15y agoYeah...but at least in that case, you can argue with the agency and publicize the outrageous request. I've done that in one instance where a city agency argued that it would take 40 hours and thousands of dollars to run a query to generate a simple payroll listing. After we threatened to write about how their payroll system was in such a sorry state that it takes thousands of taxpayer dollars to run queries against it, they handed over the data for a couple hundred dollars. This avenue of inquiry does not exist if an agency is allowed to just say: "Sorry, that doesn't exist."
- ck2 15y agoHere's the thing though - all the data should already be available as a free database, just like all NASA photos are public domain. Then let people mine it on their own dime for waste. The problem is they'd react to this by finding ways to make more and more stuff "classified" to claim it cannot be released.
- jacobgraham 15y agoNYC would appear to be a shining example of this: http://www.nyc.gov/data http://www.nyc.gov/data
- tptacek 15y agoHow would a city agency take advantage of this particular rules change? It specifically does not give FOIA respondents the blanket privilege of denying the existence of documents.
- tptacek 15y agoAnd, what appears to be the context ProPublica (a source I generally like; I'm a civil libertarian) and more especially the submitter has stripped out: (2) When a component applies an exclusion to exclude records from the requirements of the FOIA pursuant to 5 U.S.C. 552(c), the component utilizing the exclusion will respond to the request as if the excluded records did not exist. This response should not differ in wording from any other response given by the component. And so now you're wondering what 5 USC 552(c) is: (1) Whenever a request is made which involves access to records described in subsection (b)(7)(A) and - (A) the investigation or proceeding involves a possible violation of criminal law; and (B) there is reason to believe that (i) the subject of the investigation or proceeding is not aware of its pendency, and (ii) disclosure of the existence of the records could reasonably be expected to interfere with enforcement proceedings, the agency may, during only such time as that circumstance continues, treat the records as not subject to the requirements of this section. (2) Whenever informant records maintained by a criminal law enforcement agency under an informant's name or personal identifier are requested by a third party according to the informant's name or personal identifier, the agency may treat the records as not subject to the requirements of this section unless the informant's status as an informant has been officially confirmed. (3) Whenever a request is made which involves access to records maintained by the Federal Bureau of Investigation pertaining to foreign intelligence or counterintelligence, or international terrorism, and the existence of the records is classified information as provided in subsection (b)(1), the Bureau may, as long as the existence of the records remains classified information, treat the records as not subject to the requirements of this section. By my reading, the three cases are: (1) Ongoing criminal investigations that could be disrupted by disclosure (2) Criminal records pertaining to confidential informants (3) Formally classified counterintelligence documents.
- JoachimSchipper 15y agoI am confused. Why is only FBI information out-of-scope? You guys have the CIA, NSA, DHS, smaller agencies, and local police forces that are likely to be involved if there is, say, a plot to blow up the statue of liberty, no? (Corrections are welcome; in particular, I'd imagine that the NSA spooks laugh in your face if you request their records.) (Also, "terrorism" tends to be uncomfortably broadly defined. Witness the PATRIOT act.)