2 ms·
But if they have no means to support them then they will. and as a result you traumatize everyone in that family for life. So because they aren't receiving an
by em-bee 4y ago
But if they have no means to support them then they will.
and as a result you traumatize everyone in that family for life.
So because they aren't receiving any financial assistance for shelter, food, and clothing then they will rely on having a partner. We have now incentivized that type of behavior.
no, you haven't.
how do you think this works? all you are doing is forcing people to stay in relationships that are not healthy. do you think people separate because they got bored? they separate because they can't support each other. but you are forcing them to stay together, which creates environments ripe for abuse.
Adopted kids do great.
you were talking about an institution. and where are you going to find all these adoptive parents?
already now there are not enough of those.
we incentivize them to create a supportive environment
that's not what i meant by a supportive environment.
a supportive environment is a community that helps families who can't make it on their own.
We will teach them how. They will be so removed from their environment of shattering poverty, drugs, abuse, etc.
they will also be removed from the love of their parents, which is the most important thing that they need.
Or we can continue to double down on the same bad ideas we've been trying for the last 60 or 70 years
we could also look at how other countries do it, and listen to people and learn what they actually need to make this work for them.
The main difference is I'm actually trying to help the kids.
and i am trying to help the parents. so that they can actually take care of their kids themselves.
- nemo44x 4y agoI think all your ideas are great and I’d be all for them if they weren’t just completely unrealistic and ineffective. I grew up around those environments and was immersed in them. My experience as well as analyzing what we have done to “fix it” have led me to believe that a radical breaking of the wheel is necessary. And not only necessary but moral. It’s time to put kids first.
- em-bee 4y agoIt’s time to put kids first. this is where i have a problem. taking away kids from their parents is not putting kids first. unless the parents are outright abusive, in which case there are already mechanisms in place. what you are suggesting is not helpful. we do not need better individual academic performance but we need better relationships, so that people care more for each other and we can build stronger communities that can work together to improve everyones lives. taking away children from their parents hurts the ability of those children (and of the parents too) to make friends and form trusting relationships. which in the long term hurts the very fabric of society. already individualism is very strong, and it's becoming a problem. only as a united community can we solve our problems and build a better future.