5 ms·
Another only mildly disguised attack on democracy. > If you’re used to thinking that our democratic system is in bad shape, that can sound jarring. But she’s w
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
Another only mildly disguised attack on democracy.
> If you’re used to thinking that our democratic system is in bad shape, that can sound jarring. But she’s working in the tradition of what philosophers call “ideal theory”; the aim is to sketch out what a good system would be, assuming that everyone fully complied with its rules.
I'm used to thinking that democracy is in poor shape because rich and powerful people prevent it from spreading further.
Which seems appropriate for this topic. But instead of diving into that, this author seems to take as a fairly key element of their argument that people getting stupid rich and then doing government type stuff without democratic oversight is good because the obvious alternative, democratic governance is fundamentally broken.
I'll check out the book by Emma Saunders-Hastings, “Private Virtues, Public Vices: Philanthropy and Democratic Equality” as its arguments sound pretty sensible.
- itronitron 4y agoA good system needs to be resilient to people in power (the rule enforcers or sub-rule makers) not complying with the rules.
- throwaway2048 4y agoGovernments aren't the only people in power in modern America, billionaire (philanthropist or otherwise) hold as much or more power than any politician.
- gruez 4y ago>this author seems to take as a fairly key element of their argument that people getting stupid rich and then doing government type stuff without democratic oversight is good [...] Which part is bad? The "government type stuff" or the "without democratic oversight"? I agree that billionaires fielding their own armies/police forces would be pretty bad, but what's wrong with funding homeless shelters or schools? If I decide to volunteer at a soup kitchen, am I also "doing government type stuff without democratic oversight"?
- kodah 4y agoMost of the time people don't do stuff just to be nice, it's because they want something. When our needs/desires are met as well, we feel good. Philanthropers, especially of the political nature, are trying to shape society and if leading examples are anything to go by they're influencing society to be more dependent on them and see it as okay. That's what I took away from OP.
- naravara 4y ago> but what's wrong with funding homeless shelters or schools? You don't get to be fabulously wealthy without some of the second order effects of your wealth accumulation being unsavory. Generally speaking, these people will do things like run out competition, foster massive economic inequality, and perpetuate labor abuses to pad their bottom line and then buy the indulgences by doing a cosmetically "good" bit of philanthropy. But they probably could have done more good by doing their day job in a less exploitative way.
- ryandrake 4y agoTo me, the key downside of philanthropy is the "without democratic oversight" part. It's all fine when the billionaires are funding homeless shelters or schools: things everyone can agree are a public good. We are extremely lucky that guys like Bill Gates suddenly got a soft spot for fighting malaria after amassing their fortunes. But nothing exists to stop these billionaires from donating to causes against the public good. That's the problem. The public should define what "public good" means, not rich people. As inefficient as taxes/government is, at least the voters are theoretically in the driver's seat, and get to at least indirectly define public good through elected representatives. With philanthropy, we're simply letting a single wealthy demographic decide "this is public good, trust me bro", and the public can't vote out rich people if they disagree.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoBut that's not true. The people and the democratically-elected government are the ones that Define what qualifies as a charity. We have said through our Democratic process that these are good things. https://www.irs.gov/charities-non-profits/charitable-organizations/exemption-requirements-501c3-organizations https://www.irs.gov/charities-non-profits/charitable-organiz...
- User23 4y agoThe fundamental problem with democracy is, to not put too fine a point on it, that most people are idiots who really have no business having a say in how a city should be run, let alone a continental scale empire. You may see that as an "attack," but it's an observable pattern that has held everywhere and always in human history. Even the provably fair ancient Athenian method of sortition produced catastrophically inept governments. Meanwhile modern "democracy" is a propagandic plutarchy that observably prioritizes the interests of the plutocrats so highly above those of the general population that the latter have, effectively, no say whatsoever.
- terr-dav 4y ago>The fundamental problem with democracy is, to not put too fine a point on it, that most people are idiots who really have no business having a say in how a city should be run, let alone a continental scale empire. >Meanwhile modern "democracy" is a propagandic plutarchy that observably prioritizes the interests of the plutocrats so highly above those of the general population that the latter have, effectively, no say whatsoever. The former is a consequence of the latter. At least in modern times. Also don't forget that our notional foundations for democracy are rooted in a slave-society. I don't know how that's 'fair' unless you disregard the slaves. And of course most people have no business in running a government: most people have no experience governing! Most people are subjects in mini-dictatorships (employees of employers).
- jimmaswell 4y agoI think you absolutely need a few billionaires to undemocratically shake things up on their own once in a while. Push forward a new vision on rockets, transportation, satellite communication, etc. Government organizations can be too prone to stagnate or languish in design by committee otherwise, see NASA not doing much new in a long time and any city taking forever to get through its own red tape to build anything.
- nomdep 4y agoA pure democracy, a direct democracy, is no different than government though Facebook likes, everything becomes a popularity contest. You know, "Democracy is the worst form of government, except for all the others". "The people", as a collective entity, is extremely dumb, so I think that the faster the communication advances, the worse democracy has become.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoThat's why Switzerland is such a poor country and disappeared from the face of the Earth. The people who want you to believe other people are dumb and direct democracy is a bad thing are the ones benefiting the most from the current inbalanced form of government. I mean if you think the people as a collective entiry are extremely dumb, why would you want any form of democracy or even society at all? Also, I have bad news for you but reallisticly speaking unless you are the unlikely strong outlier the average person is you (and me).
- coastflow 4y agoAssume everyone in a population governed by direct democracy is not "dumb." Then, there is still a need for checks against what political scientist Alexis de Tocqueville called the "tyranny of the majority." From the United States National Endowment of the Humanities [0]: "In America, [Tocqueville] saw and praised a people who enjoyed an unprecedented equality of conditions and political and civil liberty without endangering order or prosperity. But he also saw and criticized the way white majorities supported the institution of slavery and the unjust treatment of free blacks and Native Americans. In fact, the greatest danger Americans faced was inherent in their treatment of unpopular minorities." "The power of the democratic majority arises from the fact that every individual is assumed to be competent to guide his own life and is politically the equal of every other individual. In this situation, the greatest legitimate power will always be with the majority." A lack of "intermediary institutions, [makes a country have] “no lasting obstacles” in the way of the opinions, prejudices, interests, and momentary passions of the majority and tends towards an unthinking despotism over unpopular minorities." [0] https://edsitement.neh.gov/closer-readings/alexis-de-tocquevilles-warning-tyranny-majority https://edsitement.neh.gov/closer-readings/alexis-de-tocquev...
- ouid 4y agoThere's a LOT of money to be made telling poor people that rich people are good. Given how much we have collectively been paid to find a good argument for enriching the rich, I don't find any of the arguments to be anywhere close to commensurately convincing, do you?
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoNo, but it doesn't have to be convincing if you're a kid and all your stories are about the daughters of authoritarian warlords aka princesses, or genetically superior Ubermensch aka Superheros.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]