4 ms·
Dunning sets a rather high bar for human discourse here, which comes across as gatekeeping snobbery. People can't have opinions on what they think nanotech wil
by kazinator 4y ago
Dunning sets a rather high bar for human discourse here, which comes across as gatekeeping snobbery.
People can't have opinions on what they think nanotech will bring, without becoming experts in it first?
As if that would even help? Knowing everything about nanotech won't give you a crystal ball which informs you about how the future will pan out with regard for how much it's used for good or evil.
Can't some pessimist just voice his or her pessimistic concern about nanotech without reading several texts about it and taking two semesters? At least, if he or she knows it's just an opinion of concern and not presented as an informed fact?
Over a pint of beer, I cannot posit that the purpose of an anus is the elimination of waste, because evolution isn't sentient and didn't articulate such a design intent for the orifice? Or at least, not without it then being assumed I'm a complete idiot who thinks evolution is creation?
Isn't that a rather narrow definition of "purpose"; can't there be a kind of purpose which is emergent, so that when we use the word, we don't mean something was designed by a sentient being? It just fell into place and happens to serve an identifiable role in a system. If it was removed from the system, then such and such a deleterious consequence would come about, and therefore it has a "purpose" (emergent sense) of preventing that calamity.