7 ms·
I don't necessarily want it to go away entirely, but the tax breaks should be abolished. It's particularly offensive to see the state and local tax deduction (m
by lmm 4y ago
I don't necessarily want it to go away entirely, but the tax breaks should be abolished. It's particularly offensive to see the state and local tax deduction (money that actually goes to help one's fellows in the ways they see fit, without being beholden to the whims of the "donor") capped while 503c "donations" remain an unlimited deduction.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThat’s funny, I feel the exact opposite for the same reasons. I think charitable donations are far better than taxes because the donors get to direct where the money goes and have say over its use. Those giving up their money are in the best position to ensure it is used towards the ends they want. I think direct oversight is a positive attribute and useful in ensuring the altruistic goals are effectively met. I also oppose local tax deductions despite standing to benefit greatly.
- lmm 4y ago"The ends they want" - as opposed to the ends the recipients want (as expressed through an admittedly imperfect democratic system) - is exactly what I object to. Most "donations" are made to advance a personal agenda at least in part; even when the donor sincerely believes they're doing what's best for people, that's usually a reflection of their personal politics and you'll often find other people believing the exact opposite. It's fine to fund personal causes, admirable even, but you shouldn't be given a tax break for it.
- solveit 4y agoWould you be happy with government-designed (so presumably democratic) tests and quotas for which charities get the tax breaks?
- daniel-cussen 4y agoYou know what could be good, these charities talk about stories, not their statistics. Maybe they could humanistically keep records of their stories, like use a good system for that, maybe part digital, but with paper, so they can be read. Like the complaints at Liga Chilena Contra la Epilepsia, they just have a Sugerencias y Reclamos book, which you can read (though they told me it is not for me to read). You can see for instance that they addressed one complaint they got a lot, which was the lack of cashiers, so in fact with their remodel five years ago they changed it completely so they now have up to 8 cashiers at a time, and short wait times. My favorite Chilean pharmacy, I'll repeat here the comment I left for that charity: "Un siete!"
- gruez 4y agoIsn't that already the case? You can't set up a charity to throw parties for yourself, for instance.
- lmm 4y agoYou pretty much can, if you can afford the O(1) legal costs to get it approved and set up. An "art museum" set up next door to the "donor" and open only by appointment with the "donor"? Perfectly legitimate according to the IRS.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> An "art museum" set up next door to the "donor" and open only by appointment with the "donor"? Perfectly legitimate according to the IRS. Source? Most fundraising events have a deductible and non-deductible portion of the ticket price because the IRS does not look fondly on such practices.
- lmm 4y agoThat's a start, but for me to be "happy" I'd want there to be similar level of accountability and safeguards from bottom to top. So those charities would need to be subject to the same kind of legal rules as a government agency - FOIA, equal protection clause, that kind of thing. And there'd have to be a similar culture of holding them to account. (Like, counterintuitively I'd be happier if I started seeing a lot more news reports of charities wasting funds, because that would suggest that reporters at least cared enough to investigate)
- jdminhbg 4y agoThis would be a more convincing argument if government assistance to the poor were in the form of some kind of UBI that its recipients could actually use as they wanted, rather than the current situation where it's a hodgepodge of social engineering programs filtered through layers of patronage jobs for administration.
- wolverine876 4y ago> it's a hodgepodge of social engineering programs filtered through layers of patronage jobs for administration Can you back that up? I know people who were in poverty and very much support many of those programs as lifesavers. It's wealthier people, who have no experience of them, who I see disparaging them. Also, the criticism is cliche - I haven't seen much evidence of it. While nothing is perfect, the civil service in most advanced countries, including the US, are not patronage jobs; they are protected from such hiring and firing corruption. I know civil servants and they did not get the job through patronage and take their public service and professionalism very seriously. It's very easy to smear all those people in a few words.
- jdminhbg 4y ago> very much support many of those programs as lifesavers That doesn't really address the issue though, does it? Food stamps are better than nothing, but they do not in fact allow recipients to spend the assistance as they see fit. It's fine to be in favor of social engineering programs, but it's not consistent to then complain that philanthropists' charity comes with strings attached. The government's charity does as well.
- wolverine876 4y ago> It's fine to be in favor of social engineering programs, but it's not consistent to then complain that philanthropists' charity comes with strings attached. The government's charity does as well. I don't know what you mean: This doesn't seem to fit the common definition of social engineering, or we could call stop lights and tax forms social engineering; so I can't say I'm in favor, against, etc. And 'strings attached' is much too vague, as everything has strings attached (e.g., legal requirements); the question is the degree and who the strings serve.
- gruez 4y ago>It's fine to fund personal causes, admirable even, but you shouldn't be given a tax break for it. How does this argument work for other deductions that also allow you to "fund personal causes"? For instance, the IRS allows you to deduct interest paid on student loans. I can get student loans to study anything I want, and doing so is arguably used to to advance my "personal agenda" (eg. getting a phd in economics so I can work in a thinktank). Should I be worried that the action was a "reflection of their personal politics" and therefore not get a tax break for it? Feel free to repeat this argument for other deductions that the IRS offers: https://www.irs.gov/credits-deductions-for-individuals https://www.irs.gov/credits-deductions-for-individuals
- lmm 4y agoYes, most deductions should be abolished. Payments to 503cs are one of the ones that take the most out of the public purse though, AIUI, since even the richest people don't pay a huge amount of student loan interest.
