4 ms·
please tell me you are joking. you want to punish people for having kids? do you think parents are going to give up their children willingly? what you are sug
by em-bee 4y ago
please tell me you are joking. you want to punish people for having kids?
do you think parents are going to give up their children willingly?
what you are suggesting sounds like brave new world. that's a horrible vision.
children growing up without their own parents is only going to make things worse. i do not believe that any form of institution is going to be more capable to raise children than natural parents.
your ideas work under the assumption that these parents are not capable of raising their kids. but that is not true, and that is not the problem.
the problem is that they have to raise their kids and make a living in an environment that is not supportive. pretty much any other country in the world is more supportive than the USA.
the big factor that you are missing is that we don't know if those children will be capable to have families of their own. my prediction is that they won't be because they didn't grow up in a family themselves. so this system will have to continue in perpetuity because the children of these people will also have to be raised in these institutions, and more parents are going to send kids to these institutions than parents from there who will be able to raise kids on their own. it's going to create a cycle that will end in a dystopia.
i was still with you when you said to disincentivize single parenting, but i thought you wanted to support families. you said it yourself: The #1 factor in determining if a kid will have a desired outcome is if they have a mom and a dad present.
what you are suggesting here is quite the opposite. children in institutions is not children with parents.
it smacks of hubris and arrogance. the assumption that normal people should be able to take good care of their kids without help and anyone who isn't is simply incapable and should not have had kids in the first place. that you know better than they do, and they should just submit to your authority.
brave new world indeed.
(UPDATED)
- nemo44x 4y ago> do you think parents are going to give up their children willingly? No, they won't want to lose their kids. But if they have no means to support them then they will. So because they aren't receiving any financial assistance for shelter, food, and clothing then they will rely on having a partner. We have now incentivized that type of behavior. Failing that, if they can't provide a safe environment for their kids then we will take the kids out of the home. We do this today. We could altar the civil rights act to include children in these situations. > children growing up without their own parents is only going to make things worse. Adopted kids do great. It's about structure and predictability. > your ideas work under the assumption that these parents are not capable of raising their kids. Correct. All the evidence says they are not capable. > the problem is that they have to raise their kids and make a living in an environment that is not supportive. Correct - as stated above we incentivize them to create a supportive environment or we will create one for their kids. > the big factor that you are missing is that we don't know if those children will be capable to have families of their own. We will teach them how. They will be so removed from their environment of shattering poverty, drugs, abuse, etc. They won't even recognize that world and will be disgusted by it. They will learn how to be productive people that can not only take care of themselves but can care for others. These are learned behaviors. One of the reasons we have generational poverty is because bad habits are passed down. The cycle never gets broken. > children in institutions is not children with parents. Institutions are a surrogate. > it smacks of hubris and arrogance. the assumption that people should be able to take good care of their kids without help and anyone who isn't is simply incapable and should not have had kids in the first place. that you know better than they do, and they should just submit to your authority. Or we can continue to double down on the same bad ideas we've been trying for the last 60 or 70 years. Talk about hubris and arrogance! The main difference is I'm actually trying to help the kids. Not create government dependent parents that will vote for me because I get scraps sent their way.
- archagon 4y agoThis is the same kind of thinking that lead to the abduction of Native kids, forced sterilizations, etc.: https://www.vox.com/platform/amp/2019/10/14/20913408/us-stole-thousands-of-native-american-children https://www.vox.com/platform/amp/2019/10/14/20913408/us-stol...
- nemo44x 4y agoNot really. What happened there was an attempt to destroy Native cultures and even reproduction. It's based on a racial trait. My ideas are to help kids from mothers that can't or won't provide an acceptable environment to grow up in have a chance to grow up in a caring, non-abusive environment that gives them the best chance to have a life. And hopefully reproduce and pass those values on to their own kids! :) I'm not saying it would be the best implementation, but the idea is to help kids. Not create a client of the state that will vote for a certain political party because they are helpless and dependent. I want to help people. Not hurt them and lie to myself and others and pretend I'm helping when I'm only serving my own agenda.
- archagon 4y agoWhy do you think the people who stole Native kids didn't want the best for those kids? It's just that in their case, they assumed that Native upbringing == bad parenting. (And I'm sure that the poverty/crime rate/etc. of those communities were also part of that rationalization.) > Not create a client of the state that will vote for a certain political party because they are helpless and dependent. I'm pretty sure there's no evidence bearing out that this happens to any significant degree. Moreover, people generally don't enjoy staying on welfare.
- nemo44x 4y agoI mean, we already pull a ton of kids out of abusive homes today. The difference is there has to be a case that the child is in an unsafe environment. In the case of Native kids it was simply their race. The problem today is the kids stay in or close to the negative environment. There’s no one to teach them. My idea is to simply close the loop and give them essentially boarding school. People may not enjoy being on welfare but the data shows that generational welfare is a thing.