4 ms·
Could you elaborate on some of what he got wrong? I found that the big problems with the book were errors of omission, with the book only talking about the way
by Symmetry 15y ago
Could you elaborate on some of what he got wrong? I found that the big problems with the book were errors of omission, with the book only talking about the ways that economic consensus supports government non-intervention, but ignoring the places where mainstream economic thought says that the government can safely be doing more. It always annoys me here in the US when Republicans act like they are the party blessed by economists, when most economists vote Democrat.
- nhaehnle 15y agoI would agree that most are errors of omission. The most obvious one is that he completely ignores the problem of collective action, for example when he talks about taxes. There are certain problems that private enterprise simply cannot solve for game theoretical reasons. A nice example is in this recent thread on HN on bicycle lanes: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3149320 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3149320 Here is an example of a different type of error, from the part on Minimum Wages: The first thing that happens, for example, when a law is passed that no one shall be paid less than $106 for a forty-hour week is that no one who is not worth $106 a week to an employer will be employed at all. There is plenty of empirical evidence against this from countries that actually have introduced minimum wage laws. Even worse, not having minimum wage laws perverts economic incentives. Here's an example. In Germany, people earning below a certain amount receive a basic subsidy from the state. It is a pitiful amount, but it allows them to pay the rent and survive. The problem is that this causes low-end employers to consciously pay their workers a ridiculously low amount, fully aware of the fact that their employees will receive additional income from the state. In effect, the government subsidizes employers that practice wage dumping. That is clearly inefficient. Now people react to this in two different ways. One camp says that the government subsidy should be abolished. But the latter is short-sighted, because society always pays somehow when people do not earn enough to make a living. Ideally, they pay via social safety nets, but if such nets do not exist, society pays in the form of increased black market employment and crime. The other camp (me included) argues that this abuse of the system should be prevented via a minimum wage law. That would cut into the employers profits, but there's nothing wrong with that. It also wouldn't eliminate jobs, because we're talking about low-end sectors where demand is highly inelastic anyway, such as cleaning services. Hotels will still pay for the cleaning service, even if it costs them twice as much.
- dantheman 15y agoI don't think that it's an error, in fact the argument he is making about minimum wage exists in a world without a state provided safety net. The main argument he is making in the book is that economics is a complex system and is hard, and that we always need to look at the forgotten man. Those that think policy decisions are simple - have a minimum wage or not - will cause a whole host of unintended side effects as your post describes.
- jeffdavis 15y ago"There is plenty of empirical evidence against this from countries that actually have introduced minimum wage laws." So you are saying that an employer would hire someone that only produces $96 worth of value per week for $106 per week?
- notahacker 15y agoPeople that only produce $96 of value a week would probably have been unemployed anyway; because theres no shortage of labour at the bottom end of the market companies would have been able to hire better staff at $96 per hour before the minimum wage, who would be worth retaining at $106 per hour. The correlation between wages and employee productivity is pretty loose.
- jeffdavis 15y agoSo you are arguing that there's nobody who produces a value of $1 - $105 per week? I would expect the correlation between wages and production to be much stronger at the low-income levels and for hourly positions. Regardless, it's what the employer thinks the employee is worth (or will be worth). If the employer doesn't expect at least $106+X dollars of productivity, they won't hire at $106. This is pretty basic microeconomics; supply and demand. Even if you're right that the first employee nets more than $106, that might not be true for the tenth one. The demand curve for employees is downward-sloping, right?
- notahacker 15y ago
- mnemonicsloth 15y agoRent Control. It's the Left's equivalent of Creationism.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]