9 ms·
I have resigned all my positions in ISO C++ in protest
- torstenvl 4y ago> In particular this would include me -- as while black out drunk I was subject to a graphic homosexual encounter for which I could not consent. I don't know the backstory, and I don't know OP, so I want to be careful and clearly state that I am not minimizing or in any way commenting on the facts of his case. However, the statement above is dangerously wrong from both a legal and a biological standpoint, and needs to be debunked. Any forensic toxicologist will tell you: the point of alcohol intoxication which interferes with forming long-term memories is lower than the point at which one cannot consent. Exercising poor judgment while drunk and later having a spotty memory of it does not mean you were a victim. Consenting to something when you're black out drunk is still consent. If you exercise poor judgment about having sex and later can't remember, it does not mean you were sexually assaulted. If you exercise poor judgment about buying more shots and later can't remember, it does not mean the bartender stole from you. If you exercise poor judgment about driving and later can't remember how you got home, you and you alone are still responsible for your decision to drive drunk. The neurobiological capacity to make decisions and the neurobiological capacity to form long-term memories are not identical. Conflate them at your own peril.
- toomuchtodo 4y ago> Consenting to something when you're black out drunk is still consent. This is not at all true. You don’t have the capacity to consent if you’re black out drunk.
- torstenvl 4y ago
- toomuchtodo 4y agoYou’re being pedantic (“black out drunk doesn’t mean you can’t consent”). If you want to be specific, which based on your profile you would want to be, the exact terms are “evidence of the victim's mental incapacity or defect is admissible to prove that consent was not intelligent, knowing, or voluntary.” (Florida state statute 794.022(4) specifically as an example)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- michaelmrose 4y agoThe legal and moral notion of consent to sexual activity isn't and logically driven by your brains ability to form memories or actuate voluntary motion. For someone to give consent they have to have sufficient higher function to make a reasonable judgement. If you fuck someone drunk off their ass because they can move and respond you probably morally and legally raped them in at least half the nation. For example in California https://properdefenselaw.com/drunk-sex-rape-in-california-cal-penal-code-section-261a3/ https://properdefenselaw.com/drunk-sex-rape-in-california-ca... New Jersey https://www.brickdonlaw.com/blog/2021/january/how-drunk-is-too-drunk-to-consent-to-sex-/ https://www.brickdonlaw.com/blog/2021/january/how-drunk-is-t... The fact that some states will let you get someone drunk enough to be stupid in order to get into their pants isn't a good reason to do so.
- torstenvl 4y ago> The courts in California have found the following conduct shows that someone was too intoxicated to consent . . .passed out at some point or had trouble walking on their own . . . agreeing that the victim needed to “sleep it off” . . . vomiting . . . vomiting and hit the wall. Notably absent is alcohol's effect on long-term memory. Drinking to the point of impairing long-term episodic memory (BAC of 0.08-0.15) is not the same as drinking to the point you cannot consent.
- michaelmrose 4y agoDrinking to the point of impairing memory would seem at best impair judgement and ensure the person has no way to discern whether they consented or not. I see no reason to treat that as valid consent millions of people in the states live in states that wouldn't. Morally respecting partners rights costs you nothing.
- namecheapTA 4y agoI have a video friends took of me, that I don't remember entire HOURS of before and after. In the video you can clearly see I am happy drunk but you couldn't get me to consent to things I didn't want IMO. Im not some confused lump ready to be taken advantage of, yet I lost all memory of that 4th of July BBQ. Plus, beyond my anecdote, the guy above posted research. Do we not believe in science anymore?
- michaelmrose 4y ago>Do we not believe in science anymore? You are confusing posting a link with winning an argument. The problem is people have fundamental moral and legal disagreement about what constitutes consent with poster asserting it has to do with ability to make decisions and others including lawmakers in multiple states holding it rests in not being sufficiently impaired to severely degrade ones decision making ability. It's impossible for the posters link to resolve this divergent understanding.
