6 ms·
I think the reason is pretty clear - Western nations can be pressured and people can voice their opinion and protest their own government's actions. Only a lit
by refurb 4y ago
I think the reason is pretty clear - Western nations can be pressured and people can voice their opinion and protest their own government's actions.
Only a little over 30 years ago China rolled out its military and crushed its own citizens beneath tank treads, then denied the whole thing happened.
Public condemnation against China will do nothing, so Islamic countries don't even try. Plus I would throw in a bit of geopolitcal posturing in that 1) going against China might look a little too much aligning with the US and 2) not pissing off China keeps some sort of partnership with China and it's deep pockets open in the future.
- trasz 4y agoOnly a little over 30 years ago USA rolled out its police to blow up its own citizens, razing entire city block: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1985_MOVE_bombing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1985_MOVE_bombing. They didn't need to deny or cover up anything, obviously nobody got punished for this, because the victims were black. So, yeah, while the Western people can certainly voice their opinion, it's often because their opinion doesn't matter. ("According to an article in The Lancet, between 1980 and 2018, more than 30,000 were killed by the police", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lists_of_killings_by_law_enforcement_officers_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lists_of_killings_by_law_enfor...)
- refurb 4y agoDid you read your own link? The "Aftermath" section where several courts condemned those actions and awarded substantial awards to the victims. The City apologized. Independent commissions condemned the decision. Can you please list all of the acts of restitution that the Chinese government has done since 1989? Oh, and ignoring all that, you're posting an awful lot of whataboutisms. I count about 9 of them so far. What game are you playing?
- cies 4y agoWhile you are right, I think GP still has a point. Those responsible for the MOVE massacre walked from it. The broader point I think GP tries to make is: the west should not be so quick to point fingers, especially not while it's own fingers are covered in blood. The US likes to same "human rights violations" about other nations, but then commits many themselves every year, and claims to be above the The Hague court. I also believe the US has not right to use those terms while it is still misbahaving on such a large scale.
- refurb 4y agoSo you're suggesting that the US, since it's guilty of human rights violations, should just be silent when it sees others countries commit human rights violations? I think that's absurd. There isn't a country on this planet who hasn't committed some human rights violation in its past. By your logic, nobody should ever call out human rights violations...ever. A far better approach is to judge a country by its actions in totality. Yes the US commits human rights violations, but it also has courts where victims can seek restitution, a free press to talk about such violations, free elections where voters can choose leaders who work against human rights violations. To compare the US and China and say "well they're both guilty of the same sins" is, frankly, bizarre.
- glenstein 4y agoRight, that's classic whataboutism, and it uses an inch of U.S. abuses to sweep away a mile of abuses by China. Those things just don't exist in a logical relationship of justifying, absolving, or forbidding analysis of one another. Their relation, if there is one at all, would be an and relationship, not an or, and certainly not an xor. Even a person fully invested in talking about U.S. human rights abuses and categorically disagrees with the idea that China has ever done anything wrong, you would hope that such a person wouldn't try to use the one topic to derail the other.
- trasz 4y agoThis above has a name: "American Exceptionalism".
- glenstein 4y agoI'm not sure I understand, but I like to think I was actually making a full-fledged point about the fallacy of covering for abuses by ignoring them and pointing to other abuses. Do you disagree? How can I state that point to your satisfaction without you labeling it as American exceptionalism?
- trasz 4y agoAh, right, they apologised. That changes everything :-> What matters is that nobody - not a single one of perpetrators of a bombing organised by police, which killed five random kids, and this is ignoring reports of police shooting at survivors fleeing the fire - got punished. "The city" paid some (public) money, that's all. It's not whataboutism, it's showing that the claim that "public condemnation against China will do nothing" because of Tienanmen is terribly misleading: those same things happen everywhere, you're just assuming they are somehow fundamentally different there. Sometimes they are, but mostly not. As for the Chinese government: Chinese prime minister responsible for Tienanmen spent the rest of his life in house arrest. Can you imagine this happening in the land of the free?
- refurb 4y agoChina denies the event. They just removed a memorial statue in Hong Kong. Are you seriously arguing that response is better than the US? Never mind crushing a democratic protest and killing thousands is in no way comparable to police trying to execute an arrest of a small group.
- trasz 4y ago>China denies the event. It never ceases to amaze me how people still believe things like this. https://www.quora.com/What-do-Chinese-citizens-particularly-the-young-adults-think-about-events-such-as-the-June-4th-Incident-aka-the-Tiananmen-Square-massacre-when-information-around-it-has-been-so-heavily-censored/answer/Yiran-Chen-15 https://www.quora.com/What-do-Chinese-citizens-particularly-... > Are you seriously arguing that response is better than the US? Are you seriously not realising that you're making a huge assumption here? But please, tell me how putting the prime minister in house arrest for the rest of his life is a worse response than ignoring the whole thing altogether and not even pretending to prosecute. (Also: thousands? Estimates, eg Amnesty International, say few hundred up to a thousand; funny how those numbers somehow keep growing when it's about China and not US, isn't it?)
- refurb 4y agoChina just tore down a statue in HK commemorating the massacre. But your telling me your quora link tells me all is fine? Come on, your spending an awful lot of time defending a brutal dictatorship.