56 ms·
Why not build tractors with treads, like a tank? The whole point of tank treads is to maximize the ground surface area that the vehicle weighs on.
by zozbot234 4y ago
Why not build tractors with treads, like a tank? The whole point of tank treads is to maximize the ground surface area that the vehicle weighs on.
- jacquesm 4y agoThat's been done: https://www.deere.com/en/tractors/row-crop-tractors/row-crop-8-family/8rx-410-tractor/ https://www.deere.com/en/tractors/row-crop-tractors/row-crop...
- MezzoDelCammin 4y agoexplained a few comments above - the question isn't that of direct pressure (that could indeed be solved by using tracks), but sub-surface pressure. Probably how the overall structure is held together and distributes weight in depth under the overall vehicle surface. In that sense, it would probably help making tractors more like ships...
- soco 4y agoOr like airships, floating above the crops and only touching it with the whatever devices are used... Fun aside, agricultural devices on rails are not uncommon, although definitely not for such large areas like a normal field (yet?).
- dotancohen 4y agoActually a dirigible fixture could probably reduce the weight on the wheels by an order of magnitude for (relatively) little cost. Assuming little maintenance for the dirigible fixture and reduced maintenance for the smaller drivetrain, this might actually make financial sense. But it would require a hanger for parking.
- usrusr 4y agoBut only for tasks that aren't limited by traction, unless you put mighty jet engines on that poor little airship for tilling.
- dotancohen 4y agoOf course, use the right tool for the job.
- adwww 4y agoThey do, and this is fairly common on vast machines like combine harvesters. However they are a lot more expensive to run and maintain - eg. just think about the additional moving parts and friction. Also it's possible they do different damage - the metal treads are not as forgiving as soft balloon tyres.
- supermatt 4y agoThey are (usually) rubber tracks.
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoIt's not the tracks that cost you. It's the idlers, sprockets, etc.
- supermatt 4y agoMy comment was is in response to metal treads causing damage...
- thatcat 4y agoIt's the pressurized air in the tire that reduces applied ground pressure from the vehicle not just the surface material.
- supermatt 4y agoNot sure why you are responding to my comment either... but what you are saying makes no sense to me. Obviously the pressurised air itself has mass, but I think its more to do with tyre deformation modifying the contact surface area. The air inside is just to distribute the load across the contact area.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 4y ago
- SiempreViernes 4y agoThis article considers stresses further down, where the load has already had a chance to spread substantially over a large are. Loosely speaking, at some depth it's the entire column of soil below that supports the weight of the machine, and piling on more weight will exceed the uncompressed strength from the column, and so it compresses to handle the load. The problem being that compacted soil is bad for plants ability to grow there.
- bluGill 4y agoOnly where it the tires travel (and a bit to the side), which is why one heavy tractor are still better than many small light ones doing the same job: the heavy tractors does a bit more damage to a small area, but the light tractors do a bit less damage to a lot more area.
- chiph 4y agoHere's Jay Leno driving a Case IH 620 QuadTrac. It's so huge it needed a police escort to be driven on the city streets https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Zh3OBxh8Po https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Zh3OBxh8Po
- marai2 4y agoWeighs 52000 lbs (26 tons)! But because of the surface area of the track puts down only 5 lbs of pressure (per square inch, I think).
- Dork1234 4y agoOnly 52000 lbs doesn't seem that impressive compared to other large machines: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Bud_747 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Bud_747
- bluGill 4y agoBecause treads are worse than tires for compaction overall. As a soils expert explained to me (phd in the subject), compaction is a function of weight, but the function is something like 0.2*(weight) (obviously it is more complex than that and depends on the exact soil type). Compaction happens only where the tires/treads touch the ground, and tracks touch a lot more ground when you turn so even though there is less damage across the field you lose all of that and more when you turn around. Not to mention tracks have to slide sideways to turn and that is bad for your topsoil.
- robonerd 4y ago> Not to mention tracks have to slide sideways to turn and that is bad for your topsoil. It's unusual and perhaps not suited to large tracked vehicles, but there is an alternative to using differential track speed for turning: track warping. Basically the vehicle bends the tracks one way or the other to induce a turn. The turning radius sucks though.
- ChrisLomont 4y ago>The whole point of tank treads is to maximize the ground surface area that the vehicle weighs on. The treads don't spread weight much more than the wheels - look at tank treads in practice - they are somewhat loose between wheels. Most treads are somewhat loose, meaning the tension in them is not enough to be supporting tank weight. The exist to provide traction when they catch uneven surfaces, where wheels perhaps no longer make contact. Their point is to allow the tank to catch on non-flat ground when things jut between the wheels. Treads allow grip on non-uniform surfaces. But most of the time the weight of the tank is completely on (only a few of) the wheels.