- namecheapTA 4y agoNo doubt people throw their own emotional arguments into things that have been researched with 1000x rigor compared to their internal hunches.. it doesn't mean it's right. People's entire lives are derailed when they drink and get in a car and get caught for a DUI. The fact that we prosecute people, fine them amounts greater than some people's entire savings, throw them in jail, make them loose their jobs... For deciding to get into a car after 5 drinks. But if you decide to sleep with someone after 5 drinks, you were taken advantage of and that person should be prosecuted. In one case we give no sympathy for being drunk, and in the other we treat you like a child.
- ncmncm 4y agoI had a housemate, back when, who went out every weekend and got drunk because she considered that the only way to get sex. Whoever she bonked was invariably equally drunk. Did she rape him? Did he rape her? Did they rape one another? Afterward, neither might be sure what actually happened, but both knew that whatever happened was what they went out for. Going to that bar and getting that drunk was something each chose to do while still sober, exactly like everybody else there. So, was every last patron of that bar raping somebody every weekend?
- bowsamic 4y agoYes, any sexual activity that happens when the mind is not totally sober is rape
- ncmncm 4y agoEach was raping the other? Then, why were cops not there arresting everybody as they showed up? There was no secret about what they were doing, on a regular and predictable schedule. Such bars certainly still exist.
- bowsamic 4y agoJust because bars where people get drunk and have sex exist does not mean they are legal
- quantified 4y agoThat's a bit on the strict side. Lot of sex being enjoyed with cannabis now. And between people who have relationships beyond the one-night stand.
- bowsamic 4y agoHow are you supposed to actually assess the drunkness of another when the consequence of getting it wrong (or the other person claiming you get it wrong) is that you are accused of rape? I think for this reason sex in general is not a worthwhile risk for most people
- vintermann 4y agoWhether you are blackout drunk or not should not be the dividing line, because you can be terribly impaired without having blackout, and you can have blackout without being terribly impaired. It's not in general possible to tell if someone will have blackout. I think it's important to understand that alcohol only slows your thinking, it doesn't "change your personality" or make your thoughts or wants go places they otherwise wouldn't. All that is socially learned. The drunk you is you. If you state consent as drunk, it's because you want to. In practice, though, blackout is a terrifying experience, and for all the blacked-out person knows they were completely unconscious during what happened. So they can't be faulted for fearing they were abused. And so, for your sake and theirs, you should NEVER have sex with anyone if there's the slightest chance they have blackout, i.e. if you can tell they are drunk at all. This is an easy rule to follow, and I have very little sympathy with people who can't.
- Latty 4y agoYour post implies you think that being able to say the word yes and being able to consent are the same thing, which is frankly worrying. The obvious example is children can say yes, but they cannot consent. This isn't new or surprising.
- michaelmrose 4y agoPurportedly the individual unnamed herein was "convicted of rape and possession of Child Sexual Abuse Imagery in 2011" https://patricia.no/2022/03/08/proposed-cppcon_safety__transparency_report.html https://patricia.no/2022/03/08/proposed-cppcon_safety__trans... Purportedly a "moderate" risk to reoffend
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- antiquark 4y agoThis reddit thread might be informative: https://www.reddit.com/r/cpp/comments/t9klju/this_is_troubling/ https://www.reddit.com/r/cpp/comments/t9klju/this_is_troubli... My question would be: if someone commits a crime, then is punished for that crime according to the law... does some form of punishment have to continue once they're released from prison. That's what seems to be happening here.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sp332 4y agoI don't think it's about punishment. [Edit] they're not asking for the other person to be kicked out or anything. They just don't want to be forced to interact personally.
- antiquark 4y ago"Current abusers" or "ex-abusers"? They seem similar, but they're different.
- sp332 4y agoI don't think it would work to force people to use a certain metric. They have to be free to avoid whoever they want to avoid, or else they will self-select out of the community, as happened here.
- tragictrash 4y agoConvicted of rape and in possession of CSAM is all that matters to me. They're going to want to re-offend for the rest of their life. Maybe they will, maybe they won't. Either way we should destroy the individual. https://patricia.no/2022/03/08/proposed-cppcon_safety__transparency_report.html https://patricia.no/2022/03/08/proposed-cppcon_safety__trans...
- bluefirebrand 4y agoI think the logic is always along the lines of "If they did it once, they are probably capable of doing it again. Is society obligated to give them opportunities to do so" If you strongly believe prison is for rehabilitation, you probably want to give people plenty of chances. If you strongly believe prison is for punishment, then likely you give people few chances and want their crimes to follow them forever. The best approach is probably neither extreme but something more balanced with a case by case appraisal based on risk.