- wolverine876 4y ago> even when the donor sincerely believes they're doing what's best for people ... They are wealthy people who have no experience or knowledge of what people without wealth need.
- exlexer 4y agoTo be fair, that also describes a large portion of politicians.
- wolverine876 4y agoI don't agree. Politicians aren't perfect, but they hear from their constituents a lot, especially the unhappy ones.
- cherrycherry98 4y agoThis seems to assume that the government is benevolent, whereas private actors are not. I have come to view government programs with the perspective that they are intended primarily to benefit the politicians efforts to become reelected. They can claim to be saving the world, but with other people's money. Some good may come of these efforts but I don't view them as inherently virtuous. You argue that private actors let personal politics dictate how they direct their funds, if the alternative is allowing politicians to do so, I don't see how that is much better. I am perfectly content with private actors deciding how best to use their own money for philanthropic purposes. It leads to a more diverse set of approaches. If there are people that believe in one thing and others that believe the opposite they should both be allowed to fund what they think is right without a democratic majority stifling minority points of view. I do not have a point of view on whether it is worthy of a tax break.
- lmm 4y ago> This seems to assume that the government is benevolent, whereas private actors are not. Not so much benevolent as accountable. The government, for all its faults, has a huge edifice of checks and balances, and while the gears grind slowly they do limit how far astray things can go. A private 503c is a real wild west in comparison.
- barry-cotter 4y ago> Not so much benevolent as accountable. Remind me. Who was fired for Waco? Who at the CDC was fired for stopping the Seattle Flu Study from testing for COVID, or for banning commercial labs from testing for it while their own lab reported all samples as positive because of contamination?
- rufus_foreman 4y agoIf a charity to which I contribute does a single thing I don't like, I can decide to never give them another penny. If the government doesn't do a single thing I like, more than half my income still goes to taxes each year to fund the government (income, property, sales, etc.), and there is nothing I can realistically do to change that. Which one is accountable?
- analog31 4y agoI've thought about this in the context of charities, since the US is a highly charitable country, with popular distrust of the government, yet is relatively impoverished compared to some other advanced countries. From the viewpoint of the beneficiaries of charity, who I presume are the poor, do they tend to be better off in countries where they are heavily supported by private charity, or in countries where taxes pay to support generous public institutions?
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI think this is a faulty premise. The US is actually quite heavily taxed, at a level greater than most of the OECD and many European countries, Especially in nominal dollars collected, but also as a percent of GDP, or when adjusting for local costs (PPP). In the US, when you add federal, state, and local revenue, about $8.3 trillion dollars are collected in taxes and fees. The GDP of the US is $20 trillion, so 40% of every dollar produced goes to the government. This is about $25,000 of tax per person, or $32,000 if you only count adults. My personal thought is that the main difference between the US and countries with generous public institutions is not the amount of tax revenue collected, but the percent of that revenue effectively spent on said institutions.
- gruez 4y ago>It's particularly offensive to see the state and local tax deduction (money that actually goes to help one's fellows in the ways they see fit, without being beholden to the whims of the "donor") capped while 503c "donations" remain an unlimited deduction. The point of charitable deductions is to incentivize certain types of behavior (ie. charitable donations). On the other hand the SALT deduction is effectively the federal government subsidizing high-tax jurisdictions at the expense of low-tax jurisdictions. The first seems far more defensible and in line with the federal government's mission[1], than some sort of mechanism to pad the finances of certain states. This doesn't necessarily exclude redistribute policies by the federal government entirely, but doing it by tax rate is baffling no matter how you look at it. [1] and no, this argument doesn't work for the SALT deduction because state/local taxes aren't optional
- Spooky23 4y agoNot really. Flyover and southern states in particular mooch off of the productive locales. So not only do I need to pay more taxes for the US government to fund almost double my states pro rata aid to places like West Virginia and Mississippi, but I get to pay even higher taxes because my locality actually provides things like sound education. You know what, I think we should exercise the people’s desire for small government and relocate military bases to the places that pay for them.
- gruez 4y ago> Not really. Flyover and southern states in particular mooch off of the productive locales. Addressed in my original comment (although it was edited in a few minutes after initial posting so I'll let it slide): >This doesn't necessarily exclude redistribute policies by the federal government entirely, but doing it by tax rate is baffling no matter how you look at it.
- anamax 4y ago> I get to pay even higher taxes because my locality actually provides things like sound education. Which your area benefits from....
- ars 4y agoThe tax break is only around 20% of the donation. Even if the donated money is not spent as perfectly as you would like, there's 5 times as much of it.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoExactly. You would have to believe that taxes do 5x more public good per dollar than charities. With defense spending, pet projects, and incompetence, it is hard to make a case that they are on parity.
- mercutio2 4y agoHuh? My marginal tax rate is ~45%. I get way more than a 20% benefit from 501c3 donations. I get to avoid capital gains on the donation of appreciated assets on top of that. For whom is the benefit only 20%?
- ars 4y agoLong term capital gains tax is 15%. The vast majority of these are against capital gains, not income.
- lmm 4y agoThe tax break for SALT works exactly the same way, no?
- vmception 4y agodonations aren’t limited, they are capped via a % the salt is called via a $ different political things, but the salt cap was a punitive thing purely for you to have resentment about where you live, it’s interesting that instead you got resentment for non profits republicans want you to have resentment at high tax states run by democrats, so that you consider regime change in that state