3 ms·
You could build a completely different language with some of Rust's features, if you go back a few years before Rust 1.0 there are lots of possibilities, but wh
by tialaramex 4y ago
You could build a completely different language with some of Rust's features, if you go back a few years before Rust 1.0 there are lots of possibilities, but what I was getting at is that Rust itself is much more tightly wedded to the generics than many of the languages people associate with generics, a "Rust without generics" isn't Rust at all.
Even in C++ the generics are a later addition, Stroustrup's early 1980s language doesn't have generic types, templates were a proposal added to what would become the C++ 98 standard and the Standard Template Library presents generic types for containers in C++ years after the C++ language was first popularized.
- layer8 4y agoI don’t think we really disagree. I was originally reaponding to the claim by DANK_YACHT stating that a (statically typed) language can be successful without having generics as long as it has other sufficiently innovative features. As a “counterexample” I hypothesized a version of Rust without generics but with the borrow checker (arguably the innovative feature most decisive for Rust’s success) and argued that I would doubt that this version would have been very successful, exactly because its lack of generics (which I believe aligns with what you are arguing). I’m not sure if you’re arguing that this hypothetical scenario isn’t a valid counterargument to the original claim I was responding to.