- im3w1l 4y ago> I have resigned all my positions in ISO C++ in protest of the decision to use CoC anti-discrimination rules to protect a duly convicted registered level 2 sex offender. > it was made clear by several members of my national body that avoiding this person is discrimination of an ex-felon It's a complicated balance to strike between reintegrating ex-felons, and the justified fear other people have that they will be victimized. Edit: Just mean I really don't envy the people forced to deal with this. Really a no-win situtation.
- planarhobbit 4y agoIt’s perfectly well within the rights of this individual to resign, without Reddit/HN getting into a spat about whether the individual’s justification meets some loose standard. I do think this particular tweet is very concerning. See if you can follow this train of thought: > While I empathize with any ex-felon's right reintegration, I empathize more with past or potential victim's right to do their jobs amongst people who haven't fallen short of one of the lowest moral bars in society. Choosing one side must exclude the other. How does this make you feel? Do you agree that “Choosing one side must exclude the other”? Is this an applicable statement to make in this context?
- sp332 4y agoI think so, because the person just wanted to nominate a replacement for themselves so they could be recused and avoid this other person. The job would still get done and both people would still be connected to the community while avoiding each other personally.
- bluefirebrand 4y ago> How does this make you feel? Do you agree that “Choosing one side must exclude the other”? Is this an applicable statement to make in this context? This seems straightforward to me. We are talking about people who have been victimized by another person, and may have a great deal of trauma from that event. We likely wouldn't question it even slightly if they said they could not work with their abuser. Working with someone who was convicted of performing the same (or similar) abuse on a different person wouldn't be too much different from that I don't think.
- Barrin92 4y agoI don't think it makes sense to say you support the right to reintegration and then argue that the idea of 'potential future victims' is enough to remove someone from a job. Anyone can be a potential future victim following that logic, so this person could never really be integrated at all. I think sex offenders elicit emotional responses in these discussions and that the position isn't tenable at least for someone who purports to favor reintegration. I'll pick a particularly thorny and controversial example but I think it's necessary. Imagine a member of a minority group with a background of severe violent crime spoke at a conference, he went to prison and served his sentence. Now someone attending says they don't feel save with him in the room and that the person should never hold an administrative job again. What would be the response to that?
- nullbytesmatter 4y agoIt's a tough position to be in. I think the CoC is fair in that you shouldn't discriminate the ex-felon. You can't refuse to work with someone because of something they have done in the past and paid for (with jail, presumably). You are a part of something and have a job to do. That job entails working with people (even if you don't like them due to something they have done, their race, gender, sexuality, or whatever). Do your job, or quit. He quit.
- olliej 4y agoIt is reasonable for a victim of a crime to request that they not be forced to work with someone who committed that crime. Discrimination is a problem when it is not proportional to what is being subject to scrutiny, and when it is outside the realms of something that can be controlled by the person. In this case the discrimination is minor - not working with the person - and it was the specific actions of that person that lead to the situation. What you’re effectively doing is trawling the tolerance paradox. It’s often used by people who are extremely intolerant to prevent anyone from shutting them down, and it is important to be aware of when you are allowing one party to say that any response to them other than wholesale acceptance is discrimination.
- _carbyau_ 4y agoThe thing here is "paid for (with jail, presumably)". In this case, society has effectively said the crime will not ever be "paid for" because the person is on a Public List for Life. Few crimes in society have this result.
- quantified 4y ago"Society" is malleable. These registries are recent, and may be discarded. And "society" is different from place to place. Homosexual behavior, and consuming cannabis, were likewise barred from society too. The scarlet letter was for adultery but society has downgraded the penalty for that. The subject matter here involves the sharpest reactions most people are prone to, I think, so most people involved here may agree with "society" on this one.
- yes_really 4y agoThe ironic thing is that James Damore was fired from Google for publishing a milquetoast memo on gender distribution in tech, yet the convicted felon (and registered level 2 sex offender) is being protected from "discrimination". I'm not saying that the ex-felon should be rejected, but it's absurd that people and institutions had so much vitriol against Damore for his memo, yet are just ignoring the ex-felon.
- bsnal 4y agoIt’s not ironic. It’s the system working as intended.
- ryan_lane 4y agoDamore's memo was an example of an employee actively discriminating against other employees. It showed that he couldn't be trusted in a position of power, and in general, at companies like google, every engineering position has some amount of power (via 360 reviews, interviewing, etc). He hasn't apologized for his actions, or withdrawn his viewpoints. He still can't be trusted. The ex-felon paid their debt to society by serving the punishment they were given and deserve another chance. You could argue that maybe their sentence wasn't long enough, or that there should be some period after release that they should be held for certain activities, but it's reasonable to have a policy to not discriminate against their status, so they have the opportunity to prove they've changed.
- AdhemarVandamme 4y agoYou are judging Damore not by his words, but by how his memo got misrepresented. At no point in his memo, Damore indicated that he would discriminate or called for discrimination against other employees. He did advocate to end affirmative action (“Stop restricting programs and classes to certain genders or races”), but that is not the same as advocating for discrimination. It is the opposite, in fact. In his reply to public response and misrepresentation, Damore did write: “I value diversity and inclusion, am not denying that sexism exists, and don’t endorse using stereotypes. When addressing the gap in representation in the population, we need to look at population level differences in distributions. If we can’t have an honest discussion about this, then we can never truly solve the problem.”
- yes_really 4y agoIt's honestly bizarre that there is such a thing as a "sex offender" register. It seems it comes much more from a desire to further punish people than to actually protect the population. I would be much more afraid of an ex-felon convicted of murder than of an ex-felon convicted of having sex with a 15 year old. Yet it's the latter that gets put into a register. There have been men that were added to the register for urinating in public, and now their lives are ruined because of some stupid laws and politicians praying on people's paranoia against "sexual predators".
- giraffe_lady 4y agoMurderers don't tend to be uh, murder aficionados, as it were. They usually want to kill a specific person for a specific reason and once that is done they are done. It may indicate a certain lack of self-control that could be dangerous to be around, but there is a lot of study of this. People convicted of murder and later released have relatively low recidivism rates (eg committing any crime), and very very rarely ever commit another murder. People who commit sex crimes, more than most other categories of transgression, tend to do it multiple or many times, and they follow certain patterns of escalation. Someone who has committed a sex crime is fairly likely to do it again, or do similar or worse things. I'm not arguing in favor of life-long registries or retributive justice at all. But the practical experience with different categories of crimes don't always match our intuition about what sorts of people are dangerous, and that may warrant treating different crimes differently after the fact as well. And then mostly unrelatedly, the "sex offender registry for urinating" thing is largely a myth you hear on the internet. The registry is public so you can and should go check it for your area just to get an idea. You may need to look up some unfamiliar legal terms, for example in my state there is no charge of "rape" only "aggravated sexual battery." Around me and in most places I've lived, the vast majority are for unambiguous violent sexual crimes, or crimes against minors under age 13. Simple exposure and "it was a month before her 18th birthday" are what you hear about on the internet but are actually quite rare.
- mecha_ghidorah 4y agoI actually did a tour of a now closed gaol and our tour guide talked about how back when it was running the inmates working in the kitchen that were given the knives tended to all be murderers because typically murderers aren't especially violent in a general sense. Compared with people who are locked up for assaulting strangers they were way less of a risk
- encryptluks2 4y agoThis is a difficult situation, but in terms of technology I think it is rare to get talented people into the development pool. I would hate to exclude people based on something unrelated to their talent alone. However, safeguards should be put into place to ensure that people are not being excluded based on their fear of those individuals either. I wonder if there is a way to ensure all interaction is public so that there is not any accusations that would not be of public record.
- NameTheProblem 4y ago
- Ekaros 4y agoIf we go route to exclude people what level of standard we apply? Anyone who ever received fine for anything is potentially dangerous and harmful to society individual and no one should be forced to work with such monsters?
- ratbeing 4y agoRelated consequence at LLVM, which is changing their policy: https://discourse.llvm.org/t/upcoming-project-policy-changes/62637 https://discourse.llvm.org/t/upcoming-project-policy-changes...